Oh it doesn't get them onto the battlefield but because they are being played at 1 copy gifts is a means to tutor them either into hand or graveyard and set myself up to play them safely.
September 19, 2024 11:03 a.m.
I had a similar-ish list to yours - with moderate success - around hogaak winter (when meta was hogaak + amulet titan).
With no blockers, and only counterspells for ineraction t7 is too slow.
I abused Madcap Experiment to ge around he issue way back then. Frankly in a package like yours Pact of Negation should be THE counterspell as far as free ones go. You have little to no card draw engines - as such pitch spells are an enormous liability.*
And depending on how the meta ebbs and flows (mostly on presence of noncreature removal)) Robe of Mirrors can be backbreaking.
*card selection cantrips are where card advantage is at. Read up turbo xerox principle. T4 JTMS or suspended ancestral vision is not timely enough.
September 19, 2024 5:14 p.m.
...oh and arguably since Harbinger of the Seas is better blood moon, than blood moon, it should be present in your list.
Mana denial is a great way to hamstrung greedy goodstuff decks and prevent them from overloading your counterspells in a single turn.
September 19, 2024 5:19 p.m.
haha funny you say that I literally just put Hydroelectric Specimen Flip in here because of the blocker/pitch situation!.... I hear you about Ancestral Vision... ideally i think The One Ring would be the move but i dont have that kinda money to throw at this deck... Im just hoping to troll/cheese a few wins at locals before the year is out is all... splashing red for Madcap Experiment seems like a really good move... Im trying to stay mono-blue just so i can say i finally made a mono blue control deck though. The robes seem like a great idea too thanks! ..... still tinkering/brewing this jank so i appreciate the insight!
love the fish blood moon creature idea too!
September 19, 2024 5:37 p.m.
Psst, search The One Ring altered on eBay, 5$. Unless the peeps you play with don't approve of proxies, that is.
September 19, 2024 9:41 p.m.
@Xica... I really wanna thank you for reminding me of Madcap Expiriments existence. I have been playtesting with it and this is just infinitely better. I have the fetch/shock lands to support it and a playset of madcap is like $2 bucks so I really cant justify trying to play on hard mode with Gifts Ungiven/Master Transmuter... I'm a bit mad that I'm no longer a pure blue deck and can no longer run Giant's Amulet but ill get over it.
@Craeter... Unfortunately the LGS has to vote unanimously in favor of proxies to be used for FNM. It used to be a non-issue with people proxying a few cards here and there or just for a functional mana base but it got out of hand over time.
September 20, 2024 4:34 p.m.
Fringe Jank modern combo? Say no more I'm in. My only thought is to run 4 Subtlety because Subtlety is a wincon plus being interaction it's just phenomenal. And maybe Consign to Memory in the board to protect your stuff from World Breaker and friends?
September 20, 2024 8:08 p.m. Edited.
@capwner yeah my ratios are not set in stone at all yet... before running madcap I was relying on Spellskite for my activated ability problems (my whole sideboard is junk now)... I'll probably have to get me some more subtlety and consign... or maybe I can get away with running Tale's End?
Xica says... #1
How does Gifts Ungiven help in getting Platinum Angel or Platinum Emperion onto the battlefield?
September 19, 2024 10:03 a.m.