I need to make a correction - when I said "Does it consistently threaten to kill a player off/establish a threatening board between turns 5 and 8?" I meant between turns 8 and 11. The previous point was a mistake and is a speed more consistent with cEDH (bracket 5 decks) on a slower game.

Your deck is on the Help list, and I love Slivers. So tell me, what exactly are you finding is an issue with your deck? Is it lack of consistency? Wins too often? Etc. Also, what's your budget? I can't exactly make informed recommendations if they're just too pricey. Tell me what you envision for this deck.

lhetrick13,

I'm always a fan of Dinosaur decks and am always happy to offer my critique to try and help the deck builder's vision. I don't see any of the current Gamechangers in your list so I must ask - why do you think your deck is a bracket 4 deck? Does it fare well against Stax and Combo archetypes? Does it consistently threaten to kill a player off/establish a threatening board between turns 5 and 8? I'm not trying to say this in a mean way or anything, mostly just curious as to what kind of decks you want this list to be facing off against.

I would suggest the inclusion of some evasion for your Commander. Given the high variance of the format there will be times when Gishath won't be the biggest creature on the battlefield, and therefore won't be allowed to deal combat damage. Including old favorites such as Rogue's Passage or Whispersilk Cloak will guarantee damage and ideally more dinosaurs on your field. On that note, have you considered the relatively new Roaming Throne? It's a great option for doubling your Commander's ability triggers.

You have a cool deck, and I'd love to hear more about your games and victories. I also have my own dinosaur deck. Check it out, give it a +1 if you would feel so inclined:

The Predator of Predators

Commander / EDH Mortlocke

SCORE: 397 | 120 COMMENTS | 49472 VIEWS | IN 162 FOLDERS

I'm curious if you have a special dino playmat, or maybe a special deckbox to house your deck? I recently put in a commission for a deck box for my Dinos and it turned out crazy awesome. Check my deck page for more on that :)

Ah, that makes so much more sense now, MollyMab. I remember this change! It greatly benefitted my playgroup as one of my friends had a Elenda, the Dusk Rose deck. Thanks for the clarification.

yeaGO

I believe there's a bot loose on the site @ julietharald.

I'm just wondering if there is a forums post already made about the new Commander Brackets Beta that was recently announced? Article and Video links are here in case anyone missed it. I'll just weigh in with my two cents - then when an Admin comes along to let me know that this is a duplicate thread i'll just post my opinion there.

I just have to get this out of my system first and foremost:

The RC hardly ever interacted with the community they supposedly represented. They didn't go to conventions to poll players on their experiences, or actively see what they could do to improve the average experience of the game. At times I viewed their opinions as reductive especially in regards to their banning of Mana Crypt:

"In games going over twelve turns, the accumulated threat of damage from Mana Crypt provides a reasonable counterbalance for its explosive effect, but when you are snowballing to a turn-six to -eight win, it's a meaningless drawback. Source

That statement alone is invalidating a whole portion of the group they supposedly represented - effectively stating that anyone who wants to play High Powered or cEDH decks just shouldn't. Not to mention the inconsistency of that logic - why not also ban Sol Ring, Dark Ritual or anything that leaves the player at a net positive for mana? Commander wouldn't be where it is today if games always had to be well beyond turn 8. At best, the RC banned a card because it was too easily abused, at worst they banned a card due to anecdotal evidence. I get that they wanted to help, but ultimately their execution left a lot to be desired.

I'm grateful for Gavin Verhey and his team starting the format down the right path. Now we as players are starting to have a common language to better understand the intent of our fellow players and craft an experience where we can all have fun. I am very optimistic for Commander's future, and will be participating in the Beta at my local venue.

Also, I think that Mana Crypt and Jeweled Lotus will likely see an unbanning in late April - early May.

What say you all?

Hello fellow forum goers,

I have an Edgar Markov deck that I just created a Primer for, and I would very much like an in-depth review on. Additionally, if you see any cards you think that would work well in deck please let me know. Without further ado I present to the world:

The Nobility Are Athirst

Commander / EDH Mortlocke

SCORE: 4 | 3 COMMENTS | 454 VIEWS

Felipix,

I can see that you are starting a Primer, in case you don't have them I suggest the following resource: Epochalyptik's Do you want to write a primer? I've found it useful and hope you do as well. So, first things first I have some questions:

1. What decks do you intend to play with using this deck? Do you want to play in a High Powered pod with degenerate spells like Mana Drain, Force of Will, Winter Orb and the like? Or is this a pod with lower power?

2. What's the budget with this deck? Is it to be in the same mold as an upgraded precon?

3. How do you want to win?

I saw your comments on the Advertise your deck forum, and I can see that you wish to add more draw and more control. In regards to draw I can see that Rhystic Study was suggested before and you have budgetary concerns - there is always the option to proxy. If your playgroup allows it of course.

Possible subthemes/Wincons to consider outside of Voltron: - A flicker (exile a permanent then return it to the battlefield end of turn) subtheme may be an interesting direction to go with this deck. There are numerous options to go with in blue and including creatures such as Thassa, Deep-Dwelling, Scourge of Fleets, Archaeomancer, Spark Double, and Spellseeker to use and abuse their enter the battlefield effects.

• You could try slotting in Pili-Pala and Grand Architect for infinite mana or run Tunnel Vision and then win using Laboratory Maniac/Thassa's Oracle.

Honorable Mentions for fun Control/Card Advantage effects:

• Aven Courier - this guy helps your commander do more of what it likes to do. You should try and slot him in.
• Stormtide Leviathan - this guy can stop combat damage from reaching you for a time
• Faerie Mastermind - fun little taxing effects like this are great because it guarantees card advantage
• Wavebreak Hippocamp - given your deck has a lot of interaction it's likely you could keep up your tempo with this guy out