FYI, Tajic, Legion's Edge doesn't work with what you're trying to do. If he's on the field, then Truefire Captain does nothing with Star of Extinction.
And I see the combo potential, but really if you have the mana to cast a Star of Extinction you might as well cast a kicked Fight with Fire, which has the added benefit to being early removal. Fight with Fire also has to option to deal 5 damage to your own Truefire Captain.
But if you're set on keeping the Star, I would cut it down to 1 or 2 copies. Those are just dead cards early game, and late game you shouldn't need to cast more than 1, I would hope. Banefire should be a sideboard card against control, maybe 1 copy mainboard.
I would also recommend putting in some Dauntless Bodyguards. It's a 2/1 for 1, and it gives your Captain indestructible so he can take all the damage and live to talk about how awesome it was. Speaking of awesome, I hope you target your own Captain with Justice Strike, because that's hilarious. And if he has a bunch of counters on him, that's probably a better finisher than the Star - 2 mana, instant speed, and the greatest sacrifice.
Also you probably need some card draw. You're gonna run out of gas, quick. If your mana base is good, then Zhalfirin Void is a good way to set up draws. Mentor of the Meek or Militia Bugler are also good ways to filter through your deck.
November 7, 2018 7:15 p.m.
eopneverdies420 says... #5
Natalbee yooo thats dope Fight with Fire is just like a better Lava Coil im gonna try the Dauntless Bodyguards (good idea ty) and the Mentor of the Meek I tried Militia Bugler but he kept getting rid of stuff i needed. I might cut it down to two Star of Extinctions too. ill update the deck list soon
November 9, 2018 4:43 a.m.
Sounds good, man - glad I could help. I'm not an authority on deck building, but if you wanna run anything by me, feel free.
November 9, 2018 11:12 a.m.
Just went 7-2 in constructed event (MTGA) with mostly this deck, thanks pal. I DID in fact use Fight with Fire over Star of Extinction and it won me one game. Other games I won were more burn wins, getting Tajic/Swiftblade opening hand with 2 mana is a guaranteed win. Thanks.
eopneverdies420 says... #1
Gonna swap out Rekindling Phoenix. too expensive at 25$ ea
October 23, 2018 1:26 a.m.