Additional Mana

Asked by proterran98 2 weeks ago

I have a Hall of Gemstone in play. At the beginning of turn I declare White.

  1. I tap a Wastes with a Overgrowth on it for mana. What do I add?

  2. I have a Island with Market Festival and tap for mana, do I add XX (x being my choice of colors) or ?

  3. I have a Mirari's Wake in play also. With that Island taped for mana, do I get , XX or do I get XXX?

  4. I have Weaver of Harmony in play. Does his ability work on Market Festival? If so, how does that work with the Hall of Gemstone and Mirari's Wake in play?

proterran98 says... #1

4.5 with Weaver of Harmony can I target my Mirari's Wake? If so, does the weaver copy trigger only the next time I tap for mana or does it trigger every time that turn I tap for mana from a land?

December 19, 2024 5:11 p.m.

Neotrup says... Accepted answer #2

  1. You'll add , since Wastes is a mana producing land, but Overgrowth is not.
  2. Same situation, Island will add , but Market Festival will add two mana of any combination of colors.
  3. You'll add plus two mana of any combination of colors. Island added , and Mirari's Wake adds one of any color it produced, which doesn't leave many options. It cannot add one that Market Festival added, regardless of the Hall of Gemstone.
  4. Both Market Festival and Mirari's Wake have mana abilities (which trigger from other mana abilities). Since mana abilities resolve immediately and do not use the stack, Weaver of Harmony cannot target them. Weaver of Harmony can target the trigger from Hall of Gemstone (assuming you control it), which would let you choose a second color. When a land is tapped during that turn, there will be two replacement effects, so the land's controller will get to choose the order in which the effects apply and end up with either of those two colors.
December 19, 2024 5:55 p.m.

Please login to comment