AAAA HUBS :DDD

Hmm, I once made a Lovecraft deck too, not EDh, but still, I used the cards Whispering Madness, Cosmic Horror and Grimoire of the Dead. I find 'em very Lovecraft c:

Yeah I know all of those cards :) I really wanted play cosmic horror but... It is really bad card :( :D grimoire of the dead was in the deck, but maybe I ll put it back. Hmm, it is good card, slow but with all this mill it would be very hazard!

Maybe you could try some other card to represent the necronomicon. Like Tamiyo's Journal or Library of Leng.

Also I think Reckless Scholar or something like that deserves a spot given how they're pretty much the archetypal Lovecraftian protagonist. Maybe Hapless Researcher?

NewHorizons, I made this prototype yesterday: What the Moon Brings. It's the deck against Wrexial ;) those cards you mentioned could fit in there better than here. :) I realized that these theme things needs theme decks against them too. It's not funny to play with this againts decks like dragons, fairies, elves etc fairytale creatures:D

traumatize seems pretty good and flavorful also price of knowledge is super flavorful with amazing art not sure how good it is in your deck though