Baral Bodacious Booty (Original)

Commander / EDH* Profet93

SCORE: 25 | 13 COMMENTS | 2101 VIEWS


Update —Feb. 13, 2017

Took out....

Kederekt Leviathan, Arcanis the Omnipotent and Diluvian Primordial

Put in...

Baral, Chief of Compliance, Sky Diamond and Torrential Gearhulk

erabel says... #1

Deck already looks really solid as is. Talrand isn't too difficult to build, but you've definitely got a good list here. That said, my thoughts:

  • The two vote cards (Split Decision and Plea for Power) will always end up being the mode you don't like, unless you're down to the last two people and you want the "tied" mode. Both modes on both spells are still decent, don't get me wrong, but it'll still mess you up when you absolutely need it.
  • Domineering Will is mostly a meta call, I suppose. How's your experience been with that card?
  • Stolen Identity has always felt slow to me. It's a large initial investment, and it only really pays for itself if you can stick it on something both evasive (so it can keep connecting) and large or protected (so it doesn't die immediately).
  • Future Sight is a neat card, but also, in my personal experience, slow. You can't really afford to play it and nothing else, so you have to wait until you have something in the realm of 8 mana, and by then there's probably more productive things to do (unless you're comboing off with Future Sight, which this deck, in its current state, can't do).

If you decide that my advice is totally valid, some of the cheap cards from your maybeboard that I'd add first would be Peer Through Depths, Reality Shift, Whispers of the Muse, and Chain of Vapor.

If you're deciding which cards from your "too expensive right now"-board to splurge on first, I'd recommend either Snapcaster (I'm pretty sure it's the cheapest of what you've got there, and it's incredible value) or Pact (because it's a good counterspell and you can find it off Tolaria West).

All I got on first glance. A lot of what I say might not apply because of how you like to play, or how the group you play with plays, or if I suggested you cut a pet card that you enjoy. My word ain't gospel, however, just advice, since that's what you asked for. Have fun with your deck!

October 16, 2016 4:25 p.m.

Profet93 says... #2

erabel

Thank you for your suggestions! Split Decision and Plea for Power are both interesting cards I want to try out. I have not yet had a chance to fully test them, although I am pretty sure you are right. More testing will need to be done.

Domineering Will is one of my FAVORITE cards in the deck. It doesn't look much, but it really help you out of a tight spot. It's also really funny to use Bident of Thassa's second ability, use domineering will and then Twincast.

I feel the same about Stolen Identity. It has been too slow. I'm gonna give it another shot, but it looks like it will be the first on the chopping board.

Future Sight is interesting, as it helps me go through more and more of my deck. It also shows me opponents whatever card is coming up next which can often times be very negative. A potential card to cut.

For the cheap cards you recommend me to add, do you think I should take away some higher CMC spells (as discussed) and/or remove some lands? I've been confused as to the appropriate amount of ramp/lands for this kind of deck.

October 16, 2016 5:22 p.m.

erabel says... #4

All seem like real good changes. I'm still testing Insidious Will, so I'm iffy on taking it out just yet, but I can see the reasoning behind it (dropping the curve, mostly).

October 20, 2016 7:23 p.m.

Profet93 says... #5

erabel

If you had to rate the deck as it is 1 -10, 1 = bleh, 10 = Perfect, what would you rate it? Anything else you recommend to put in/out? My apologies for all of my questions, I'm just unfamiliar with Talrand.

I am looking into purchasing the pieces (most of the expensive pieces I own). I will slowly trade for the expensive wants listed in the sideboard.

And exactly, it's nice to have a lower curve, and most of the time you want to counter a spell than copy or change it's target.

November 2, 2016 1:24 a.m.

Snap157 says... #6

Would Omniscience or High Tide Work in a deck like this? Also I think Gitaxian Probe, Peek, and Spy Network would really help. +1 neat deck

February 6, 2017 2:07 p.m.

Profet93 says... #7

Snap157

Thank you for your suggestions.

Omniscience is too costly. I am already trying to reduce the Avg CMC of the deck.

High Tide is a potential addition. I will definitely consider that seeing how I need ramp.

Gitaxian Probe is already in the deck. I had Peek but it wasn't that helpful surprisingly enough.

Spy Network isn't a cantrip so I am unwilling to include it

February 6, 2017 2:14 p.m.