Time Walk

Tinker

Balance

Demonic Tutor

Survival of the Fittest

Fastbond

Necropotence

Mirari's Wake

Time Walk - Easy win.

Tinker - Gave it a slight edge.

Balance - Although Bribery is an awesome card, Balance out shines it by a land slide. Literally.

Demonic Tutor - Not even close.

Survival of the Fittest - Thought about this for a while and realized that this could be savagely abused by many different decks.

Fastbond - This was an awful matchup. Fastbond would kill Moat in any game. Not sure how Moat even made it to Round 2, let alone Round 1.

Necropotence - Quite an amazing match-up! This was a very tough decision, but I gave the edge to Necropotence for the fact that you can use it's ability as many times as you want, where Sylvan Library , is only at your Draw step, still an awesome card, but Necropotence got the edge.

Land Tax - I thought this was an odd match-up but still had to give it to Land Tax for all those times where mana is the only thing you need to start winning. Mirari's Wake is cool, but Land Tax is to hard to pass up.

Thoughts: I think the Sorcery and Enchantment brackets will come down to the following in the final round with the winners being:

Time Walk vs Balance = Balance

Necropotence vs Fastbond = Necropotence

@Human_Rogue_21, you think that Balance is better than Time Walk , why?

Sorceries:

1 Time Walk

2 Tinker

3 Balance

4 Demonic Tutor

Enchantments:

1 Oblivion Ring

2 Fastbond

3 Sylvan Library

4 Land Tax

It's just my opinion. I think Land Destruction is cooler than Extra Turns. I will be happy if either of them win because they are both undoubtedly great cards.

Time Walk

Tinker

Bribery

Demonic Tutor

Survival of the Fittest

Moat

Sylvan Library

Mirrari's Wake

• Time Walk
• Tinker
• Balance

• Demonic Tutor

• Survival of the Fittest

• Fastbond
• Necropotence
• Land Tax

1. Time Walk no contest
2. Tinker
3. Balance simply has the edge
4. Demonic Tutor
5. Oblivion Ring some of the best removal in the game
6. Fastbond No contest here
7. Necropotence
8. Land Tax

1. Time Walk
2. Armageddon
3. Briber
4. Demonic Tutor
5. Survival of the Fittest
6. Fastbond
7. Necropotence
8. Land Tax

• Yawgmoth's Will : no contest. I'd rather do everything twice in one turn than once over the course of two turns.
• Tinker : no contest. I'd rather tutor a wincon than blow up everything in defense.
• Balance : no contest. I know I'm going against what I just said, but you shouldn't pay more than 3 for a tutor.
• Demonic Tutor : I sound like a broken record, but no contest. Actually, my justification for picking Tinker works here perfectly.

• Survival of the Fittest : no contest. I'm a combo player; I'd rather tutor than remove.
• Moat : Meh, I don't landramp.
• Necropotence : no contest (You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means). Pay 2 life for 2 cards, or pay 8 life for 2 cards. Also, black wins.
• Land Tax : Both cards are kinda "meh" in my opinion, but at least Tax has a legacy.

1. Time Walk wins because one of the early playtest versions of the card said "opponent loses next turn"
2. Tinker wins because it makes the game end in a much more exciting way
3. Balance wins because it's one of my favorite cards ever
4. Wrath of God wins not just because it's powerful and I like it, but also because time has shown it to have been an inherently good and balanced design

1. Oblivion Ring wins because it can do so many more useful things
2. Fastbond wins because it's a more exciting card
3. Necropotence wins because it's another one of my favorite cards ever
4. Land Tax wins for pure power reasons

Yawgmoth's Will / Armageddon / Balance / Demonic Tutor

Survival of the Fittest / Moat / Necropotence / Land Tax

Sorceries:

1. Time Walk is the best magic card ever.
2. Tinker is one busted card. Turn 2 Blightsteel Colossus is really dumb.
3. Balance is really, really unbalanced.
4. Demonic Tutor puts a CARD in your HAND. For 2 mana.

Enchantments:

1. Survival of the Fittest is really good.
2. Moat is just the business.
3. Sylvan Library is really cool, and because Necropotence is unfair and dumb, yeah.
4. Land Tax is super sweet.

SORCERIES

(1) Time Walk

(6) Tinker

(14) Bribery

(2) Demonic Tutor

ENCHANTMENTS

(1) Survival of the Fittest

(4) Moat

(5) Sylvan Library

(7) Mirari's Wake

Time Walk

Armageddon

Balance

Demonic Tutor

O-Ring

Fastbond

Sylvan Library

Land Tax

Can I just say, I'm really wish I could be voting for Hymn to Tourach and Fireball here? Anybody else missing either of these as much as I am?

Timewalk

Armageddon

Bribery

Wrath of God

Survival of the Fittest

Moat

Necropotence

Mirari's Wake

Also gonna whine that I can't vote for Shared Animosity . There, done. I think.

Wait, Natural Order isn't in here either? Powerful too. That's my favorite sorcery. Sorry guys, got a late start on this forum.

Sorceries:

1. Time Walk
   
2. Tinker
   
3. Bribery
   
4. Demonic Tutor
   

Enchantments:

1. Oblivion Ring
   
2. Fastbond
   
3. Necropotence
   
4. Mirari's Wake

1) Time Walk

2) Tinker

3) Balance

4) Demonic Tutor

1) Survival of the Fittest

2) Moat

3) Sylvan Library

4) Land Tax

Sorceries

1) Yawgmoth's Will
2) Tinker
3) Balance
4) Demonic Tutor

Enchantments

1) Survival of the Fittest
2) Moat
3) Necropotence
4) Mirari's Wake

Sorceries

1. Time Walk - Tough match, down to personal preference
2. Tinker - It wins games. There's a reason why it's banned
3. Balance - Another tough match, but it's better to play a card that gains power from your deck instead of your opponent's, imo
4. Demonic Tutor - Why hurt yourself when you can just hurt your opponent?

Enchantments

1. Oblivion Ring - Could be personal preference, but this wins by a large margin for me. Jace, the Mind who?
2. Moat - Infinitely more frustrating and more fun to play with than Fastbond , which is broken in the right deck. No one ever accuses Moat of being broken.
3. Necropotence - No fight
4. Land Tax - One of the few white ramps, and for only 1 mana

Time Walk

Armageddon

Balance

Wrath of God

Oblivion Ring

Fastbond

Necropotence

Wake or tax...tough call...but you know what they say. the only sure things in life are Death and Land Tax

Yawgmoth's Will

Armageddon

Balance

Demonic Tutor

Oblivion Ring

Fastbond

Necropotence

Mirari's Wake

1. Time Walk
2. Tinker
3. Balance
4. Demonic Tutor
5. Oblivion Ring
6. Fastbond
7. Necropotence
8. Land Tax

1) Time Walk

2) Tinker

3) Balance

4) Demonic Tutor

1) Survival of the Fittest

2) Fastbond

3) Necropotence

4) Mirari's Wake

Sorceries:
Time Walk
Tinker
Bribery
Demonic Tutor

Enchantments:
Oblivion Ring
Moat
Necropotence
Mirari's Wake

Yawgmoth's Will

Tinker

Balance

Demonic Tutor

Survival of the Fittest

Fastbond

Necropotence

Land Tax

Time Walk: not really all that close, considering this is what most constructed matches are about.Armageddon: While tinker is fairly strong, ld is a favorite of mine.Balance: As badly as I want to vote for bribery, this isn't really all that closeDemonic Tutor: Also not close, finds an answer to any specific situation, not just creatures like WoG.EnchantmentSurvival of the Fittest: Broken beyond all get out, against the fairest card on the list.Fastbond: Gush bond is a real thing, makes this one also not all that close.Sylvan Library: Beats Necro because you don't get sylvan locked like you can get necro locked. Also triple black really hurts.Land Tax: Repeatable shuffle effects are super powerful, this one is no exception,

1. Time Walk
2. Tinker
3. Balance

4. Demonic Tutor

5. Survival of the Fittest

6. Fastbond
7. Necropotence
8. Mirari's Wake

1. Time Walk b/c booo graveyard shenanigans.
2. Armageddon good luck getting that tinker out with out any lands
3. Balance both cards are terribly wordy.... so when in doubt of ties due to horrid wordyness go w/ the non blue one.
4. Demonic Tutor hardest matchup so far... but i went w/ it b/c it finds stuff!
5. Oblivion Ring killing things rather than some wordy green bs card.
6. Moat strong defense and did you see the number of words on that green card?
7. Sylvan Library both rediculously wordy but i hated a lot of wordy green cards so far so it gets the nod.
8. Land Tax cuz ramp in white why not!

Sorceries:

1. Yawgmoth's Will , For Stupidness (and fun)

2. Tinker , also for stupidness

3. Balance to Even the odds...

4. Many wraths exist, but You can't exaxtly replace the one True Demonic Tutor

Enchantments:

1. Survival of the Fittest , it says it in the name.

2. Fastbond wins the race just barely.

3. Necropotence , Maralen of the Mornsong , Amarite?

4. Mirari's Wake , RampRampRamp...

Time Walk : Duh.

Tinker : SO broken

Bribery : I love edh...

Demonic Tutor : One of the best black cards of all time.

Survival of the Fittest : Repeatable creature tutor???

Fastbond : TIMMY OVERLOAD

Necropotence : Someone please explain to me why this isn't banned in EDH yet.

Land Tax : Can be used in more decks, great acceleration early game.

Yawgmoth's Will because I'm aparently a huge fan of upsets.

Tinker , because it's less unfun to play against.

Bribery because I dislike LD.

Wrath of God gets the job done.

Oblivion Ring Spot removal is so good. SOO GOOD

Fastbond was involved with the first combo deck I'd ever seen.

Sylvan Library is neat.

Mirari's Wake is a bloody powerhouse in Commander.

1. ...Fine, Time Walk can have a vote from me.
   
2. Tinker - Wreck this fun, Armegaddon.
   
3. Bribery , I choose you!
   
4. Demonic Tutor - Anything you want, including dead guys in thongs.
   -------
   
5. Survival of the Fittest - That is one unhappy Mogg.
   
6. Fastbond - I think it's been well proven that players will gladly pay life and bits of string for better mana.
   
7. Necropotence - If one's going to pay the life anyway...
   
8. Land Tax - There's something about mana fixing and emptying my deck of dead draws at the same time that I just can't turn down.

1) Time Walk

2) Armageddon

3) Bribery

4) Demonic Tutor

1) Survival of the Fittest

2) Moat

3) Necropotence

4) Mirari's Wake