Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

User769 on "Show and Tell"

3 weeks ago

RobertButler23, do you think it's better to use cards like Force of Will and Force of Negation, or cards like Flusterstorm and An Offer You Can't Refuse?

Lord_Olga on Surveil

3 weeks ago

Icbrgr lol ive never played arena!!! was it an issue? I just really like the dimir guild and making decks with their keywords

Macaronigrill on Living weapon

3 weeks ago

Murrow Thanks I appreciate it!

legendofa on You're looking at your hands …

3 weeks ago

Balaam__ Nice pick! I think that one's almost from the viewpoint of the golem or whatever's being summoned, going off where the leg shadows are coming from. It doesn't show hands directly, so it's an Honorable Mention, but it's perfect for the theme.

bvowles on Pauper Lands

3 weeks ago

I'm going to test out most of these changes then probably make more based on your suggestions. Thanks again.

You make an amazing point about Deprive and Growth Spiral. Also Explore, I've made the cuts you mentioned.

I might need to add more creatures so there's still potential for more cuts to fit some in. Thanks for those suggestions as well.

Optimator on Anarchy Burger

3 weeks ago

You know, Hylda's Crown of Winter might be a good source of card draw. Could protect you early game and then draw you a hefty chunk later.

Icbrgr on Surveil

3 weeks ago

This deck list gave me PTSD from when I used to play Arena regularly lol

Balaam__ on You're looking at your hands …

3 weeks ago

I love collections like these. Here’s one I had to look at twice to make sure—Summoner's Pact. From the direction the shadows fall I’d wager that’s a first person perspective.

Bookrook on Go Too Jail

3 weeks ago

GO TO JAIL. Technically illegal, but it’s not that good and fits on flavor so people should let you play with it.

Derpasaurus17 on G/W Pioneer Midrange

3 weeks ago

Looks like garbage to me :^)

Bookrook on Kaseto, Orochi Archmage Snake Tribal …

3 weeks ago

So sad serpents don’t count as snakes. Koma, Cosmos Serpent is such a ridiculous card.

Tsukimi on Zinnia, a Hare Parent Apparently …

3 weeks ago

chaosshadow589 Thank you! I'd highly recommend it, its a lot of fun, and let me know what you build!

wozislightning on Heavy Grinder

3 weeks ago

I have run Phenax basically since he came out. I like your brew! Here are a few things that work well for me.

Card draw is important: Fallowsage , Into the Story , and Visions of Beyond have put in a ton of work for me. Combo potential: Intruder Alarm , Zellix, Sanity Flayerfoil , and Undead Alchemist all seem to work well with what you already have. Other: Gyruda, Doom of Depths has been an absolute powerhouse for me. Sheoldred  Flip has a decent body and is easy to flip. Silent Arbiter is also good against a lot of go wide decks. Trinket Mage may be small, but it can tutor up sol ring, Alter of the Brood, and Soul Guide Lantern depending on what you need - very versatile. Wight of Precinct Six can get enormous for only 2 mana.

Good luck and happy brewing!

Niko9 on Catti-B's Quiver

3 weeks ago

The Drizzt novels were very fun, I really like how they were like action fantasy, and every part set in the underdark was super creative and vivid. Mtg's forgotten realms set had some absolutely awesome cards flavor wise, even if they weren't always the strongest. Just something like Fifty Feet of Rope perfectly fits it's DnD counterpart of, this thing I put in my inventory and I'll figure out what to do with it later : ) There were so many good flavor cards! The only one that really fell flat for me was Tarrasque just because it missed the ball on what the biggest monster in DnD really is. If they made it a board wipe, like an unbeatable something to restart a campaign, it would have been perfect.

I also really like the card for Catti because it fits her character really well. Being able to both attack on turn and then throw arrows around on opponent's turns really makes her feel like she is everywhere at once with her arrows, and that's so on theme. And I love playing the deck because it's always doing something from the very start.

Those are both really good suggestions or the deck, especially Doubling Season because I do have some enchantment support, but honestly at this point I'm just playing with what I've got and have no plans to buy magic going forward. I've got a lot of random cards to play with and my decks mostly work, and I'm just not really loving newer sets, but both of those could really help the deck!

chaosshadow589 on Zinnia, a Hare Parent Apparently …

3 weeks ago

This deck is hilarious! It's exactly what I was hoping to see from hare apparent. I may have to build something similar!

exarwanfett on Endrek Sahr, Master Breeder

3 weeks ago

Craeter thanks! Yeah, I love playing with it. To be honest cos of all the sac outlets it pretty much goes infinite anyway.

Taida on I like suffering

3 weeks ago

SufferFromEDHD Probably I have to change some of the cards, I am realizing there is a lot of options to consider, but some cards like Sardian Cliffstomper are there just as big things to make it more difficult for anybody to attack me without consequences. Also, hope you can brew something nice with Arashi, the Sky Asunder.

SufferFromEDHD on I like suffering

3 weeks ago

I really like how you have utilized this forgotten gem of jank from Kamigawa block. You have inspired me to explore Arashi, the Sky Asunder this weekend.

Mogg Maniac > Sardian Cliffstomper

Blackgate on Greta’s Revenge (Golgari Cookies)

3 weeks ago

Hello Taycott, appreciate the kind words :) Glad you enjoy the deck.

Taida on I like suffering

3 weeks ago

SufferFromEDHD, the suggestions seem quite good. I just included in the deck general removal, but it is true that allowing my commander more could prove useful. I would love to use Gravity Sphere, but it is completely out of budget, which is a shame.

I will probably look at more options, because I mainly built the deck centered around using Stuffy Doll or similars and shooting it, so maybe I should consider other options if those get removed or do not arrive.

Craeter on Endrek Sahr, Master Breeder

3 weeks ago

This commander is really cool. Imagine if you could remove your creature types for endless value from him. That would be sumtin

Taycott on Greta’s Revenge (Golgari Cookies)

3 weeks ago

Love the deck, love the lore description! <3

TheLazySherlock on Ultimate Sliver EDH

3 weeks ago

Isn't this technically not legal? As a deck it has two copies of Sliver Overlord (commander and in the creatures list?)

Craeter on Catti-B's Quiver

3 weeks ago

Nice I love the Legend of Drizzt novels. I'm not seeing Doubling Season or Ozolith, the Shattered Spire in this list, have you considered those? Pretty staple in counter heavy decks. Doubling Season is a bit pricey, but there are proxies out there for a few bucks.

I'm a fan tho, good work. I didn't even realize they added Drizzt cards to mtg

Lord_Olga on Free Kittens!

3 weeks ago

For lands, Dragonskull Summit is great because it almost never comes in tapped, and Bloodstained Mire is great because you can grab what you need and also by tutoring the lands yoy thin lands out of your deck so you'll be more likely to draw things you need instead of unneeded land

K4nkato on Narset’s Hostile Therapy Sessions

3 weeks ago

Weekly Results:

Atarka Red: ❌❌

Soulflayer: ✅✅

Rakdos Midrange: ✅✅

Never drew a sweeper or a portable hole vs Atarka :(

User769 on "Show and Tell"

3 weeks ago

Thank You RobertButler23, I will adopt

User769 on "Show and Tell"

3 weeks ago

Thank You RobertButler23, I will join

Mannface on Wernog and Hargilde, Investigators!

3 weeks ago

NV_1980

Ah thank you for the feedback, I'm really happy with how this build has tuened out. And that is an excellent suggestion, thank you!

NV_1980 on Wernog and Hargilde, Investigators!

3 weeks ago

Well done on a fantastic looking deck! Wanted to give a shout-out for Nadier's Nightblade (unlike the other pain-cards in here, it actually has you gain life as well as force opponents to lose some). You could probably drop one or two lands in favor of some more content for the deck; with amount of rocks that the deck is rocking :)

griffstick on Dean's car collection

3 weeks ago

Yea but I started this before that announcement

ihatemakingaccountsforthings on Meren Gravestorm

3 weeks ago

Tooth And Nail for Mikaeus + Triskelion is a bit too boring so the combo for this deck is Living Death + Eternal Witness + Craterhoof Behemoth + Concordant Crossroads + Phyrexian Altar. You can make infinite mana with Phyrexian Altar and then reclaim the Living Death with Eternal Witness to create a loop. If you have a lot of mana and one or two pieces of the combo you can fetch the rest of the pieces with Sidisi. Once you are able to get about 20+ creatures going with your Living Death loop the Concordant Crossroads gives the team haste for a finishing move.

Murrow on Living weapon

3 weeks ago

This is seriously awesome!

Frykas on I see doub- triple!

3 weeks ago

Mirrorweave definitely looks like an interesting finisher! I'll see how it does

Apollo_Paladin on Esper Control

3 weeks ago

I'd say working in 4x Raffine's Towers might be helpful; they're by far one of the best things you can fetch into play with either those 4x Flooded Strands and/or the 4x Polluted Deltas you're already running. Also adds card draw late-game when drawing a normal land is otherwise beyond the point of helping.

Balaam__ on I see doub- triple!

3 weeks ago

Mirrorweave and Quasiduplicate are two cards worth considering; both really synergize well with what you’re trying to achieve.

legendofa on Dean's car collection

3 weeks ago

Wait for the Aether Drift set to come out. That set's looking like Motor Sports: the Magicking.

Eloniel on Feather Redeems Boros in EDH …

3 weeks ago

What about Rite of the Dragoncaller, Frontline Heroism and Divine Resilience ?

Divine resilience would be a reusable mass protection since it target.

Lionheart0115 on wolverine

3 weeks ago

Here's some tips to improve your deck. Id tone down your lands from 47 to 38-40 lands. Maybe add some bounce lands like Gruul Turf, Guildless Commons, Arid Archway fetch lands like Evolving Wilds, Terramorphic Expanse, Myriad Landscape, Mountain Valley, Wooded Foothills Prismatic Vista Ect. Theres's way more, but I aint gonna list them all off. That way you'll have more ways to trigger your landfall and in the case of fetch lands, thin your deck out.

Some random cards id look into possibly adding would be Fight Rigging, Bear Umbra Mutant's Prey, Ancient Animus, Pounce, Prey Upon, Pit Fight Boxing Ring Rancor, Alpha Authority, Sticky Fingers, Fireshrieker, Whispersilk Cloak ect

Most of my recommendations either give you access to -fighting (Which would trigger Wolverines +1/+1 counter trigger even when if its not your turn. That way you wouldnt have to rely on someone attacking you and blocking) -Double strike (Since Wolverine doubles damage without saying "Double Strike", He would go from a 2/2 that doubles damage so 4/2 effectively. To a 2/2 that attacks twice and doubles damage, so effectively an 8/2) -Protection (You want him to be really hard to kill even though he has regeneration, plenty of removal still has "This creature cant be regenerated" slapped at the end of it. So Aura's that make Wolverine either even harder to target or respond to before he mops the floor with your opponents the better.