I have never been a Blue player. I refused to play anything Blue for years, so when the Commander 2016 spoilers started and I saw Atraxa, I did not even give her a second glance.
A few months later I was checking out at Walmart and saw her precon. I had seen how much her deck had been selling for online and thought I would pick it up with no intention of ever playing it; however, curiosity got the better of me and I started playing with her, growing to love her. In my hateful ignorance of Blue, I failed to see how well it supported my favorite mechanic: Infect. So after many more months of tinkering and playing I present my second favorite Commander.
"Perfection is at hand. You have been freed of weakness and made complete."
With the focus that WotC put into making 4-color Commanders, they created the basis of what these colors do best together: Counters. I have always loved counters, so naturally I am inclined to these colors.
Aside from "counters matter", these colors have all the right things going for them: Ramp, removal, tutors, and counter magic. Therefor the color combination is very interactive and resilient.
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice delivers many benefits. She supports counters exceptionally well, and if her end step proliferation isn't enough, she is a 4/4 for 4 with flying, vigilance, deathtouch, and lifelink...
I play in a super fast, super aggressive playgroup, so sometimes you have to take shortcuts to win. That is another thing that Atraxa allows us to do by virtually taking our opponent(s) life from 40 to 10. With all of the Infect in this deck, she makes getting 10 poison counters on someone a breeze.
This deck is resilient and attritional (not to be confused with nutritional!). The longer the deck stays around, the more powerful it becomes. Any creature can become a giant monster that your opponent(s) will have to deal with.
I think this is what makes the deck so strong. A 2/2 creature is something that will eventually become huge and either force an opponent to remove it or get hit by it. Additionally, once an opponent gets a poison counter they essentially have a maximum of 9 turns before they lose.
Simply put, this deck is overwhelming. It causes your opponent(s) to throw all of their removal out and die from Infect, or try and take you out fast and get hit with a 20/20 double striker that they ignored.
The deck's biggest weakness is Solemnity...just kidding.
All jokes aside, this deck is more midrange than anything. So any deck that makes me unable to get the counters out is bad news. Those decks are either super aggro (see "Feedback" for an example) or super oppressive decks, and force us to use our removal or counter magic and lose tempo.
To elaborate more, play on curve and ramp as much as you can until you can get Atraxa, Praetors' Voice out, and then switch gears to infecting and proliferating. Pump up your creatures and shrink your opponents' until you have snowballed beyond their control.
By mid game all of your opponent(s) should have a poison counter on them. You should also have some Proliferate engines out and should be shrinking down enemy creatures while pumping up your own.
Late game you should already have a bulky battalion of creatures that a Timmy would die for, so this phase is dedicated to topping off all of the poison counters on your opponent(s) and/or smacking them in the face with a huge critter with evasion.
Card Choices Explained
These are mostly just self-explanatory lands, but there are two that I want to specifically mention:
Both of these two provide counters to the rest of my creatures. They are needed to get the initial +1/+1 on everyone in order for me to begin my proliferation spree.
Counter doublers. The difference being that Bubbling Season, otherwise known as Deepglow Skate, doubles counters on any number of permanents and Vorel doubles the number on one specific thing at a time.
Experience counters can be proliferated and then the counters that Ezuri gives to someone can be proliferated. In other words, this is just a whole lotta counter value.
Both of these two are "evolvers" (and no, this isn't a Pokémon reference). So being a 1/1 for 4 or a 1/1 for 2 is justified when that leads to massive card draw and massive ramp, respectively.
These three are grouped together because of their ETB difference. When other creatures, or when "this creature" (looking at you, Rishkar), enters the battlefield they provide counters all around.
A fat, fatty that doubles counters every time he attacks? Sign me, and any Timmy ever, up. This guy basically has a sign on his back that reads: Use your removal on me or get removed by me!
A decent utility creature that can put a +1/+1 counter on a buddy or prevent combat damage. I'd write this up as a helluva lot better than Glacial Chasm. At least in a deck like this.
Basically, this allows for your counters to stick around longer (which you don't need me to explain how nice that is). The longer that Reyhan sticks around, the longer those precious +1/+1 counters get to stick.
This card goes absolutely bonkers with As Foretold. Proliferate every time I cast a spell and pump up As Foretold to play bigger and bigger spells and Proliferate again. Crazy fun synergy there, as well as Tide on its own and you're just by playing the deck.
These two put a -1/-1 counter on creature(s) and Proliferate for added value. Shrink your opponent(s) creatures and pump anything you want with that extra proliferation.
This is a fun alternative win condition. Believe it or not, it is not that hard to get 20+ counters on here in a short period of time, and the indestructibility makes removing this a tough challenge.
One of my favorite cards to play in any green deck, this can (and has on many occasions) win games out of nowhere. Remember when I said everyone loves Infect?
Huge shout out to freakingShane for all the help with this primer! If you are looking for inspiration on primers or spikey decks, go check him or his decks out right here:
I appreciate any and all suggestions, comments, and feedback. If you have recommendations, please try to suggest possible cuts for the replacement. Thanks for stopping by!
Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. This site is unaffiliated. Articles and comments are user-submitted and do not represent official endorsements of this site.