Barjack521 on Budget Foodchain Tazri
3 weeks ago
Thanks for making this. It looks really interesting to pilot, what upgrades would you recommend if budget wasn’t an issue? Or do you have a compete cEDH non-budget list to compare too?
Baron777 on Going beyond 40 lands if …
3 weeks ago
So I have tended to notice some of my decks, particularly my Jund (non-landfall) decks, seem to always start lacking in lands whenever I play. I have upped the lands from 36, to 38, to 40 now and still a majority of my games I need to go down to 5 or 4 cards to get a starting hand of a minimum of 3 or even 2 lands. Even then I'll also not typically see a land draw until turn 3 or 4.
There are also a healthy number of mana rocks/dorks as well as some ramp, and my curves for these decks tend to put around 40-60% in the 2-4 CMC range (more of a general trend, as this isn't the place for a deck by deck analysis)
So what would be the advice here?
-Run more lands? 42-45, or should I go higher? -Add more ramp options? -Add more mana dorks? Something I'm missing here?
SteelSentry on Are there any flavor/biological reasons …
3 weeks ago
I think Phoenix as a type lives in the same boat as Ninja, where the creature type is evocative of its mechanical function; Ninjas could just be called Rogues, but they're attached to being either unblockable and/or the Ninjutsu mechanic.
As for could they change them, I would like to say no, but they literally just changed all Nagas to Snakes, erasing their cultural baggage their inclusion had, and changed Viashino, an original race that's closest to the Dragonborn from D&D in origin, into just being lizards. The latter I'm personally upset by because not only is it something that only exists in Magic, but you may as well call Dragons lizards as well, or combine Demons, Devils and Tieflings into one race.
Bookrook on Using shrazarad
3 weeks ago
That’s good to know for the Psychic Surgery deck with sharazad I’m building.
Craeter on The Forces of Light
3 weeks ago
Ah yes, The most OP of colors IMO. Nice work here! I have a lot of suggestions if you wanna shell out some $$ to make this even more powerful just lmk
sandwich_steve on Vish-ing for Compliments
3 weeks ago
Illusionist's Bracers let's you double up the counters and removing counters on both of Vish Kal's abilities.
Also due to his high cmc, I run Mindslicer to threaten/control opponents' hands. Sac at instant speed if they target Vish. Then different options for resurrection.
AWebb on Help with my Vampire Blood …
3 weeks ago
See the thing is, is that I haven't bought it yet and the only thing I've been able to use is to test it is that playtest button in here. So, I'm not sure if there are any problems with it. Sorry!
Xtough on Doran, the Tiny Leader
3 weeks ago
I like the verstility of Inscription of Ruin in tiny leader. Maybe exchange for Treasured Find? (Maybe Regrowth woukd be better if this recursion is absolutely necessary?)
Icbrgr on Damnatio memoriae
3 weeks ago
Looks like you need to make some cuts... i think Telepathy is an easy out because its redundant with your Commander ability? obviously they aren't the same but idk just trying to help trim the list a bit.
Icbrgr on Hatsune Miku Superfriends
3 weeks ago
well thanks just by seeing this decklist im gonna have that polka leek dance song in my head lol
Icbrgr on Modern Through Vengeance
3 weeks ago
how about now does this fix it? (you may have t click the see latest version tab up top)
Icbrgr on Modern Through Vengeance
3 weeks ago
is is it the decklist itself or the pic quality that hurts?
ShadowMasterNL on Red's Best Stax? - Plargg …
3 weeks ago
Use snow mountains instead, since youre using extraplanar lens! (yes, that works)
Seuchenschutz on Give em Helga ( Helga, …
3 weeks ago
Hi I actually think that a good approach to Helga. You can take a look at my deck, maybe you will find it useful: https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/helga-fatties/
ChaosJester on Using shrazarad
3 weeks ago
I have a shahrazad deck full of Wish cards. You play Shahrazad, then a subgame starts immediately. In the subgame, you play Wish and wish for the Shahrazad in your graveyard from the main game, etc. The wincon is decking out your opponent in the best case because at some point after 20 Subgames, there will be no cards to draw and they lose immediately.
TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge
3 weeks ago
My year has been largely uneventful lmao
Just working my butt off and paying down credit card debts. So, I'll make Pacman!
Pac-Man
Legendary Creature - Hero
Vigilance
At the beginning of your upkeep, whenever you play a land or whenever Pac-Man attacks, create a pellet token. It's a colorless artifact with no abilities.
Sacrifice 3 pellets, : Draw a card and put a +1/+1 counter on Pacman
Sacrifice 5 pellets, : Gain 10 life.
Sacrifice 10 pellets, : If the current turn isn't an extra turn, take an extra turn.
4/4
Make Steve from Minecraft. He must:
- Be at least three colors
- Have the Landfall ability
- Care about your choice of artifacts and / or enchantments OR
- Create some sort of interesting token
SufferFromEDHD on Doran, the Tiny Leader
3 weeks ago
Wall of Essence and Wall of Souls finish out the rest of the Stronghold uncommon walls
Spidersilk Armor solid anthem effect
Vessiliana on Help with my Vampire Blood …
3 weeks ago
AWebb, in practice, do you find the deck to stall out? Or to run short of mana? You might want to trim your curve a little if that is the case.
Ender02 on Oozing Fun
3 weeks ago
Spellweaver Helix does nothing in Commander. How can you cast a spell with the same name as one of the exiled ones if you can only have one of each spell in your deck?
I guess you could do it to someone else's graveyard, but what are the chances that you are running 2 of the same sorcery cards that they are, both of which happen to be in the graveyard, and then you have to find one of those two cards in your 99 to play after. It seems to leave a lot up to a very slim chance for the possibility of getting one free spell, possibly two. Granted there are ways to get those back and recast them again, but that requires even more setup for very little.
vic on Can a Conspicuous Snoop plus …
3 weeks ago
Rhadamanthus Thanks, that's what I thought. It came up in a playtest situation in a Krenko, Mob Boss commander deck. So big yes on that last part.
Lord_of_Lords on Svyelun: The Way of Water
3 weeks ago
Thank you for the upvote and suggestion! Not sure about Step Through though, or adding any sorceries. I haven't run any in this deck for a while and it makes me happy having 36 lands, 36 creatures, 16 instants, 6 enchantments, and 6 artifacts. I run Step Through in my wizard-typal deck though.
Ender02 on All Planechase Cards (WHO INCLUDED)
3 weeks ago
This isn't all of them.
At current count, there are 151 unique Plane Chase cards.
40 from the original 2009 release 40 from the 2012 release 25 from the 2023 March of the Machines release (there were 50 in the set, but 25 were reprints) 40 from the Dr Who release 6 Promo cards that were re-released as the Anthology Set
Darb_the_Bard on Buttercup: Princess Bride
3 weeks ago
I think it would be too low of an impact for this deck.
lukecwolf on Surfing the Dragoon Waves
3 weeks ago
Hey Minicoopflo. In short, modern has really turned into modern horizons the formats. Decks without any support from them really struggle.
The equivalent of this deck, boros burn, (mostly red stuff) got a huge upgrade and lots of wins with slick-shot but immediately got powercrept with MH3.
For silver bullets, this deck is guaranteed to lose if an opponent sides in Leyline of Sanctity
There are simply better ways to spend $200 with MH3.
Even if you were to play modern without modern horizons, dragons are a silly gimmick that usually need a different color identity. Blue for tempo control, green for ramp, etc.
I think what the creator did was upgrade a game night precon, which is made to be more casual. This probably accounts for its weird gimmick.
Muirina on Slushy Whimsy ascended
3 weeks ago
https://mtgcardsmith.com/view/slushy-whimsy-ascended?list=user
sanarthra217 on The Road to Death
3 weeks ago
This deck is illegal and invalid with more than 100 cards in a commander deck. Just so u know
sandwich_steve on Pattern Recognition #342 - Goblins, …
3 weeks ago
My favorite is Festering Goblin because he's just a cute little feller.
AstroAA on Share your hidden gems
3 weeks ago
I love Enduring Renewal for the absolute shenanigans you can do with sac outlets.
When paired with something like Aluren and a sac outlet like Phyrexian Altar, you can loop any creature with CMC three or less infinitely and gain infinite mana and infinite ETB effects of said creature. In addition if you have something like Dauntless Escort you can sac them and then get them back and play them again.
There is a TON you can do with Enduring Renewal. I just think it's neat.
hyalopterouslemur on Share your hidden gems
3 weeks ago
Banding's fine. I just don't see the point of bands with other.