--- 9/15/24 ---
Control update!
(-) Urza, Lord Protector
, (+) Grand Abolisher: These creatures allow us to not have to use countermagic to protect our own spells.
(-) The Mightstone and Weakstone
, (+) Vexing Shusher
--- 6/23/24 ---
Outlaws of Thunder Junction update!
(-) Settle the Wreckage, (+) Final Showdown: Instant speed boardwipe swap.
--- 8/5/23 ---
Commander Masters update!
(-) Pramikon, Sky Rampart, (+) Deflecting Swat: Pramikon, Sky Rampart hasn't worked as well as I had hoped, hopefully you have no one attacking you instead of forcing a single opponent to only attack you and is useless in a 1v1 situation. Commander Masters has made Deflecting Swats much more affordable, so get them soon.
--- 4/19/23 ---
March of Machines update!
(-) Tidal Barracuda, (+) Heliod, the Radiant Dawn
: Front side helps recur enchantments, back side provides flash and makes our spells cheaper.
(-) Teferi, Hero of Dominaria, (+) Urza, Lord Protector
: Meld planeswalker is cool, and Urza, Lord Protector
makes most of our spells cheaper to cast.
(-) Treasure Map
, (+) The Mightstone and Weakstone
--- 7/21/22 ---
Lands update!
(-) Plains, (+) Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire
(-) Island, (+) Otawara, Soaring City
(-) Mountain, (+) Shatterskull Smashing
(-) Forest, (+) Boseiju, Who Endures
(-) Sunpetal Grove, (+) Windswept Heath
(-) Rootbound Crag, (+) Wooded Foothills
--- 5/15/22 ---
Streets of New Capenna update!
(-) Chaos Warp, (+) Endless Detour: A super flexible card. Able to hit indestructible permanents like Chaos Warp, even if it just delays them for a turn. Also able to recur our own spells to the top of our library.
(-) Kruphix, God of Horizons, (+) Smuggler's Share: Smuggler's Share has great synergy with all of our extra draw spells, allowing us to get more consistency from it than most decks.
(-) Seaside Citadel, (+) Spara's Headquarters: A strict upgrade, able to be fetched with Three Visits and Nature's Lore
(-) Deflecting Palm, (+) Three Visits: Extra ramp that is able to get our tri-lands.
--- 4/29/21 ---
(-) Sphinx of the Second Sun, (+) Jadzi, Oracle of Arcavios
: We mainly want this for the reverse side, which allows us to drop lands that we draw in our x-cost draw spells.
--- 11/15/20 ---
Commander Legends update!
(-) Tatyova, Benthic Druid, (+) Sphinx of the Second Sun: 8 mana is steep, but because of the additional untap phase he immediately pays for himself. This card is potentially more powerful than an additional card/untap during our turn, since we play so many howling mine type effects which trigger during the untap or draw phase.
--- 10/2/20 ---
(-) Forest, (+) Sea Gate Restoration
: A land that can draw a bunch of cards.
--- 5/24/20 ---
Ikoria update!
(-) Summary Dismissal, (+) Fierce Guardianship: Cutting a powerful, but situational, counterspell for a more flexible and free one.
(-) Hour of Revelation, (+) Tidal Barracuda: Vedalken Orrery + stopping opponents from countering our stuff on our turn. Fits the group hug theme.
(-) Frontier Bivouac, (+) Ketria Triome: Can fetch this land with Nature's Lore.
(-) Mystic Monastery, (+) Raugrin Triome: Can fetch this land with Tithe.
--- 2/5/20 ---
(-) Dictate of Karametra, (+) Nyxbloom Ancient: Nyxbloom Ancient is less of a group hug card, but triple mana seems fun.
(-) Eternal Witness, (+) Seasons Past
(-) Show and Tell, (+) Chance for Glory
(-) Horn of Greed, (+) Rhystic Study
(-) Wrath of God, (+) Supreme Verdict
(-) Desertion, (+) Thought Vessel
(-) Crush Contraband, (+) Chaos Warp
--- 10/18/19 ---
(-) Wilderness Reclamation, (+) Kruphix, God of Horizons: Kruphix is back, looking to add more effects to remove maximum hand size.
(-) Wall of Shards, (+) Folio of Fancies
--- 9/2/19 ---
(-) Wall of Denial, (+) Pramikon, Sky Rampart: Testing out the new Commander 2019 wall as a direct replacement for Wall of Denial.
--- 5/9/19 ---
War of the Spark update!
(-) Veteran Explorer, (+) Dovin's Veto: We have no way to easily kill Veteran Explorer ourselves, so it's not as reliable ramp as I would like. Dovin's Veto is great at stopping people's spells and can be tutored with Sunforger.
(-) Tempt with Discovery, (+) Teferi, Time Raveler: Usually opponents either won't get any lands, causing you to pay 4 mana to get Reliquary Tower since we don't run any really broken lands, or opponents run Gaea's Cradle/Serra Sanctum/Cabal Coffers and we don't run Strip Mine to destroy those. Teferi, Time Raveler has multiple useful modes; he makes our spells uncounterable, allows us to flash in sorceries (the main reason we run Leyline of Anticipation and Vedalken Orrery), and can temporarily remove most permanents while drawing us cards, for just 3 mana!
(-) Blue Sun's Zenith, (+) Finale of Revelation: Finale of Revelation addresses the drawbacks of sorcery speed x-draw spells by giving us no maximum handsize for the rest of the game and untapping 5 lands, allowing us to use countermagic and removal that we draw into.
(-) Mystic Confluence, (+) Narset's Reversal: A cheaper counterspell that allows for fun interactions with opponent's spells (Cyclonic Rift) and our own x-cost draw spells and Expropriate.
--- 3/23/19 ---
I've revised the list to reduce the amount of cards that tend to draw the opponents more cards than us.
(-) Heartwood Storyteller, (+) Sylvan Library: We tend to play more noncreature spells than our opponents. Sylvan Library comes down earlier, easier to cast, and can draw us a lot of cards.
(-) Forced Fruition, (+) Teferi, Hero of Dominaria: Forced Fruition was always a risky wincon, allowing our opponents to draw a lot of cards and giving them a chance to find an answer to Forced Fruition. Teferi, Hero of Dominaria costs less mana, draws us cards and lets us hold up mana, removes problem permanents, and his ult will win us the game.
(-) Minds Aglow (-) Prosperity, (+) Sphinx's Revelation (+) Blue Sun's Zenith: I like the group hug aspect of Minds Aglow and Prosperity, and with Consecrated Sphinx these cards became incredibly powerful, I found that if I cast these at sorcery speed they give the opponent such a huge advantage that the only way these cards were useful were if they could be flashed in at end step. Instead of relying on a flash enabler we can just run card draw spells that have instant speed and are one sided. Blue Sun's Zenith is nice because it goes back in the deck and can still be used to mill opponents.
I've also removed cards that I've found haven't been impactful enough.
(-) Selvala, Explorer Returned, (+) Eladamri's Call: Group hug effect, ramp, card draw, and life gain, she ends up not doing enough of any of those in a consistent enough manner, and the fact that you have to wait a turn to use her, has caused me to cut her. We run very powerful creatures, and Consecrated Sphinx is one of the best cards in the deck, and Eladamri's Call gets them at instant speed and can be cast off of Sun Forger.
(-) Kruphix, God of Horizons, (+) Treasure Map
: No maximum hand size and storing tons of mana is good, but not quite good enough to pay 5 mana for. Treasure Map
allows us to control our draws in the early game, flips and provides ramp or card draw, and combos very nicely with Smothering Tithe.
(-) Reins of Power, (+) Mystic Confluence: Too situational, Insurrection, even though it costs more mana, usually wins the game on the spot. Mystic Confluence allows us to remove problematic creatures (providing a similar role when casting Reins of Power on an opponents turn), counter spells, and draw cards.
(-) Insidious Will, (+) Pact of Negation: The easiest to cut of the expensive countermagic we run (see comment section below).