When playing Mizzix I have often had doubts about how the stack works. Understanding the stack really help play this deck well as there are over 35 instant spells in the deck. Therefore I have decided to help myself, and maybe you as well?, by creating a FAQ that has a focus on Mizzix and the stack
A)
When is a spell cast?
A spell is considered cast when it is successfully put on the stack (not when it is resolved)
B)
When will I get an experience counter?
You will get an experience counter once you cast a spell (see A). The experience counter will be resolved just before the spell gets resolved. E.g
1. You cast a spell and it is put on the stack,
Master the Way
2. Mizzix’ ability trigger that gives you an experience counter is put on the stack
The stack will resolve in reverse order, so first you get the experience counter, and then
Master the Way resolves. Also note that they are two different events. So when 2) Mizzix’ ability, is put on the stack, you will get an experience counter even though
Master the Way would not be able to resolve.
C)
Can I get multiple experience counters from casting spells with the same CMC?
Yes if the spells are on the same stack. Say you have 3 experience counters and cast
AEtherize. You will get to place
AEtherize on the stack, and you will place a trigger of Mizzix' ability that gives you an experience counter on the stack. You can now respond to Mizzix' ability and put
Fact or Fiction on the stack, that will again trigger Mizzix' abilityr. And since Mizzix at this point, still only sees 3 experience counters; it will be legal to put the additional trigger on the stack. The stack would look like this
1.
AEtherize (The first spell on the stack could be a sorcery spell)
2. Mizzix’ ability trigger that gives you an experience counter is put on the stack (legal because we only have 3 experience counters)
3.
Fact or Fiction (This spell must be an instant, you cast in response to the first ability trigger)
4. Mizzix’ ability trigger that gives you an experience counter is put on the stack (still legal because we still only have 3 experience counters)
Thus we will get 2 additional experience counters, and end up with 5 experience counters. This will only work if the spells are on the same stack.
D)
Does Mizzix cost reducing ability works on alternative costs such as buyback, kicker, overload, flashback etc?
Yes it does, if the alternative cost still makes you cast the card. Just be aware that alternative cost does not count towards the total mana cost (only spells with X cost in the upper right corner works). For instance a kicked
Blink of an Eye will only be considered as 2 CMC even though you paid 4 CMC for it, but Mizzix cost reduction ability make a kicked
Blink of an Eye cheaper, so you only have to pay 2 Blue mana for a kicked
Blink of an Eye. But a
Devil's Play with X = 3 would count as 4 CMC.
E)
If I cast Devastation Tide for its miracle cost will Mizzix only see it as 2 CMC?
No Mizzix will read the upper right corner. The CMC for
Devastation Tide will be 5 regardless if you cast it for its full cost or the miracle cost.
F)
If i cast Mizzium Mortars for its overload, will I get an experience counter, if I already have 3 experience counters?
No, Mizzix will read the upper right corner. The CMC for
Mizzium Mortars is 2, regardless of how you cast it.
G)
If I copy a spell such as Prophetic Bolt with Increasing Vengeance, Fury Storm, Wild Ricochet or Insidious Will can I then get an additional experience counter from the copy of Prophetic Bolt?
No, Mizzix’ ability specifically says you must cast a spell in order for her ability to work. All of the aforementioned copy spells just put a new spell on the stack without casting it. An example of a spell that makes copies, that could create experience counters, is
Mizzix's Mastery, because is says “... you may cast the copy…”.
H)
Will I always get an experience counter; if I cast a spell with X in its mana cost?
As a rule of thumb yes. But the exception is whenever you pay additional costs, sucs as buyback, kicker costs etc. Suppose you have 6 experience counters and 2 red mana. If you play
Fanning the Flames for two red mana, pay for the buyback cost with the value from 3 experience counters then you only have 3 experience counters to put in X and the total CMC will be 2 red + 3 generic = 5 CMC and therefore you will not gain an experience counters from casting
Fanning the Flames.
I)
If I put multiple spells with X in the mana cost on the stack. Will each spell on the stack become one stronger? E.g if i have 5 experience counters and put Comet Storm for X = 5 on the stack and then respond with Stroke of Genius will i then have 6 experience counters so that i can cast Stroke of Genius for X = 6?
No, while they are on the same stack, you will still have 5 experience counters. The stack would go like this:
1.
Comet Storm with X =5, from experience counters
2. Mizzix’ ability trigger - experience counter will be incremented with one
3.
Stroke of Genius will still only benefit from 5 = x experience counters because Mizzix’ cost reduction is still only 5
4. Mizzix’ ability trigger - experience counter will be incremented with one
You will get 2 experience counters once the entire stack has resolved. The optimal play would likely have been to let the stack with
Comet Storm fully resolve before casting
Stroke of Genius, you will still get 2 experience counters, but you get one more mana in the CMC for
Stroke of Genius.
J)
If I have 0 experience counters and I bounce Mizzix back to my hand with Call to Heel will I then get an experience counter?
Yes you will, because of the order that stack resolves. The stack would like this:
1.
Call to Heel
2. Ability trigger that gives you an experience counter is put on the stack
First 2) the ability trigger resolves giving you an experience counter and then 1)
Call to Heel resolves
K)
If I have 0 experience counters and I bounce Mizzix back to my hand with Call to Heel, and then in response cast Jace's Ingenuity will I then get 2 experience counters?
Yes, each spell you cast will trigger Mizzix’ ability that gives an experience counter on the stack. But no discounts will be given; you have to pay full price for both spells (see I)
L)
If I have 2 experience counters and cast Tezzeret's Gambit and cast Cerebral Vortex in response, how many experience will I end up with?
It will give you 3 experience counters. The stack could look like this
1.
Tezzeret's Gambit
2. Proliferate ability trigger
3. Mizzix’ ability trigger (you can stack the ability triggers, 2 and 3, in any order, but the order makes no difference in this case)
4.
Cerebral Vortex
5. Mizzix’ ability trigger (legal because we have 2 experience counters)
So again, we resolve in reverse order. We will get an experience counter from step 5, then step 3, and finally step 2. You will end up with 5 experience counters in total. However if you sit with 3 experience counters, cast
Tezzeret's Gambit and let the stack resolve, you will only get 2 experience counters, and casting
Cerebral Vortex after that would not give you more experience counters. You would only have a total of 4 experience counters.
M)
If someone Counterspell a spell I have cast, Enter the Infinite, will I still get an experience counter?
Yes, your spell
Enter the Infinite will be countered but Mizzix triggered ability will be put on the stack, the time you casted
Enter the Infinite, and therefore Mizzix' triggered ability will not be countered..
1.
Enter the Infinite
2. Mizzix’ ability trigger
3.
Counterspell → points on
Enter the Infinite (note that the counter spell does not point on “2. Mizzix’ ability trigger”)
This also means that if you are on the pursuit of experience counters, say you have 4 experience counters and need 6. You could put an instant spell on the stack, such as
Thoughtflare then cast something like
Remand (note remand is not in the deck) on
Thoughtflare.
Thoughtflare will get returned to your hand and then you can cast it again on the same stack. The first version of
Thoughtflare will never get to resolve but it will be cast, so you will get an experience counter, and the second version of
Thoughtflare will be cast as well, resulting in another experience counter. The stack would go like this
1.
Thoughtflare
2. Mizzix’ ability trigger
3.
Remand →
Thoughtflare (
Remand will not trigger Mizzix’ ability, since you already have 4 experience counters)
You let step 3 resolve and get
Thoughtflare to your hand, and draw a card. The entire stack looks like this
4. Mizzix’ ability trigger
Before 4. Resolves, you ask for priority and cast again
Thoughtflare, as response to 4, and the final stack will look like this:
5. Mizzix’ ability trigger
6.
Thoughtflare
7. Mizzix’ ability trigger
And you let the entire stack resolve. You get 2 experience counters, draw 4 cards and discard 2 cards.
N)
Can I play Firemind's Foresight in response to Murder targeting Mizzix, and fetch a bounce spell and cast that targeting Mizzix or fetch a counter spell?
Yes, sure you can. If you do not have
Firemind's Foresight in hand you could also try with any instant draw spell such as
Stroke of Genius and see if you get lucky with your draws, maybe you will find
Wild Ricochet.