i tested on untap and I beat U/B control/aggro 3-0 3 games in a row.

Yeah, I thought for a second "wait, how is this card legal and not played?" Well, now I know why it isn't played :)

I like how this turned from lets all make a modern deck to look mine is better. :p

i don't think it is. I was just saying the archetype actually works. I think TheHroth should put one of our decks in here so we can edit it together.

It was a joke. I understand we have to start somewhere. Haha. This at least gives us a more defined list to tune.

At school for 12 hours today studying calculus nearly the whole time! I only took a couple hours break to play a couple games with my friends, and eat.

What I'll do for now is add all the cards that all the lists shared here have in common, then we can decide where to go from there!

We are so close. Do we have goal for amount of up-votes?

As many as we can get! Imagine this hits #1! :o!!!

Yeah. That would be amazing.

Are we gonna rename it after we make it public?

Oh yes, definitely.

For school we have a poetry contest and I was gonna make my poem about the deck, so if it turns out, and you guys can critique it, it could be our intro to the description.

That would be great!

Ok, so the deck is now a cross-reference of all the decks shared, containing only cards in amounts that all 3 builds had in common.

16 cards in common. More than 1/4 of the way there!

Wow. 16 cards in common, that's actually surprising given the amount of changes each person has made. I think an addition Time of Need would be beneficial bith for Delver triggers and an extra way to get out Melira. I also agree with the amount of 2 Spell Pierce and 2 Mana Leak, though I wouldn't mind going perhaps up to 3 leaks.

i think 3x Mana Leak is the way to go.

This deck need 4x Mana Confluence

Ya, those and/or City of Brass. It pings us, perhaps a total of 6 using any combination of the 2. It buffs our Shadow while ensuring no mana screw. Which is VERY important.

In my deck I use 4 confluence and 3 city of brass and it works perfectly.

I lost to merfolk, how do we beat them.

*?

We honestly should just start from my list, as I spent all night critiquing it to make it work.

I don't mind doing what Kiora_Fan-01 said, so if all others are in agreement I'll go ahead and finish up the list, then we'll go from there!

I can agree to that. We can start with a full list like that then try to come up with better options. I believe it'll work better if we start with a full list instead of just the 15 that we all agree on.

Exacty my thinking.