Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Fingall on Bringers of the end

2 weeks ago

add sire of seven deaths

ivaggione on Rec’s?

2 weeks ago

Should be working better now. If for any deck it's not working, please link it here. Thanks!

SufferFromEDHD on Glarb Black Green Blue Creatureless …

2 weeks ago

Tabernacle! You are fortunate enough to own a copy and you have both Urborg and Yavimaya making the mana flow.

Tainted Pact silver bullet tutor

vaholla on Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror

2 weeks ago

Have you tried this deck in a tournament?

Icaruskid on Green Fireball | Omnath, Locus …

2 weeks ago

Risenforce Thank you! It's an unusual deck and so many people have helped evolve it into the fun but effective weird green machine it is today.

And yes! Because Omnath is commonly above 20 power, Life's Legacy, Momentous Fall, and Greater Goodfoil basically read "Draw 15 cards, recast your commander for 5 mana, and still have 10 mana."

vaholla on Kaalia, Mirror Breaker EDH

2 weeks ago

Hello im pretty new to magic, how does the infinite angles work?

Spyrechild on Halvar, Divine Voltron

2 weeks ago

Leyline Axe

So yes I our commander already enables doublestrike but a potrential free play and a source of trample seems neat.

Risenforce on Green Fireball | Omnath, Locus …

2 weeks ago

Looks awesome!

I presume you use cards like Life's Legacy on Omnath, and just re-cast him?

Icbrgr on Formatting a deck to have …

2 weeks ago

I'm pretty sure this is done in the same way you indicate a card is your commander.

Tromokratis *CMDR*

Only instead of that you put however you want the card to be described like "draw" or "removal"

But you also need to check the custom categories box

Fingall on Unleash the Krakens

2 weeks ago

Koma, World-Eater for Colossal Majesty

jonny909090 on Ygra used crunch, it's super …

2 weeks ago

That could be fun, might set that up later. Thanks for the suggestion.

Fingall on Angelic Host

2 weeks ago

1x Path to Exile

1x Swords to Plowshares

1x Serra's Emissary

1x Enduring Angel

1x Giada, Font of Hope update card to new art

DrummerGarrett on Blue/White ALICE Deck

2 weeks ago

Just a note: Kjeldoran Royal Guard can force an interaction with Scars of the Veteran/Sacred Bloom. Allow the attack to hit you, Tap, and then use the desired spell to MAX out the Guard's toughness to serve as an awesome blocker or alternate primary attacker.

Caran_Lyg on Arachnophobia

2 weeks ago

Thanks for the upvote Balaam__. I saw that card before I just keep forgetting to add it here.

Fingall on Alela's Illusions

2 weeks ago

add High Fae Trickster

Abaques on Korn: the 30th Anniversary

2 weeks ago

Rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr u ready??????

Korn's self-titled album was pretty ground breaking at the time. I was listening to a lot of Pantera, Sepultura and Fear Factory when Korn came out. I certainly got into Korn at the time, but eventually my interests shifted into death metal and then eventually into hardcore and punk (before circling back into more of the classics). I think that nu-metal in general was something that got too formulaic too quickly with tons of bands jumping on Korn's bandwagon, but I know it's undergoing a bit of a renascence these days.

KongMing on Ygra used crunch, it's super …

2 weeks ago

Great deck name, your deck categories should also match Pokemon references. Lands = Energy/PP, Reanimation = Revive, Ramp = Boosting, Buffs = Items, Removal = OHKO/Super Effective, etc.

Balaam__ on Arachnophobia

2 weeks ago

One of the better spider decks I’ve seen. Do you think Swarmyard is worth including?

blong217 on Defiler Wombo Combo

2 weeks ago

Seuchenschutz all great suggestions. I was looking through cards as possibilities thanks to the concerns you made and a card showed up that I couldn't believe I didn't consider. Sage of Hours

Lord_Olga on Silence in the Library

2 weeks ago

Follow up comment, same question as before since I saw you deckcycled again

bryanedds on Double Dragon

2 weeks ago

Bulk Up huge here (the card, not the deck).

bloodredChili on The Imitation Game

2 weeks ago

In/Out

OUT:

  • 1x Phenax, God of Deception (SLD)
  • 1x Jace, Wielder of Mysteries (SLD)
  • 1x Temple of the False God (OTC)
  • 1x Oskar, Rubbish Reclaimer (NCC)
  • 1x Tainted Strike (SOM)
  • 1x Lazav, the Multifarious (MKC)
  • 1x Laboratory Maniac (TSR)
  • 1x One with the Multiverse (BRO)
  • 1x Blue Sun's Zenith (STA)
  • 1x Jace's Erasure (M11)

IN:

  • 1x Kami of the Crescent Moon (SLD)
  • 1x Mana Drain (CMR:637)
  • 1x Abundance (CMM)
  • 1x Mission Briefing (MKC)
  • 1x Lazav, Dimir Mastermind (ZNC)
  • 1x Go for the Throat (BRO)
  • 1x Tooth and Nail (MMA)
  • 1x Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth (M3C)
  • 1x Angel of Suffering (SNC)
  • 1x Essence Harvest (AVR)

Apollo_Paladin on Griff-Griff

2 weeks ago

Ultarian Yeah that's not an unfair call at all now that I consider it more. Cheers!

Severin-buttercup on Mono Black Bittercontrol

2 weeks ago

I am toying with the idea of having a bunch of 1/1 creatures in combination of Ensnaring Bridge..

hootsnag on Glarb Black Green Blue Creatureless …

2 weeks ago

I thought about adding that. I will consider it

blong217 on Defiler Wombo Combo

2 weeks ago

Seuchenschutz Crossroads is the enabler to finish them immediately. Though Vivien and Alchemists Refuge can let you do it at the end of an opponents turn going into your turn. Essence warden and innkeeper offsets the life loss by gaining life for every creature entering.

PyroBerserker on Rise of the Griffins

2 weeks ago

TheVectornaut Thank you for all of the hints/tips! I feel like i'll probably try to do something with lifegain instead as you make several very vaild arguments for it. I'll finagle with it a tad and see how it pans out!

Optimator on Obligatory Settlement Joke

2 weeks ago

I love it! Brilliant deck name, too.

Seuchenschutz on Defiler Wombo Combo

2 weeks ago

I can see more or less how your combo works, but how does it finish? I see how you can put almost all green creatures in your deck out and put many +1+1 counters on them, but without Concordant Crossroads you wont be able to finish and the next board wipe will be your demise. You also get a lot of damage from defiler.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

2 weeks ago

"Create a card that shows a feeling of relief."

ok.


Sweet Release of Death

Instant

Sacrifice a creature you control. You gain life equal to its power plus it's mana value. Exile your graveyard.

"Unlike the others," Edgar growled with a sort of twisted-delight, "your death will mean something."


Make a new keyworded mechanic.

Avacyn1986 on Phyrexia

2 weeks ago

Update: It's devastating...

Gidgetimer on Why is WotC Reducing the …

2 weeks ago

"I hope this doesn't seem too disagreeable, but I don't know how you can argue Commander doesn't have some fairly strict rules about decks..."

My comment was in direct response to someone using the format philosophy to try and backup that Tutors are antithetical to the format and quoting "promote an environment where players are not pressured to conform to any specific method of deckbuilding" to me. I realize that the social contract imposes deck building restrictions. As a matter of fact I specified "You just have to make sure that everyone's expectations are the same within a pod".

If you don't want to include tutors, that is fine. If you don't want to play against tutors, let me know. If you want to act like you are somehow playing a more "pure" version of commander or that commander isn't for me because I run tutors, get out of here with that.

zn.tportlock on My spells are your spells

2 weeks ago

Rev, tithe extractor is great

ProspectiveGIS on Can I get Some Help?

2 weeks ago

TheForsakenOne Thank you.

I removed Ob Nixilis of the Black Oath and Gonti's Machinations, and added back in Peer into the Abyss, good suggestions. Made a fair amount of changes as well, mostly to help ramp mana and lands.

TheVectornaut on Rise of the Griffins

2 weeks ago

While I like the idea of the current enchantment combo, I don't know that it's really necessary. Privileged Position already protects your stuff without the need to get out 2 cards. Further, turning all of your lands into enchantments opens you up to instantly losing the game to something like Spring Cleaning, although players are more likely to play mass wipes that will also destroy or exile their permanents due to Enchanted Evening's symmetry. Speaking of, you can try to take advanatge of that symmetry in other ways like playing Azorius First-Wing as an unblockable griffin, assuming you don't mind going into blue. Otherwise, I'd still try to upgrade the griffins here to be a little faster and more impactful. Diving Griffin and Resplendent Griffin have the potential to be better than Sunspire Griffin, depending on the final build. Fearless Fledgling and Griffin Rider are both aggressive options to shore up the 2 slot in a way I think would be more impactful than Crashing Drawbridge or the currently underwhelming Pearl Medallion. Finally, Wanted Griffin may be better than Senate Griffin at 4, again depending on what your game plan ends up being. Mutavault and Metallic Mimic are some less budget friendly options that could help the tribe's limited card pool.

As for anthems, I usually prefer the 2 cost options to the 3, although I do like Always Watching. Honor of the Pure is the vanilla option while Rally the Ranks or even Obelisk of Urd could fit in a tribal shell. One thing I thought of while looking at the high number of white pips making the Medallion worse was that you could lean into that and go for a mono-white devotion build. Some anthems like Flowering of the White Tree and Benalish Marshal already fit well in such a deck. You'd definitely want a playset of Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx and some sort of payoff for the extra mana like Elesh Norn, Grand Cenobite, Walking Ballistafoil, or whatever other bomb you prefer. You'd also want something to play on 1 for that strategy. War Falcon has some synergy with Griffin Rider, Esper Sentinel is a generically powerful draw engine, and Weathered Wayfarer is a classic way to find Nykthos. War Falcon also brings to mind the idea of leaning more into broad flying support like Sephara, Sky's Blade and Rally of Wings, although I acknowledge going down that path could severely dilute the tribal identity of the deck. One final approach I can think of is pivoting to focus on lifegain to use the Griffin Aerie in your maybeboard. You'd definitely need cheaper ways to gain life than True Conviction, especially since I think it's already one of the weaker cards in the deck. The reality is that you'd probably be nudged towards splitting the griffins with angels to take advanatge of Angelic Accord, Bishop of Wings, Speaker of the Heavens, and even Archangel of Thune. Outside of that, the options are more limited. Maybe mass lifelink could be made cheaper with Metallic Mimic plus Envoy of the Ancestors or Abzan Battle Priest. This is the only route where I actually see Path of Bravery being worth it.

griffstick on Card creation challenge

2 weeks ago

Im working on a deck for a friend. He wants all altered art cards made by me.

enter image description here

enter image description here

enter image description here

enter image description here

enter image description here

enter image description here

And his cmdr is

Migloz, Maze Crusher

enter image description here

I just wanted to share them with you guys. I was gonna do the wildcard challenge with this same presentation but it took too long.

legendofa on Card creation challenge

2 weeks ago

wallisface Is your Rat Colony slow and expensive? Just add The Abyssal Chronicles, and watch it take off!

Crushing Headache

Sorcery

Target player discards two cards.

Threshold - If you have seven or more cards in your graveyard, that player sacrifices a creature.

Delirium - If you have four or more card types among cards in your graveyard, that player loses 2 life.


Create a card that shows a feeling of relief.

Craeter on Our Lord and Master Gitrog

2 weeks ago

Is Conduit of Worlds on your radar? Could provide some redundancy for Crucible if it's not drawn or destroyed.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

2 weeks ago

Oh btw, yes The Imperial Fists is actually my favorite legion in 40k.

I was introduced to 40k maybe in 2006? But I never had the time, money or friends to actually pick it up as a hobby.

Still kept up with the lore and books, though.