Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Unlife on Card creation challenge

a few seconds ago

Hungry Slime

Creature - Ooze 1/1

Whenever Hungry Slime deals combat damage to a player, create a token that's a copy of Hungry Slime.

Whenever a creature dealt damage by Hungry Slime is put into a graveyard from play, put a +1/+1 counter on Hungry Slime.

Create a creature next

Eloniel on Feather Redeems Boros in EDH …

14 minutes ago

What about Rite of the Dragoncaller, Frontline Heroism and Divine Resilience ?

Divine resilience would be a reusable mass protection since it target.

Lionheart0115 on wolverine

22 minutes ago

Here's some tips to improve your deck. Id tone down your lands from 47 to 38-40 lands. Maybe add some bounce lands like Gruul Turf, Guildless Commons, Arid Archway fetch lands like Evolving Wilds, Terramorphic Expanse, Myriad Landscape, Mountain Valley, Wooded Foothills Prismatic Vista Ect. Theres's way more, but I aint gonna list them all off. That way you'll have more ways to trigger your landfall and in the case of fetch lands, thin your deck out.

Some random cards id look into possibly adding would be Fight Rigging, Bear Umbra Mutant's Prey, Ancient Animus, Pounce, Prey Upon, Pit Fight Boxing Ring Rancor, Alpha Authority, Sticky Fingers, Fireshrieker, Whispersilk Cloak ect

Most of my recommendations either give you access to -fighting (Which would trigger Wolverines +1/+1 counter trigger even when if its not your turn. That way you wouldnt have to rely on someone attacking you and blocking) -Double strike (Since Wolverine doubles damage without saying "Double Strike", He would go from a 2/2 that doubles damage so 4/2 effectively. To a 2/2 that attacks twice and doubles damage, so effectively an 8/2) -Protection (You want him to be really hard to kill even though he has regeneration, plenty of removal still has "This creature cant be regenerated" slapped at the end of it. So Aura's that make Wolverine either even harder to target or respond to before he mops the floor with your opponents the better.

JustJohn97 on Pauper Lands

56 minutes ago

Hi!

Truthfully I've never played a lands deck, but in general when deckbuilding and cutting cards I would start with those that would be the most difficult to cast or have limited upside. How easy do you find it to cast Deprive? If you feel getting to double by turn 2 is inconsistent that might be a place to start. Also it seems like you're playing at sorcery speed anyway when ramping. Do you feel like holding up countermagic is typically better than just playing Explore? If so you may want to go with the Growth Spiral in your maybeboard over Explore because that allows you to hold up interaction on your opponent's turn and still ramp if they don't cast anything worthwhile.

If you find yourself not able to take full advantage of your creature etbs, that could mean either take away some etbs or add more ways to get lands into your hand depending on which way you want to go with it.

If for example you removed 4 Deprive and one Crop Rotation, you now have 5 extra slots to put lands into your hand, so you could add additional Winding Way or possibly Mulch.

Alternatively there are creatures like Floriferous Vinewall or Gatecreeper Vine if you would prefer to have an earlier presence rather than focusing on card quantity. Although admittedly these creatures are only there to block 1 power creatures.

The deck looks fun though!

KayneMarco on Eye for an Eye Damage …

1 hour ago

I have a deck similar to this except I’m in mardu colors. Just wanna offer a few suggestions from my list that would definitely fit in here.

I have a bunch of other similar card ideas that fit the theme as well but I’ll stop here for now. If you wanna hear the rest of them let me know. +1ed

markbeloit on Card creation challenge

1 hour ago

Dark Tendrils

Instant

Choose one —

• Target player reveals their hand. You choose a nonland card from it. That player discards that card.

• Dark Tendrils deals 3 damage to target creature.

Entwine (Choose both if you pay the entwine cost.)


Make a card.

OldTrees on Yarok Grind

1 hour ago
Testing swapping
Reanimate (2)
1x Coiling Rebirth
1x From the Catacombs
Flash (1)
1x Valley Floodcaller
Life (1)
1x Platinum Angel
Tutor (2)
1x Nylea's Intervention
1x Archdruid's Charm
Draw (1)
1x Interpret the Signs

for 
# Mana Multiplier
1x Dictate of Karametra
1x Boundless Realms
1x Awakening
1x Reshape the Earth
1x Seedborn Muse
# Flash
1x Leyline of Anticipation
1x High Fae Trickster

OldTrees on Yarok Grind

2 hours ago

The deck's thematic core (cards recycling) is card advantage so I can cut down on other card advantage cards. However I still need to get cards to the graveyard to make reanimation relevant.

Likewise I discovered it is very mana greedy. One way to handle that is with Awakening and Seedborn Muse (and other mana multipliers) as long as I keep flash and don't accidentally ramp out of theme range and into wincon range. Villainous Wealth costs 10+ mana but is not a concern. Exsanguinate costs 22+ mana. So I want to ramp to 10-15 mana rather than to 20+ mana. A single doubler should be fine and I will have higher prioritizes than finding another doubler (probably avoid Nyxbloom).

Reminder, tutors and recusion can help lower the card count for specific effects. Dictate of Karametra + Awakening might be the smallest multiplier package I could run.

Craeter on Hit 'em with a rat …

2 hours ago

<3 rats

Since you're running more than 1/4 of the deck of Relentless Rats, I'd highly recommend you include a Thrumming Stone along with a couple staple Black tutors

RobertButler23 on "Show and Tell"

2 hours ago

The way I've seen other people run decks like this are more streamlined. I would take out a few time stretch and dream halls because of how efficient atraxa and maelstrom wanderer are and replace them with some countermeasures.

bvowles on Pauper Lands

3 hours ago

Thanks for the suggestions! I really like Winding Way especially. Ghostly Flicker I'm not as sure on, but you're absolutely right it would work really well with Coiling Oracle and Archaeomancer, but if I added both I'd turn this into a more familiars type of list with your suggestions and cut back on the lands.

In testing on modo I've found that I almost have too many additional land effects in the deck, so I guess I could start there when looking to fit in Winding Way at least. Do you have any suggestions on cards to cut? It feels tight even though I'm still brewing around with it. While I said earlier that I may have too many additional land effects in the deck, Arboreal Grazer gives me great ground game against red.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Had to drop him to 0/1 because I forgot basic snow lands are a thing XD

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Zygoth, The Indomitable

Legendary Snow Creature - Elemental

Snowwalk

Zygoth, The Indomitable gets +1/+1 for each snow permanent you control and has Ward where X is the number of snow permanents your opponents control.

Landfall - Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you may put a snow counter on target permanent. It becomes a Snow type in addition to its other types.

0/1


Wild

PuritanPuree on Urtet, Mastermyr

3 hours ago

I plan on making an Urtet deck of my own one of these days, so I love seeing them. Distant Melody is a fun, affordable card for kindred decks that spit out lots of tokens.

griffstick on Card creation challenge

3 hours ago

Im sharing this deck that's totally alters. I'm sharing it in hopes that you guys have good suggestions as to what to add. Please take a look and make suggestions. I'm about %50 done with the alters. Thank you guys. Deans car collection

legendofa on Card creation challenge

4 hours ago

Temple Mosaic

Artifact

Clerics and Knights you control have vigilance.

: Target Cleric or Knight you control gets +0/+1 until end of turn.

: Temple Mosaic becomes a 2/2 Knight creature in addition to its other types until end of turn.


Create a Legendary Snow Creature - Elemental.

biggestmtgnerd on Why Did the Story Stop …

5 hours ago

The closest I could think of to a modern, explicit, in-lore reference to color is on Tarkir, the Jeskai speak of “soulfire,” “bloodfire,” “mistfire,” the forbidden “vitalfire” and “deathfire,” and the elusive “ghostfire.” Those seem pretty obviously like the color pie plus colorless.

Abaques on I'm semi-giving up magic

5 hours ago

How about Gale, Waterdeep Prodigy and Candlekeep Sage? Run blink and bounce effects as control that's not too heavy that also gets you a lot of value.

jani_01 on Jarad, Golgari Lich Lord

6 hours ago

I would suggest one of my pet cards - Grim Flayer. Seems like great value in this nasty build. :)

Neotrup on Does card:General's Regalia and card:Jade …

6 hours ago

No. Each replacement effect can only apply to an event once. You can bounce the damage back and forth as many times as you like because each activation will create another replacement effect, but Furnace of Rath will only apply to the event of Ancient Tomb dealing damage once, no matter how many times you change where that damage is being dealt.

Balaam__ on List of card draw from …

6 hours ago

Sounds great. Glad to be of service!

Noxid05 on List of card draw from …

6 hours ago

Balaam__ Wirewood Savage is great! Don't know how I missed that on gatherer searches

I have been debating adding in sections for enchantment creatures as well as artifact creatures. I think I might start though now, and I'll add Argothian Enchantress under enchantment creatures.

Balaam__ on List of card draw from …

6 hours ago

Argothian Enchantress and Wirewood Savage might qualify for inclusion under the Tribal subcategory. Not sure how prevalent Enchantment creatures and Beasts are in EDH, but maybe somebody might find them useful.

Noxid05 on List of card draw from …

6 hours ago

Balaam__ Not quite, Beast Whisperer like effects are what I am focusing on. I am going to add Cryptbreaker to the maybeboard though because you could use it to turn every third zombie spell into a Beast Whisperer like effect. Prophet of Distortion's card draw is an activated ability that you have to sink mana into and isn't tied to casting creatures.

Noxid05 on List of card draw from …

7 hours ago

Balaam__ I was not including cards like Baleful Strix, trying to focus on the cards that you can get repeatable draws off of. Thank you for the suggestion though!

freezerboy on Does card:General's Regalia and card:Jade …

9 hours ago

This is a little complicated because I run Zirda, the Dawnwaker, but say I have a General's Regalia, Furnace of Rath and Jade Monolith in play with a bunch of mana free. Something I own deals damage to myself like tapping a Ancient Tomb, and I redirect it to one of my creatures like Boros Reckoner, can I then tap 1 each time the damage is redirected to keep exponentially increasing the damage till I shoot a player for lethal?

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

9 hours ago

Field Ox

Creature - Ox

(no text, it's vanilla)

5/5


Hey a 5/5 for 3 ain't that bad

Wild

TheoryCrafter on The Writing’s on the Wall

9 hours ago

If you're looking to put some extra flavor to this deck, Wall of Runes would be an option.

Happy Hunting!

BotaNickill on Miirym and Friends

10 hours ago

VerbotenViper, Thanks so much for the comments and suggestions. I'll poke around my collection and see if I have all of those. I know I have some Birds laying around here somewhere, and I probably have the other cards too. Now I just have to decide what else to cut from the list!

Bookrook on Card creation challenge

11 hours ago

Sheep of sacrifice

Creature-sheep

When this card enters, draw a card.

When you sacrifice this card, create a food token for each boar, ox, sheep, or goat you control.

Escape-, exile a card from your graveyard, sacrifice three foods.

1/1

Make a vanilla for this deck.

Gleeock on I'm semi-giving up magic

12 hours ago

I've been slowly selling off the "collection" as well, getting out of buying new toys, & just playing a few decks I am happy with. So a couple of pointers that have been good for me on my remaining decks that I rarely get out to play:

1) Randomized but impactful effects, to guarantee you always end up playing a different game. Higher budget examples: Etali, Primal Conqueror  Flip, Breach the Multiverse

2) Par down your color pie. Your mono example is not for me, but it does run in-line to this idea. This is a great opportunity to sell off a couple of specific-color staples & get rid of that WUBRG land base (if you had all that).

3) Valgavoth, Harrower of Soulsfoil not really control.. But IMO groupslug, done right, can be fun for your opponent specifically because you are NOT controlling their gameplay. Though, if you wanted Rakdos control suite, you can find a few cards that will accomplish that while drawing you a card.

4) Play off opponent's topdeck will not mess with their hand/limit resources. If you make a deck that does this, you have less need to "stay caught up/enfranchised" because you are as "caught up" to MtG as your opponents' are with this deck. This will be impactful, but always play differently (good qualities if you play infrequently). Eg. Rakdos, the Muscle

moo1234 on Card creation challenge

12 hours ago

forgot power and toughness my guy is a 2/4

moo1234 on Card creation challenge

12 hours ago

Old farmer Barrett

Legendary Creature - Human Peasant

Goats, Oxes, Boars and Sheep you control get +2/+2

Whenever a goat, ox, boar or sheep you control dies create a food token.

Sacrifice a goat, ox, boar or sheep you control: Create a treasure token

"He's a farmer"


THere are just not enough good ox, boar, sheep or goat cards to make a good commander deck around this fella, and arguably the best ox is red (Ox of Agonas). There's Pathbreaker Ibex which is a banging card as well and of course the immensely powerful Yoked Ox.

Make a mythic rare white or green ox, goat, sheep or boar that might help pad out this deck.

fuzzking123 on grixis midrange test

14 hours ago

needs updating haven't played in a while list some upgrades if you know of some

polydamas on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

14 hours ago

https://cards.scryfall.io/large/front/4/3/4311bea6-a65c-4c1b-9596-797cc3410eb7.jpg?1729216631

polydamas on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

14 hours ago

Terror of the Peaks is missing its promo

DreadKhan on I'm semi-giving up magic

15 hours ago

I'd suggest Kresh the Bloodbraided if you're limited to one deck, it can be dirt cheap and Kresh often gets hilariously big. You don't have Blue control, but Jund is awfully good at removing problems, arguably more efficiently than Blue control. More people are fine playing against Jund control than Blue permission, so you might avoid 'do you have something else?' coming up right away.

Another option might be Sisay, Weatherlight Captain, this can be incredibly 'samey' between games, but if you have several lines of wildly different power included it's possible to make a Sisay list that is fun vs a huge range of decks. I have a Progenitus in my Sisay list, so it technically has a huge terrifying monster I can fetch out if I want. If you want a more control heavy option you can lean into Hatebears with Sisay, she's a cEDH level Commander that often uses Rule of Law to great effect.

I have a deck built around each if you want some ideas.

miqualmedanis on The Chitter-Chatter(Fang) of So Many …

15 hours ago

i totally understand needing to put a hold on some cards for the sake of how expensive they are lol. in my case chatterfang is the only deck i have that would be able to use parallel lives or doubling season which i already had so they got slotted in. i got lucky a while ago pulling an old gnawbone which is the only reason ive got him in there too. the idea that you dont want to help your opponents with yavimaya makes sense, but i suppose that also comes down to your playgroup. ive only got a few friends i play with and only one of them runs a green deck. at that point yavimaya doesnt really do anything for him anyway cuz its a landfall deck and he's got his mana fix figured out immediately anyway.

Seuchenschutz on The Queen's Egg

18 hours ago

Hi, how about playing Lands, like Path of Ancestry or Sliver Hive? You could as well play The First Sliver, with is also a great commander in my sliver deck. What I really like in 5Color Sliver Decks is Bring to Light, it will get you any Sliver you need, including the 5 Colored Sliver Legends or even removal or a Patriarch's Bidding.

Spam8338 on "3 Slugs!" - Linda

19 hours ago

Update 11/14/24: - Traded out Sad Robot (solemn simulacrum) for Jeska's Will. Jeska's Will is more explosive, you can get immediate mana and cards wehre as sad robot land enters tapped adn card draw when he dies. Jeskas will can choose ramp or card draw - or both if the commander is on the field

  • Traded out mountain for Shinka, the Bloodsoaked Keep , gives access to first strike for on red mana and does not enter tapped.

orih25 on Card creation challenge

19 hours ago

Naya Cataclysm

Sorcery

Each player loses 3 life. Any player may sacrifice a creature. If they do, repeat this process.

"Wilt."


Make a tribal legendary creature that isn't part of the chosen tribe.