AffinityNot a great matchup, as they can Mox Opal/Springleaf Drum to avoid our LD, and Blood Moon does not affect them that much. Bonfire of the Damned can help us put up a fight, though. For SB, I would suggest something along the lines of:
-IN: 1x Kitchen Finks, 1x Shatterstorm, 2x Firespout, 1x Sudden Shock, 2x Ancient Grudge, 2x Natural State, 2x Pithing Needle (name Arcbound Ravager/Cranial Plating/Steel Overseer).
-OUT: 4x Blood Moon, 4x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss, 3x Stone Rain.
Burn
A surprisingly good matchup because of all our lifegain, Burn I would say is favored G1. For SB, I would suggest:
-IN: 1x Kitchen Finks, 1x Sudden Shock, 2x Firespout.
-OUT: 2x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss, 2x Beast Within.
Jund
A very good matchup from the beginning for us. This deck just wrecks their 1-for-1 removal with all our resilient threats. We can be weak to discard, however. Getting them to Thoughtseize an Obstinate Baloth can be very entertaining. For sideboarding:
-IN: 2x Relic of Progenitus, sometimes Pithing Needle for opposing LOTVs while on the draw. Kitchen Finks is debatable. I wouldn't really suggest Spellskite, but it could be an option.
-OUT: 2x beast withn.
Aggro Eldrazi (Bant)
Great matchup, they rely very heavily on their lands. Noble Hierarch can be quite annoying. As for the sideboard, I do not suggest any changes!
Abzan Beatdown
Blood Moon utterly destroys this deck. Good luck casting Siege Rhino. Their rampers can be a problem, messes with our mana denial. For the sideboard:
-IN: 1x Sudden Shock (for rampers and other meddlesome creatures of the small variety).
-OUT: 1x Beast Within.
Normal Zoo
This deck is a lot like our burn matchup, we play our life-gaining fatties and overpower their smaller, faster creatures. Normally favorable G1. Bonfire of the Damned helps a lot. For the sideboard, I recommend:
-IN: 2x Firespout, 1x Kitchen Finks, 1x Sudden Shock for small nacatls and other creatures.
-OUT: 4x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss.
Death's Shadow Zoo
Very similar to traditional zoo, but a large Death's Shadow can be VERY hard to remove sometimes. Bonfire of the Damned off the top can make some surprise wins for us. As for sideboarding, I would suggest the same as "Normal Zoo". Do note, if you see them playing Phyrexian Unlife, I would suggest MBing a few Natural States.
Knight of the Reliquary Zoo
A less popular brew, but still will show up from time to time. Normally a good matchup. There are many variations of this deck, some running Collected Company, most running Tarmogoyf. For the sideboard:
-IN: 2x Relic of Progenitus, 1x Sudden Shock, 1x Kitchen Finks. Firespout depends on what creatures your opponent is running. Pithing Needle is also an option.
-OUT: 3x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss.
Hatebears (Most likely Eldrazi)
This matchup depends a lot on whether they get an Aether Vial out, and whether or not they play a Thalia, Guardian of Thraben T2. Is quite a toss up, but our fatties do a good job at overpowering them. For sideboarding, I would suggest:
-IN: 1x Sudden Shock, 2x Firespout, 2x Ancient Grudge, 1x Natural State, above Pithing Needle because of Tidehollow Sculler.
-OUT: 4x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss (Leonin Arbiter says hello), and Kitchen Finks.
Also of note: Flickerwisp hitting a Utopia Sprawled land can hurt.
UR Aggro/Suicide Blue
Quite a tough matchup, as our land destruction doesn't really hit them hard enough. Our fatties get overpowered by their Kiln Fiends and Thing in the Ice
s. For the sideboard:
-IN: 1x Choke, 1x Sudden Shock, 1x Spellskite
-OUT: 3x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss
Merfolk
Not a great game 1 because of their Aether Vials, basic Islands and possible Master of Waves. This can be a tough matchup, but we have good sideboard tech.
-IN: 2x Firespout, 1x Choke, 2x Natural State (hits Spreading Seas). 1x Ancient Grudge/Pithing Needle.
-OUT: 4x Blood Moon, 2x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss.
Bogles
The dreaded bogles. Our land destruction and moons hit them very hard. A lot of this comes down to who is on the play or not. We can board:
-IN: 2x Firespout, 1x Spellskite
-OUT: 1x Huntmaster of the Fells
, 2x Inferno Titan
Scapeshift/Titanshift
If we resolve a Blood Moon, the game is pretty close to being over. Although they can beat down with their primetime sometimes, our fatties' combined strength can take one out. As for sideboarding, I would suggest:
-IN: 1x Spellskite, 1x Kitchen Finks, and Choke if temur.
-OUT: 2x Bonfire of the Damned
Tron
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! Easily our best matchup. I've had opponents snap concede to T2 Blood Moons. This is our bye that counts as a win. For sideboarding:
-IN: 2x Pithing Needle (name Ugin or Karn, generally), Choke and Relic of Progenitus if Mono-U tron with Mindslaver.
-OUT: 2x Bonfire of the Damned
Jeskai Nahiri, the Harbinger
Not our greatest matchup, but they are some of the best games of Magic I have ever played. Stormbreath Dragon is simply amazing against this deck. It's path-proof, Nahiri-proof, and it's monstrosity ability punishes control players especially. Watch out for Nahiri's -2, it can hit our moons. For sideboarding, I would recommend:
-IN: 2x Pithing Needle, 1x Choke.
-Out: 1x Kitchen Finks, 1x Obstinate Baloth, 1x Bonfire of the Damned (it's good to have another card that hits Nahiri, so I only cut one).
Grixis Control
A little bit of a better matchup than Nahiri. Blood Moon hits them hard, and they have a lot of lack of interaction with it (they won't be casting any cryptics, at least). For sideboarding, I would recommend:
-IN: 1x Choke, 2x Relic of Progenitus to combat snappies and Tasigur.
-OUT: 2x Obstinate Baloth (I think playing 61 here is fine, considering your relics cantrip.
Grixis Delver
This matchup is quite close. Our bonfires help clear Young Pyromancer tokens and our lifegain fatties help dodge their big guys and burn, but they can throw a lot of stuff at us. Delver of Secrets
is especially bad for us, due to our lack of flying creatures. For sideboarding:
-IN: 2x Relic of Progenitus, 1x Choke, 1x Kitchen Finks. Firespout is inconsistent against delver, but when it's good, it often 3-for-1's them.
-OUT: 4x Beast Within
U/W Control
A good control matchup for us, their wraths don't hit us that hard due to our resilient threats. Gideon Jura can sometimes be a problem. Elspeth tokens can be annoying, but bonfire or Inferno Titan clears a path very well. For the sideboard, I would suggest:
-IN: 1x Choke, 2x Pithing Needle if walker-based finishers.
-OUT: 1-3x Bonfire of the Damned
Lantern Control
G1 is basically if they have their combo+bridge down quickly or not. Games 2 and 3, we get a LOT of hate.
-IN: 2x Ancient Grudge, 2x Natural State, 1x Shatterstorm, 2x Pithing Needle, 1x Kitchen Finks.
-OUT: 4x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss, 4x Blood Moon.
Do note that Birds of Paradise+Kessig Wolf Run can really help us get under a bridge, albeit quite unlikely.
Skred
Being completely honest, I am not quite sure about this matchup. I think we get stronger post-board to deal with opposing walkers. Although they can kill our larger threats, those threats are still resilient and get us good value.
-IN: 2x Pithing Needle, possibly Ancient Grudge if Batterskull is present. Also helps take out an early Mind Stone.
-OUT 2-4x Blood Moon.
Dredge
A horrid matchup game 1 if they have even a half good hand and top of library. Our Blood Moons don't work well enough against their discard outlets, and they don't need much mana to operate past that. From the board:
-IN: 1x Kitchen Finks, 2x Relic of Progenitus, 2x Firespout, 1x Spellskite (good chumper).
-OUT: 4x Blood Moon, 2x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss.
Infect
Not necessarily a great matchup, but we can hit their Inkmoth Nexuses hard, which is sometimes enough. Noble Hierarchs are annoying, as always. We have some good hate in the board.
-IN: 1x Spellskite, 1x Sudden Shock, 2x Firespout. I do not think Pithing Needle is needed to combat their Inkmoth Nexuses.
-OUT: 1x Obstinate Baloth, 3x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss.
Abzan Combo/Toolbox
Blood Moon, as always, shuts them down well. Generally in our favor, especially after boarding.
-IN: 2x Pithing Needle, 2x Firespout, 1x Sudden Shock.
-OUT: 1x Kitchen Finks, 1x Obstinate Baloth, 3x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss.
Ad Nauseam
Not normally a great matchup G1, it is mainly about Lotus Blooms. For sideboarding, I would suggest:
-IN: 2x Pithing Needle (name Lightning Storm).
-OUT: 2x Bonfire of the Damned
Living End
This matchup isn't terrible. If we can keep them off of 3 mana for long enough, that's often a good way to win, especially considering their greedy manabase. For sideboarding:
-IN: 2x Relic of Progenitus, 1x Kitchen Finks
-OUT: 3x Bonfire of the Damned
Griselbrand Reanimator
Keeping them off of mana for Goryo's Vengeance is the way to play. Sometimes we can amass a board state and life total to win through multiple swings of the big demon himself. For sideboarding, I'd recommend:
-IN: 2x Relic of Progenitus, 2x Pithing Needle (name Grislebrand).
-OUT: 3x Bonfire of the Damned, 1x Huntmaster of the Fells
.
UR Storm
Very similar to Suicide Blue/UR Aggro G1, meaning not good. Post-board we have:
-IN: 2x Relic of Progenitus, 1x Choke.
-OUT: 2x Bonfire of the Damned, 1x Kitchen Finks. I think it is worth keeping moon in against this deck, coupled with our land destruction.
Bloomless Titan
A great matchup for Blood Moon. That's about all there is to it. For sideboarding:
-IN: 2x Ancient Grudge, 2x Natural State (for Amulet of Vigor). 1x Sudden Shock may also be used to take out an opposing Azusa, Lost but Seeking.
-OUT: 3x Bonfire of the Damned, 1x Kitchen Finks.
8-rack
Normally a bad game 1, we get lots of SB hate for their artifacts/enchantments, swinging the tide significantly in our favor. As a side note, Obstinate Baloth is funny to slam down for free against them.
-IN: 2x Ancient Grudge, 1x Shatterstorm, 2x Natural State. Perhaps Pithing Needle, too.
-OUT: 2x Mwonvuli Acid-Moss, 3x Bonfire of the Damned.