Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Lord_Olga on Living End [Primer]

3 weeks ago

This is a fun idea!!! Ever thought about using a Tormod's Cryptfoil to make sure your opponents dont get to revive anything?

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

3 weeks ago

Drylagon, The Mountain

Legendary Creature - Turtle Elemental Beast

Indestructible, shroud, trample

Drylagon can't be untapped unless you pay

All creatures must block Drylagon if able.

Whenever Drylagon deals combat damage to an opponent, destroy up to one target nonbasic land or up to two target basic lands they control.

12/12


How's that for Abzan, seshiro_of_the_orochi?? :D

Obviously Drylagon is from Ikoria. Obviously.

Make another Abzan commander!

philias on Card creation challenge

3 weeks ago

Vula, Young Hemomancer

Legendary Creature: Human Wizard (Uncommon)

When ~ takes damage, it does that much damage to any target.

2/3


Falnik, Prodigal Pyromancer

Legendary Creature: Human Shaman (Uncoomon)

; Scry 3, then draw a card. ~ takes 1 damage

1/3


Maha, Esteemed Lithomancer

Legendary Creature: Human Wizard (Uncommon)

Whenever you would draw a card, instead scry 1, then draw a card.

2/2


Wild

SkittleBread on atleast its not goblins

3 weeks ago

I love the idea of using the mono red aggro tools to win off poison. if you feel like your wanting more removal you might make all the mountains snow covered mountains and add Skred. if youd ever consider adding green id suggest Ancient Stirringsfoil to search for those infect creatures. but seriously cool stuff!!

Metropolis39 on Mono Blue Dreadmaw $20

3 weeks ago

good thoughts and yes i agree. but this is supposed to just be a $20 deck but yeah. some protection might be good

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

3 weeks ago

Niabel, Hazeshroud Slayer

Legendary Creature - Human Warrior

Flash

Vigilance

When ~ enters, prevent all combat damage that would be dealt this turn.

Whenever damage is prevented, distribute that many +1/+1 counters among any number of creatures.

: Prevent the next 3 damage that would be dealt this turn.

3/3


We need more Abzan commanders anyway.


Wild

AzureCuzYeah on [EDH] Hazezon

3 weeks ago

Any updates to the deck? It has been 6 years and I can imagine a lot of worthy changes to this deck.

Balaam__ on Jund at Home

3 weeks ago

@Profet93 Depending on the matchup draw can be an issue, but in aggregate it’s performed decently well. This is an older build that hasn’t been updated in quite awhile, so with all the latest sets Pauper has seen a bit of mild power creep. Perhaps some additional draw options wouldn’t be a bad idea.

Profet93 on Jund at Home

3 weeks ago

Caran_Lyg - Mom can I get some jund from Balaam__? No, we have jund at home

How has Faithless Looting been playing for you? I know it loots and helps with card quality. I do wonder how you are with card draw as a result. You have 2 cards that can draw you cards, but I also understand this format doesn't necessarily need as much draw as EDH

Caran_Lyg on Jund at Home

3 weeks ago

@Balaam__. This Jund is not bad at all, unlike the Jund my mom bought for us.

jethstriker on Mark Rosewater's Comments on the …

3 weeks ago

If I remember correctly, old rulebooks defined Interrupts as a type of card that targets another spell (ex.Counterspell). With the release of Classic 6th Ed. also came a major revisions of rules. And one of them is simplifying card types, merging Interrupts to Instants.

Bookrook on Mark Rosewater's Comments on the …

3 weeks ago

Some interrupts were also permanent, like Thoughtlace. Alchemy in its earliest form.

legendofa on Mark Rosewater's Comments on the …

3 weeks ago

Bookrook Pretty much, yeah. That's the main concept.

Once an interrupt was played, you couldn't do anything else but play another interrupt. It was "faster" than instants, like activated abilities and instants are "faster," than sorceries.

SufferFromEDHD on Oloro's Eternal Bargain

3 weeks ago

Absorb worth it

Pristine Talisman consistent triggers

Echo of Eonsfoil epic alongside your big creatures

Bookrook on Mark Rosewater's Comments on the …

3 weeks ago

Interrupt is basically split second but you can play interrupts in response, right?

Noobybro_ on Storm doing what storm do

3 weeks ago

I made a Storm deck list using neoform to OTK if you have any recommendations they would be greatly appreciated. It's called Storm's Neo Storm.

hyalopterouslemur on Green Fireball | Omnath, Locus …

3 weeks ago

Ah, classic Elfball. You might want some lifegain so that you survive your Hurricane tho. Maybe give a creature lifelink somehow?

Oh, and Squallmonger loves Snake Umbra or Keen Sense.

BioProfDude on Tinker Time - precon

3 weeks ago

I think you have this listed in the wrong format!

BasilBlair on izzyphonics

3 weeks ago

+1 into the flood maw

sergiodelrio on Pattern Recognition #342 - Goblins, …

3 weeks ago

Goblin Game

Sure, not an actual goblin, but goblin themed and goblin art.

How tf is this black border?

BasilBlair on izzyphonics

3 weeks ago

-4 thing in the ice +3 artists talent -2 chart a course +2 ledger shredder

Gleeock on Mark Rosewater's Comments on the …

3 weeks ago

flash is more common than ever

GuztheManII on Storm doing what storm do

3 weeks ago

I was trying to avoid them cause I don't wanna destroy my friendships.... but I'm making a more powerful version of it with a few to really break it. Adding some double strike and other stuff.

grave_lord on Oozing Fun

3 weeks ago

Ender02 Hey, it’s very unconventional so I can’t blame you for the first comment XD. It is pretty funny when people see the helix ask what I’m doing and then I exile two slime against humanity under it. (Whenever a slime against humanity is cast the helix triggers and puts a copy of Slime against humanity on the stack.)

EchoSpice on Golems And Stones May Break …

3 weeks ago

Welp, accidentally hit the wrong button and added this to the feature queue XD. Oh well. Cool deck!

void.braun on suspend deck

3 weeks ago

removed zodiac dragon. deck currently needs another card to be a completed deck

EchoSpice on Jadzi, Oracle of the Storm

3 weeks ago

Neat deck! Cant say ive ever seen this commander be built :D I’d recommend some big payoff blue spells like Aminatou's Augury or Omniscience. Mnemonic Deluge too!

Blackgate on Raid

3 weeks ago

Very cool deck. Always wanted to build around Obosh, the Preypiercer!

Tenin on err

3 weeks ago

No

Planeswalker_X on [EDIT] Mikaeus, the Unhallowd + …

3 weeks ago

After play testing... Mikaeus on the field and 2 open mana is all you need with Ballista in hand. If you can put a single +1/+1 counter on Ballista by paying , Ballistas ability can then ping himself in the face with that +1/+1 counter. Killing himself and starting the undying loop.

Noobybro_ on Storm doing what storm do

3 weeks ago

Extra Turn Spells are Broken with Storm btw

Planeswalker_X on [EDIT] Mikaeus, the Unhallowd + …

3 weeks ago

Proved myself wrong lol. The +1/+1 from Mikaeus means you need any sac outlet to start the engine here...

Planeswalker_X on [EDIT] Mikaeus, the Unhallowd + …

3 weeks ago

This is certainly not true. This combo needs nothing else other than Mikaeus on the battlefield and Ballista in your hand. No mana needed at all.

1.With Mikaeus on the field, cast Ballista from your hand for 0. He enters the battle field as a 0/0 and gains Undying (checked with judge, Ballista does gain Undying before state based actions kill it for being a 0/0). Ballista dies, Undying triggers and Ballista comes back with a +1/+1 counter.

2.Remove that counter ping opponents face. Ballista dies. Undying checks for a +1/+1 counter on ballista. It does not have one. Therefore ballista returns with a +1/+1 counter from Undying.

3.Remove that counter ping opponents face. Repeat. Repeat. Repeat. Game over.

4.Prove me wrong.

knucklekustard on Sneak Orb

3 weeks ago
  1. Palladia-Mors was my first consideration for a cut, and my partner actually did suggest Symbiotic Wurm for the death trigger, so I'll playtest this. My main concern was that Wurm doesn't have flying or trample and 7 damage from insects is nice, but it's next-turn damage.

  2. I'll test this, too. Though I've mostly done fine having 8 tutors, I guess more Sneaks is more chance of a faster win.

  3. I totally agree with having 1 copy for a tutor... I find it hard to discern when it's best to run 3 or 1 copies of something at times, usually for situational/non-stacking effects. Orb could even be sideboarded but I do like the disruption it gives.

  4. Erratic Explosion is awesome. Oddly, it might incentivize a lower creature count... which could be the chance to slot in Bolts. But 16 damage isn't shabby if I've already hit with something and don't have creatures in hand - since Gamble is my only creature tutor (and unreliable).

Thanks for your comment. I might also reconsider Icbrgr's suggestion to run a counterspell, at least in the SB, in case I'm facing another combo or heavy removal. And maybe mainboard Ancient Tomb + ditch City.

warshipgod_2 on Enchantment Angels

3 weeks ago

last updated after Duskmourn

StarRushford on Rhys of the Elves

3 weeks ago

Add Ghalta and Mavren, it can get out of hand VERY quickly. Especially with your Doubling Season, Parallel Lives and Rhys the Redeemed. That will be 5 attacking 12/12s with trample the turn after Ghalta and Mavren comes out. The next turn, if you used Rhys the Redeemed, that'll be 32 dinosaurs, but if you attack with Ghalta and Mavren again, that'll be 37 12/12 dinosaurs with trample. In 3 turns. That are attacking.

Epidilius on Going beyond 40 lands if …

3 weeks ago

Bookrook I think you meant to tag me about the homebrew mulligan rule haha. To respond to your concern: that is not something that has ever been considered. If you don't trust the people you play with, then just don't do mulligans this way. This is why you talk about stuff like this before you play. If I sat down at a table and tried this without discussing it, I would expect to be called out for it immediately.

For context, I have two playgroups, each having a pod of 4-6 players (depending on who shows up to my place/the LGS), and we use this rule. The only deck that isn't allowed to do this is the No Land Narset combo deck lol. Similarly, when we play our more tuned decks, we don't do this.

StarRushford on Steves deck

3 weeks ago

how are you doing the full-art custom cards?

nuperokaso on Sneak Orb

3 weeks ago
  1. Instead of Palladia-Mors, play Symbiotic Wurm. It will leave 7 creatures behind after dying, allowing them to finish the job.
  2. Playing only 2 Sneak Attack is a huge mistake. Your deck does pretty much nothing without it. Play 4.
  3. Undiscovered Paradise works with Winter Orb. As for the orb, play 1 if you must as a tutor target. But it's situational.
  4. Since you are already playing Draco, you could add Insidious Dreams and 1 Erratic Explosion. However, that will only deal 16 damage, so unless you add some other burn, it will be useless.

DrummerGarrett on Blue/White ALICE Deck

3 weeks ago

Replace 1 copy of Swords to Plowshares with something more accessible like Portent, Enervate, Lat-Nam's Legacy, or something like that.