Daily Dose 58 - Standard
Daily Dose of Standard
KrazyCaley
20 May 2013
1369 views
Community Matchup!
20 May 2013
1369 views
Community Matchup!
Bolas for a Better Tomorrow
Standard*
SCORE: 107 | 506 COMMENTS | 23119 VIEWS | IN 42 FOLDERS
vs.
Esperanimator
Standard
SCORE: 4 | 3 COMMENTS | 494 VIEWS
Piloted by Elaine, her comments in bold.
Game 1
Caley wins the toss and plays first. He keeps an opening hand of Island, Watery Grave, 2x Dreadbore, Chromatic Lantern, Counterflux, and Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker.
Risky, but very good if I draw that third land.
Elaine keeps a hand of 2x Hallowed Fountain, Island Terminus, Supreme Verdict, 2x Unburial Rites.
Just need to get some creatures in the graveyard.
C1
C plays Watery Grave tapped.
E1
E draws Dimir Charm. She plays Hallowed Fountain tapped.
C2
C draws Island and plays it.
E2
E draws Glacial Fortress. She plays Hallowed Fountain tapped.
Also need black mana, thx.
C3
C draws Drowned Catacomb. He plays it and casts Chromatic Lantern, then passes.
E3
E draws Hallowed Fountain. She plays it tapped and passes.
At this rate I'm just going to be CASTING creatures.
C4
C draws Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker. He plays Island and passes.
E4
E draws Godless Shrine and plays it untapped. (C 20, E 18). She passes.
Curious that she played it untapped. Too early for a Sphinx's Revelation. She has something instant speed with black mana in it, but what could it be?
C5
C draws Barter in Blood and does nothing. End step, E casts Dimir Charm targeting her own library.
Oh, ok, this is a reanimator deck.
E puts Forbidden Alchemy and Dissipate into the graveyard, and Thought Scour into hand.
E5
E draws Snapcaster Mage and plays Island.
C6
C draws Counterflux and does nothing. End step, E flashes down Snapcaster Mage, but C Counterfluxes it. Then E casts Thought Scour on herself, milling Detention Sphere and Forbidden Alchemy, and drawing Plains.
E6
E draws Forbidden Alchemy. She casts Unburial Rites on Snapcaster Mage, targeting and casting Thought Scour. E mills Plains and Hallowed Fountain and draws Angel of Serenity. She passes.
Man, terrible luck.
C7
C draws Mountain and plays it. He casts Dreadbore on Snapcaster Mage and passes.
E7
E draws Lingering Souls and plays Plains. She casts Lingering Souls, but C Counterfluxes it. Then she flashes it back and gets two 1/1s.
C8
C draws Staff of Nin and casts it. He immediately destroys a 1/1.
E8
E draws Forbidden Alchemy. She attacks with the 1/1 and hits. (C 19, E 18).
C9
C draws Counterflux and Murder. He does nothing. E casts Forbidden Alchemy in the end step, keeping Nephalia Drownyard and tossing Thought Scour, Isolated Chapel, and Glacial Fortress. He blows up the remaining 1/1 with Staff of Nin.
E9
E draws Detention Sphere. She plays Nephalia Drownyard.
C10
C draws Watery Grave and Swamp. He plays Swamp, casts Bolas, and destroys Godless Shrine. In response, E flashes back Forbidden Alchemy, keeping Drowned Catacomb and throwing away 2x Glacial Fortress and Sphinx of Uthuun.
E10
E draws Angel of Serenity. She plays Drowned Catacomb, then flashes back Unburial Rites targeting Sphinx of Uthuun, but C Counterfluxes it. Then E casts Detention Sphere on Bolas.
C11
C draws Sulfur Falls and Dragonskull Summit. He plays Sulfur Falls. Then he casts Bolas and E concedes.
Too much. Way bad luck on the milling.
Sideboarding
E boards out 2x Supreme Verdict and 2x Terminus and boards in 1x Jace, Memory Adept and 3x Duress.
C boards out 3x Mystic Retrieval and 3x Think Twice and boards in 2x Grafdigger's Cage, 3x Slaughter Games, and 1x Curse of Death's Hold.
Game 2
E is on the play and keeps a hand of Godless Shrine, Hallowed Fountain, Watery Grave, Island, Lingering Souls, Duress, and Dissipate.
C keeps a hand of Mountain, Swamp, 2x Drowned Catacomb, Sulfur Falls, Murder, and Slaughter Games.
E1
E plays Watery Grave untapped. (C 20, E 18). She casts Duress and eliminates Slaughter Games.
C1
C draws Grafdigger's Cage. He plays Swamp and passes.
E2
E draws Island. She plays Hallowed Fountain tapped.
C2
C draws Grafdigger's Cage. He plays Mountain and casts Grafdigger's Cage, then passes.
Well, crap.
E3
E draws Thought Scour. She plays Island and casts Lingering Souls, then passes.
C3
C draws Liliana of the Veil. He plays Drowned Catacomb and passes.
E4
E draws Drowned Catacomb. She plays it and attacks with her spirits. Caley tries to Murder one of them, but E Dissipates it. (C 18, E 18).
C4
C draws Dragonskull Summit and plays it. He casts Liliana of the Veil and uses her -2 ability to kill a spirit.
E5
E draws Godless Shrine and plays it tapped. She attacks Liliana with a spirit, sending Liliana to the graveyard.
C5
E draws Drowned Catacomb and plays Sulfur Falls.
How high's the water, mama?
End step, E casts Thought Scour, milling Hallowed Fountain and Duress and keeping Snapcaster Mage. Then she casts Snapcaster Mage.
E6
E draws Dimir Charm and plays Island. She attacks with a spirit and snapcaster. (E 18, C 15). She casts Dimir Charm at C's library, throwing away Counterflux and Drowned Catacomb and putting Mountain on top.
C6
C draws Mountain and plays it.
E7
E draws Hallowed Fountain and plays it tapped. She attacks with snapcaster and spirit. (E 18, C 12).
C7
C draws Barter in Blood and casts it, killing everything. C plays Drowned Catacomb.
E8
E draws Sphinx of Uthuun. She plays Godless Shrine tapped and casts the Sphinx. The Sphinx reveals Swamp, Watery Grave, Sphinx of Uthuun, Forbidden Alchemy, and Unburial Rites. C puts the Sphinx in one pile and the other cards in another. E selects the Sphinx and trashes the rest.
C8
C draws Island. He plays Drowned Catacomb.
About six feet high and risin'.
E9
E draws Nephalia Drownyard and plays it. She casts Sphinx of Uthuun, revealing Sphinx's Revelation, Isolated Chapel, Plains, Thought Scour, and Angel of Serenity. C puts the angel in one pile and all other cards in another pile. E throws away the angel and keeps the other cards.
This ordering makes sense because I need to buy a lot of time.
E attacks with the Sphinx and hits. (E 18, C 7)
C9
C draws Murder. He immediately Murders a Sphinx.
E10
E draws Drowned Catacomb and plays it. She casts Thought Scour on C, milling 2x Gilded Lotus. E draws Plains. E attacks with Sphinx. (E 18, C 2).
C10
C draws Staff of Nin and concedes.
Sideboarding
No changes from either side.
Game 3
C is on the play and keeps 2x Swamp, Devour Flesh, Chromatic Lantern, Murder, Dreadbore, Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker.
E keeps Island, Glacial Fortress, 2x Sphinx of Uthuun, Forbidden Alchemy, Sphinx's Revelation, Unburial Rites.
C1
C plays Swamp and passes.
E1
E draws Glacial Fortress, plays Island, and passes.
C2
C draws Gilded Lotus, plays Swamp, and passes.
If your deck alternately floods you AND screws you, that's how you know you have the mana balance right. PROTIP.
E2
E draws Snapcaster Mage and plays Glacial Fortress.
C3
C draws Drowned Catacomb, plays it, and casts Chromatic Lantern, then passes.
Phew.
End step, E flashes down Snapcaster Mage.
E3
E draws Plains and plays it. She attacks with snapcaster. (E 20, C 18).
C4
C draws Counterflux. He casts Dreadbore on Snapcaster Mage.
E4
E draws Angel of Serenity. She plays Glacial Fortress.
C5
C draws Mountain and plays it, then casts Gilded Lotus. End step, E casts Forbidden Alchemy, keeping Detention Sphere and throwing away Lingering Souls, Glacial Fortress, Island.
E5
E draws Snapcaster Mage. She does nothing.
Black mana!
C6
C draws Counterflux. He casts Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker. Bolas blows up a Glacial Fortress.
Yes, YOU TOO can cast Bolas on four land using these three simple steps!
E6
E draws Forbidden Alchemy. She puts Detention Sphere on Bolas.
C7
C draws Staff of Nin and casts it.
E7
E draws Duress. She passes and discards Sphinx of Uthuun.
C8
C draws Dragonskull Summit and Murder. He plays Dragonskull Summit and passes.
E8
E draws Unburial Rites. She does nothing and discards Sphinx of Uthuun. [
C9
C draws Barter in Blood and Gilded Lotus. He casts Gilded Lotus.
E9
E draws Snapcaster Mage and concedes.
A little early, maybe, but mana screw is frustrating.
Never going to beat him stalling out for black mana while he builds a perfect hand with the staff.
Comments
Trashy games in 2 and 3. Game 1 was a little better, but even that one was plagued by bad luck for the reanimator deck. Not really a good look at these decks' performance.
That was a pretty slow-moving and unfun set of games. Not sure I have a lot to say about it other than it's good to have good draws?
FINALLY. I feel like I've waiting an eternity for the (not-so) Daily Dose. Always enjoy reading.
May 20, 2013 5:29 p.m.
Timekeeper says... #4
Doesn't Dimir Charm put two cards into the graveyard and one back on top of the library? At turn 5 of the first game, you made it sound like it puts that last card in your hand...
May 20, 2013 5:59 p.m.
KrazyCaley says... #5
@aeonblue - Sorry, I know it's been a while. Trying to increase the frequency, but I've got a lot that I'm trying to juggle. Stay patient.
@Timekeeper - That's what the notes said. Either we played it wrong, or else I recorded it wrong. Apologies either way.
May 20, 2013 6:10 p.m.
Timekeeper says... #6
It's just one small mistake, and it certainly doesn't appear to have affected the outcome of the game. As always, thanks for doing these!
May 20, 2013 7:17 p.m.
theobjection says... #7
I feel like the first hand was a bad keep on E's part. 2x cards that do nothing, 3x lands, and 2x cards that do nothing at the present time are not very good. Also, I believe that turn 5 of game 2 you have E where you should have C.
May 20, 2013 9:54 p.m.
exarkun809 says... #8
Well that was weak.
You definitely have to mulligan both games 1 and 3. It's a control deck, but it definitely has a curve and you have to have something playable in the first few turns (or black mana!). T1-3 has to have a Thought Scour , Dimir Charm , Lingering Souls , or at least a tapped shock land.
Also, sideboarding was a bit off. I probably should have put in the description, but most decks sideboard GY hate against this deck (obviously) and it's better to put in the entire sideboard package (everything but Supreme Verdict and Terminus ) in and just go all control in this matchup.
So I'd of done:
-2 Supreme Verdict
-2 Terminus
-4 Forbidden Alchemy
-4 Unburial Rites
-1 Snapcaster Mage
+2 Detention Sphere +1 Dissipate +3 Duress +1 Jace, Memory Adept +2 Planar Cleansing +2 Sphinx's Revelation +2 Witchbane Orb (at least in game 3 vs Slaughter Games )
May 21, 2013 10:03 a.m.
KrazyCaley says... #10
@quargur - That's what I said. I mean, I definitely have the advantage, but I hardly have a lock.
ShimmerVoid says... #1
E should just save Dimir Charm to counter Barter in Blood .
May 20, 2013 3:22 p.m.