Peaceful_Ninja says... #2
Alright. I think I have seen enough of this play to understand my shortcomings... I do prefer the non token them. That being said persist and undying creatures outweigh my other creatures whom I must pay over and over again to get on the field. So I am working on moving creatures that are less valuable; particularly that don't hit the battlefield after hitting the graveyard. If the come back to hand that won't do with the exception of very very light mana costing cards like Rancor, Bloodghast and the like.I think I am also going to work Gilded Lotus in instead of Thran Dynamo I might keep both... Other cards that do not support this theme and pace will be reconsidered. Should have my revisions up later tonight. Necropotence is looking like is should be in here rather than Dark Prophecy. Stuff like that is going to happen. :)
June 12, 2015 12:12 a.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #3
Have a working copy to keep my ideal changes handy... In the mean time I made a few changes.
in: Birds of Paradise out: Tenacious Dead
in: Rancor out: Sensei's Divining Top
in: Darksteel Ingot out: Golgari Signet
in: Murderous Redcap out: Xenagos, the Reveler
in: Destructive Revelry out: Brood of Cockroaches
These are temporary until I get a few other cards but I think the removal will help me with what is working.
June 12, 2015 1:21 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #4
oh and.. Hull Breach in and Rings of Brighthearth out
June 12, 2015 1:24 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #7
Green blue infect deck slaughtered me. Apparently some spot removal would be of benefit. Abrupt Decay and a couple more might make their way in...
June 16, 2015 12:54 a.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #8
Real debate going on with these choices...
Deathrender vs. Nim Deathmantle
Xenagos, the Reveler vs. Nether Traitor I know they are different beast but which fits in this build better..
More Dual Lands vs Basics and the fetch package I have Cultivate Farseek Skyshroud Claim Terramorphic Expanse Evolving Wilds Solemn Simulacrum
Deathrite Shaman vs Sakura-Tribe Elder
Vraska the Unseen vs Decree of Pain
Decree of Pain vs Reaper from the Abyss
Terramorphic Expanse Evolving Wilds vs Kessig Wolf Run
I do not have a lot of beaters so maybe Reaper from the Abyss instead Sidisi, Undead Vizier? Kokusho, the Evening Star Mikaeus, the Unhallowed Murderous Redcap with Mimic Vat or Cauldron of Souls get a lot done though..
Chime in!
June 21, 2015 6:39 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #9
Terramorphic ExpanseEvolving Wilds trade one out for Sakura-Tribe Elder seems more fitting when I look at it. choices...
June 21, 2015 6:55 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #10
Terramorphic Expanse and Evolving Wilds will go for Sakura-Tribe Elder and Thran Dynamo
June 21, 2015 7:09 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #11
Fetch package:
CultivateFarseekSkyshroud Claim Kodama's Reach Solemn Simulacrum Sakura-Tribe Elder Wooded FoothillsBloodstained Mire
Sac Outlets:
Fleshbag MarauderSidisi, Undead VizierViscera SeerDiabolic IntentPhyrexian TowerAshnod's AltarBirthing PodCulling DaisTrading Post
Sac Fodder Outlets:
Avenger of ZendikarBloodghastBloodline Keeper FlipCreakwood LiegeFeldon of the Third PathMurderous RedcapMyr BattlesphereNether TraitorOphiomancerSakura-Tribe ElderSolemn SimulacrumWurmcoil EngineKher KeepTrading PostRancorAspect of Mongoose
Uility/Card Draw and Shenanigans:
Vicious ShadowsDark ProphecyDefense of the HeartDictate of ErebosFecundityGrave PactPhyrexian ArenaPrimal VigorTrading PostMimic VatSkullclampDeathrenderCauldron of SoulsChromatic LanternVolrath's StrongholdHarmonizeViscera SeerSheoldred, Whispering OneMyr RetrieverMikaeus, the UnhallowedGlissa, the TraitorGoblin WelderHex ParasiteJunk DiverDeathrite ShamanEternal WitnessFeldon of the Third PathHomeward Path
Tutor Package:
Demonic TutorDiabolic IntentSidisi, Undead VizierDefense of the HeartBirthing Pod
Graveyard Recursion:Eternal WitnessFeldon of the Third PathGlissa, the TraitorGoblin WelderJunk DiverMyr RetrieverBloodghastNether TraitorSheoldred, Whispering OneVolrath's StrongholdMimic Vat -- not really graveyard recursion but creature recursion utility!Trading PostAspect of MongooseRancor
Destruction/Removal:
Ghost QuarterAbrupt DecayChaos WarpKrosan GripPutrefyHull BreachDreadboreDecree of PainSheoldred, Whispering OneMurderous RedcapFleshbag MarauderDeathrite ShamanAcidic SlimeHex Parasite --loves Planeswalkers and keeps my persist/undying theme rolling--
June 21, 2015 7:52 p.m.
awesomealex77 says... #12
Your mana base looks really nice. I have to admit though, I am kind of surprised you didn't play a Yavimaya Elder, any reason? He feeds into a skull clamp and your commander amazingly.
June 23, 2015 11:01 a.m.
awesomealex77 says... #13
I played with a Deathrender before in my bant EDH deck, Thrun, the Dank Commander and I took it out after drawing it twice. It just didn't work as nicely as I figured. Maybe you have a better reasoning for it then I did, but I doubt it will work how you want it to. So go with the Nim Deathmantle if its between the two, its just better.
Xenagos, the Reveler looks like a solid card for this deck, Nether Traitor has graveyard recurrence yes, but its just a hasty 1/1 and it looks like you already have plenty of 1/1 generators to feed into Skullclamp or whatever.
Reaper from the Abyss is a solid EDH card. Vraska the Unseen seems a little underwhelming in EDH.
June 23, 2015 11:08 a.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #14
Deathrender attaches to sac fodder and cheats out big nasties I may not have the mana for at the time. It being colorless at 4 it hits the board. After that any top deck creature can be played for 2 -attach-- & --sac fodder-- & --free costing creature--. It may be underwhelming though. With Nim Deathmantle I am not always sure I will have the 4 mana when my NON token creature croaks as this deck is mana intensive.
I like Xenagos, the Reveler a lot also. He just does more and the mana ramp is sweet, not to mention more sac fodder.
Yavimaya Elder was a contender but Sakura-Tribe Elder won out at 1 less mana and just as clampable. The elder is sac ready with a card for 2 so he is definitely worthy.
I really like Reaper from the Abyss, but struggle on what to take out for it... Maybe Deathrender. lol
Thanks for sharing your thoughts awesomealex77!
June 23, 2015 2:03 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #15
Another debate brews:Bloodline Keeper Flip or Myr Battlesphere vs Thopter Assembly The artifact creatures seem relevant as well as getting to recast it. Sac fodder flying blockers are a thing.
June 23, 2015 2:23 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #16
I really like Vraska the Unseen for the spot removal. vs Reaper from the Abyss whhich just deals with non-demon creatures.. She comes out and removes my biggest problem right away.
June 23, 2015 2:30 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #18
Thopter Assembly in Bloodline Keeper Flip will go out...
Xenagos, the Reveler in Nether Traitor out
Phyrexian Altar in Deathrender out
Lastly when I get oneWoodfall Primus will replace Acidic Slime
June 23, 2015 11:34 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #20
Bloodghast out for Strionic Resonator and I am thinking that Harmonize can go and Rings of Brighthearth would be a good trade off
June 24, 2015 9:36 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #21
Okay so after the last edits I am pretty satisfied with my build.
I feel my weakest links are:
Deathrite Shaman -- He is a great card but just doesn't get me closer to winning when I get him out on turn one he still just durdles me along more than affect the board like I want Farseek -- Another solid choice but really only gives me two choice picks to grab out of my whole deck Blood Crypt, Overgrown Tomb. Late game pretty much a dead drawMyr Retriever, and Junk Diver -- Both synergize well in this build but just don't do alot especially early game when I don't have an artifact in my graveyard yet. Glissa, the Traitor, and Trading Post get the job done with much better value
Murderous Redcap -- Infinite combos with a sac outlet and Mikaeus but just think I could do better
Replacements ideas for Deathrite Shaman are: Sensei's Divining Top, Thoughtpicker Witch, Voltaic Key, Killing Wave, and Worldly Tutor
Replacements ideas for Farseek are: Terramorphic Expanse, and Evolving Wilds... Bad idea? Ideas Welcome here!
Replacements ideas for Myr Retriever, and Junk Diver are: Hell's Caretaker, Liquimetal Coating, Merciless Executioner, Parallel Lives, Purphoros, God of the Forge. and Yavimaya Elder
Replacements ideas for Murderous Redcap are: Parallel Lives, Purphoros, God of the Forge, Mitotic Slime, Braids, Cabal Minion, Creeping Renaissance, Hell's Caretaker, and Prossh, Skyraider of Kher
Other cards I am considering swapping include:
Dark Prophecy out for Necropotence
Ghost Quarter in? worth it in this build?
Beast Within will replace Chaos Warp when I get it in hand
I really like Parallel Lives, and Thoughtpicker Witch and I already replaced Farseek for Terramorphic Expanse. Purphoros, God of the Forge looks like a solid choice in this deck as well.
Interested to hear feedback!
June 26, 2015 1:26 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #22
As much as I love Birthing Pod after really looking at my creatures and their mana curve I just don't see it paying dividends. I think replacing it for another card draw engine, mana source, or tutor option would just be more beneficial. I am going to drop in Bloodgift Demon in and take it out. I am open to hearing opinions about this. I just don't think I have enough 2-3 drop creatures to get me what I'd rather have using the pod.
Parallel Lives and Beast Within came in today replacing Chaos Warp, and Deathrite Shaman
I am going to get Thoughtpicker Witch, and Mitotic Slime, they will replace Junk Diver, and Murderous Redcap
The last card on my list is Hell's Caretaker and it will replace Myr Retriever
June 26, 2015 8:04 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #23
I am still on the fence about Purphoros, God of the Forge
June 26, 2015 8:14 p.m.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #24
I went back to Chaos Warp because of the indestructible permanents.
Peaceful_Ninja says... #1
I like but my build is more mono black with a splash of green and red... 3G would be tough to hit and at 8cmc again it bumps my curve which wouldn't be so bad of it were black. Again thank you for your input. I will find a Murderous Redcap. That will make it in..
June 10, 2015 12:06 a.m.