I am editing the Golgari deck and want to know if these are good edits
Deck Help forum
Posted on Sept. 28, 2012, 4:23 p.m. by CarryOnMyWaywardSon
I got the duel decks today and looked for flaws and looked through my extras and changed a few cards. The cards taken out were:
The cards added in are:
Demonmail Hauberk (I have two of these but cant find a place for the other)
I also want to take out Dakmor Salvage but I wanted to know if anything here thinks it is essential first.
CarryOnMyWaywardSon says... #3
Well since the Izzet vs Golgari decks arent posted on this site I cant.
September 28, 2012 8:04 p.m.
I'm sorry I was unclear. Let me try to explain that differently:
By using the "Deck Builder" link, you can open a link entitled, "Add MTG Deck." You could then title your deck something like, "Izzet vs Golgari Edit," and proceed to enter the decklist in the textbox marked, "Mainboard." In the description, you could credit WotC with the original deck idea, and then list the card cuts and adds for clarity. At that point, people could readily critique your mana base, card choices, curve, etc. You would also be able to add a sideboard, and by linking the deck in the Deck Help forum, you could solicit feedback on your idea.
Of course, you can always leave things as they are with this post, but since most of us haven't memorized the Iz-v-Gol decklist, unless we feel uniquely compelled to look it up online, we won't be in a position to provide you with any substantial, or even useful, feedback.
This would be a good time to mention that, since the above is the conventional and preferred way to submit a decklist on this particular site, not too many people will feel uniquely compelled to look up the original decklist and crunch the numbers on your cuts with pen and paper. It isn't a question of etiquette so much as convenience; all of us exist outside this forum, and the Deck Builder tool allows us to quickly survey a deck and make suggestions without doing lots of legwork. People here are much more inclined to offer feedback if the data is pooled in one place.
September 28, 2012 10:49 p.m.
CarryOnMyWaywardSon says... #5
Oh my... im an idiot -_-... I did not know they all reprints. Im posting it now.
September 29, 2012 8:39 a.m.
CarryOnMyWaywardSon says... #6
its Golgari's Edited Army I will post in the deck help section but I think you could be a essential helper. (You seem the type)
xantm70 says... #2
It might help to list this in a more conventional deck format on the site. The Deck Builder link at the top of the screen will let you set the deck up in an easily readable manner.
September 28, 2012 7:10 p.m.