Maybe you should have a bigger maybe board? Maybe.

4x Young Pyromancer would be pretty great in here. No matter what they chose, you get an elemental. Value! Maybe drop some of your 5-6 CMC spells for something a bit more efficient like the Pyromancer. It'll help a TON with consistency. Because after play testing several games with this deck, consistency is what is lacking. Also, if you want to use high CMC spells, Indulgent Tormentor might fit the spot better than the ones you're using.

@Saljen Young Pyromancer is interesting, though the 1/1 army they can make doesn't seem to mesh well with all the AoE removal the deck has. It doesn't fit the theme either.

I think I'll add 1 Indulgent Tormentor to start and see how it does since it's been mentioned multiple times and has potential.

Can you go into further detail about consistency issue? Was it the curve?

I don't know if somebody mentioned this but Grave Pact ?

Grave Pact is pretty sweet, however I feel it doesn't fit the deck too well with only 6 creatures. Also I don't think it fits the theme of the deck.

What about Standstill ?

I feel like this deck could use Desperate Ritual and Seething Song . It would fit into the theme because if you counter them you can't counter future spells but if you don't more spells than you can handle will be played.

Hey I love this idea I just made made my own version that I decided to feature more creatures and focus more on land destruction and forcing my opponent to sac their creeps. Please check it out and let me know what you think.

Any thoughts on Flame Rift ?

This deck looks like a lot of fun! Definitely something to try out!

Looks fun to play!

Oooh, love the deck! Not usually a huge fan of red (both the decks I have constructed on here are blue/black), since fast burn always strikes me as kind of boring, but oh, the trolling. Seems wicked fun to play. +1, and much kudos for this idea.

This is an evil deck that I must play to annoy everybody with.

Wow this is great! I knew about Browbeat but not Blazing Salvo which is OP! I can't wait for my opponent to play a Delver and then for me to Blazing Salvo it! > : ) Turn 2 Dash Hopes is OP as well. And if they do start letting you kill everything and counter everything you can just painful quandary their face bravo!

Quite the devious creation. :)

Found a choice card for the list! Tyrant's Choice

Also, I came across this build because I built a standard deck around the choice theme and liked it so much that I wanted to explore the idea in modern/legacy. Check it out here if you'd like!

Aaaand another one, Nettlevine Blight

Oooooooooh! Great finds there jayprev. Tyrant's Choice in particular lead me to 8 other cards with "Will of the council" effects. Adding them all on the list =)

Temporal Extortion?

Best deck 10/10

So fun, can't help but smiling evilly >:)

I would get rid of one Choice of Damnations and put in better win condition spell at lower mana cost that can stay longer because I think your mana curves a little out reach of beating my deck(a lifegain and card stealing deck(already tested against mine 6 times) have not won with yours). I would go with that old suggestion of Phyrexian Obliterator to replace one.

Wow so fun!!! 3 games, 3 opponents who ragequit!! +1

won by turn 22 goldfishing. woo. I'm probably just playing it wrong.