How competitive do you want these commanders to be?

Sweet. Now my true creative styles can come alive. I already have a commander in mind, even though I wish this was tiny leader feasible. I want to use the commander that I created for the collaboration. You know...

Do you think this would be a acceptable commander?

Sorry, I didn't see you comment until after I had reset the comment section SirFowler. But yeah, that commander is entirely alright, it has been nerfed from original, so it is fine. Just remember that you can only use official mtg cards for the decklist itself.

Here's my commander:

and my list.

What is this? Life Tomp? IS THAT AN ARCHETYPE? Playtest

Commander / EDH Magicrafter

SCORE: 6 | 31 COMMENTS | 638 VIEWS

Sorry, I'll be gone for a few hours, I'll get back to you on the commander. Sorry for the inconvenience :(

@Magicrafter Is that supposed to be an alternate version of Selvala, Explorer Returned?

Maybe...

In one timeline Selva ignited her spark after she fell in a hole filled with goblins and she now explorers the multiverse.

In the current timeline she became a prestigious explorer at her home plane, earning the local suffix -la, meaning great explorer before venturing to the city and fighting for her people, as the grand counsel was planning to destory her homeland.

Made-up? Yes! Canon? No!

Cool beans

I have a bunch of legendary creatures I had made a while ago. Anyone want to see/borrow any?

Go for it, nemesis

Sorry about the length of this, y'all. I suck at html enough not to try to spoiler-tag this.

The several with cartoon art are from Tom Siddel's masterpiece webcomic Gunnerkrigg Court.

I haven't decided which I plan to use yet...

Oooh! Just thought of another funny multiplayer one:

I think I'm going with that one lol, if it's feasible with how we're playing.

Ooh, I like that. I hope wizards makes it someday XD

So I drop in for one sec before going to bed for good, and there are tons of these things here XD

Oh my goodness, nemesis

Daedalus, you should play Jacinta.

Um, this is cool, I guess. Hold on, let me dig up some old cards...found one!

(insert imaginary clause that says it can be my commander because mtgcardsmith doesn't let me do that.)

okay scrubs, let's get this on.

@Daedalus19876 from what I can tell, you plan on using Jacinta, correct? One question besides that one: how does her ability stop?

@SirFowler your,commander was actually already approved, I just didn't want to make you feel excluded by not mentioning you. ;)

@Magicrafter, the "when you control" effect to the activated ability, that way it reads "Search you library for an enchantment or equipment card with converted mana cost X or less, and put it into your hand, then shuffle your library. If you control four or more equipment, flip Selva, Ancient Explorer." That way you actually have to use her activated ability to be able to flip her.

@6tennis, are you sure you wanna go mono colored? And I think that if you'd like a planeswalker, it has to be a flip, that way you don't have immediate advantage by having a readily available walker. But other than that, I like it.

Alright nerds, you're all doing pretty good so far, keep it up.

NoviceMagician: I'm not sure which I'm using yet (mono-colored is hard; maybe I'll make a RU version of her to play chaos effects). She specifies "next turn", so in theory it's just the next turn cycle (she comes into play, A controls B, B controls C, C controls D, D controls A, then the effect is finished).

Should I include a clause to prevent blinking her to make her effect semi-permanent? Something like "when you cast Jalira from your command zone"?

Changes made:

Why not just a cast trigger? Or would that be too OP?

I am pretty sure I could manage to use the cast trigger every turn, and so we'd essentially all be playing the next deck over. I'm trying to find a way to restrict its utility without shafting any of the players involved. Also, in the current formulation I lose my next turn so I want to avoid that yet still have it be fair...somehow.

Or I just could not the bullet and make th effect continuous lol. Somebody will kill her eventually and reset it, since every deck is being played.

Oooh! Idea!

Still acceptable? Solves many of the issues that would have happened previously.