Wait on Gatherer is common, while at Magiccardsinfo is uncommon... Who has the right answer?

NeverTheTwelve, generally people go by Gatherer rarities. It's common and legal for PDH.

Also, finally offering up my Esper Stax Deck to be added. A more detailed description is underway and should be finished up within the week.

Esper Stax

@NeverTheTwelve: PDH uses the Gatherer rarities, as that is the official Wizards card index. It contains rarities for both paper and MTGO and PDH allows the use of a card printed at common in either.

Oh I see... Thanks alot Tyrannosaurus_Maximus and Ruffigan, I used to play classical pauper where you can't use Merchant Scroll because isn't on MTGO. Now I know where to look

I'm back! And I added everything. Sorry I missed your deck Zuty.

We also have new decks to debate in the comment section above. (Ruffigan/NeverTheTwelve)

Decks added:

• Lady Evangela
• Sarcatog
• Invisible Stalker
• Spinebiter
• Siren of the Silent Song

Jack in the box is a Golgari counters deck that looks to go big with creatures that either get counters or can be given counters!

Omenreader's chapter on Cheating is a mono green ramp/cost reduction deck that looks to reduce the costs of your big 6cmc+ creatures so you're filling the board with nothing but monsters.

@hothmagoth your Golgari list is not a Pauper EDH deck. Please only submit Pauper EDH decks.

My apologies, I've linked a deck that shares the same name as my Pauper Golgari list, as you can see, I wasn't the publisher of the deck. This is the deck Jack in the Box

Two more decks have been added to the debate section.

Also...

Decks added:

• Corpsejack Menace
• Centaur Omenreader

Heyo, got another decklist to offer up. This time it's Viral Drake Infect

And I'm back again, this time with Renegade Renewal, a Renegade Rallier value/combo deck

Decks added:

• Renegade Rallier
• Viral Drake

Yo, check my 1v1 Rakdos Cackler deck at Rakdos Cackler - PDH.

@wraya2 thats a submission right?

Yup :)

There was no discussion over our debate deck lists. Deck placement left the same.

Deck added:

• Rakdos Cackler

Ruffigan just got this email from contact at EDHrec

"Im not sure if you saw, but today I posted an april fools joke about Tiny Leaders https://tiny.edhrec.com/. I made this as a joke because it was pretty easy to do after I built https://brawl.edhrec.com/ which is getting announced tomorrow.

mtggoldfish.com's deck builder made it really easy for me to make brawl and tiny leaders because they have separate designations for Tiny Leaders + Brawl + EDH. If you could get them to make a Pauper EDH designation and then get a few hundred decks in there I might be able to put together something for the PDH community fairly easily.

-Don"

Did not know this was a thing, been playing this PDH deck in regular EDH leagues / tourny's for a challenge, https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/birds-of-prey-make-them-pray/

Birds of Prey - Make Them Pray

Primer still incoming but will be added when I get the chance, also got a Temur version using Bear Companion if that is wanted

Deck added:

• Messenger Falcons

Gwent share the bear!

@wraya2: Thanks for the headsup! I'll let the team know.

So I was wondering what's your opinion about partners. Yes, I know there is another compendium for that but double uncommon commander feels pretty broken (like if in real EDH you play two regular legendaries instead of the less powerful partners)... Because I would like to try a Etherium Sculptor + this dude here (http://www.mythicspoiler.com/dom/cards/cabalpaladin.jpg) that seems pretty cool.

I think Partners are a neat but iffy idea. There are a lot of ways to break things and it raises the deck complexity a lot. It is also better as a 1v1 format. But it is still a fun experiment. Only rule is that they can't go infinite with each other or 1 other card.

I don't think there are any 2-creatures-combo in pauper... Maybe Archaeomancer and Chittering Rats but it needs some flickers (and even in Duel EDH some cards are banned to be chosen as commanders). As far as now ideas might be:

• Any couple of common creatures
• Any couple of 2-colored common creatures (like the partners in EDH)
• Any couple of common creatures but the deck must be 2 colors or more

You can break and abuse partners, but you don't have to. They can also just be a way to build three-colored decks besides the usual and quite short list of three-colored uncommon creatures; or even four-colored decks, which is otherwise impossible. You can support cool deck themes and enable those you couldn't play without partners.

Commander is a casual format and when you build decks that are not only fun to play, but also fun to play against, there should be no problem with partners, even two uncommons.