Do we want to use Grisly Salvage over Commune with the Gods though? We might mill out of our reanimate option?

out of the 3 you listed earlier I said my vote would be for Grisly Salvage because of the 3 it was the only instant. I do see what your saying though, the fact that Commune with the Gods lets us take an enchantment means that we can take a Whip if it shows up in the 5 cards. Good eye, I wasn't even thinking about the whip being an Enchantment Artifact. I was just thinking the instant speed spell gave us more flexibility to do it at the end of opponents turn.

Im good with removing the bident and a rescue. So do you guys like GS or CwtG? Do we want instant speed, or ability to grab the whip?

I'm going to change my vote to Commune with the Gods I think the whip is too valuable/important to lose it like that. What does everyone else think??

I feel we can give up instant speed to ensure we don't pitch the whip. My vote is for CwtG.