Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Malicious on Fumulus Edictocrats

3 weeks ago

I think its impossible for anyone to know every card that exists, so I'm always looking for suggestions for cards that I might not have thought of, or might have a good synergy/interaction with cards I'm already using

Goldberserkerdragon on The Conjunction of the Spheres

3 weeks ago

800 views!? Wtf you feeding this thing man?

Profet93 on Fumulus Edictocrats

3 weeks ago

Malicious

What kind of suggestions r u looking for?

All is Dust - Wipe that sacrifices and hits enchantments.

devolovsk on Ignore maybeboard for calculations

3 weeks ago

My maybeboard is included in my mana curve and color pie; how do I only display my main board?

emberryanss on Bant Enchant Edh 2025 CEDH …

4 weeks ago

I feel like crackdown is okay because my main goal isn't to win by combat in group play

emberryanss on Bant Enchant Edh 2025 CEDH …

4 weeks ago

pretty sure Platinum Angel needs to be dropped

UltimateRoxas40 on Glissa the Traitor, Phyrexian Golgari …

4 weeks ago

I'm flattered that you used my deck as an inspiration! I hope you have fun running it.

Tsukimi on Can't Catch Me, I'm the …

4 weeks ago

Craeter Thank you so much for feedback! I am planning to edit the primer for readability and I will add in accordions, thanks for the tip.

For Brenard, one of the reasons I enjoyed building him is he encourages you to forgo a lot of staples so instead of swiftfoot boots we have cards like Benevolent Bodyguard and Selfless Spirit etc. Targeted exile spells can be hard so I'm considering adding Linvala, Shield of Sea Gate for that. If someone tries to slap something like Darksteel Mutation on him we also have Foundation Breaker, Skyclave Apparition, etc. Having all this protection be creatures can have drawbacks but with Brenard it's usually the opposite.

Love the feedback! You're right there's so many directions Brenard can go as such a versatile commander I just happen to love how good he is for populate (:

B_Boy_Crumps on Rebbec and Silas

4 weeks ago

Planned additions for Aetherdrift: Valor's Flagship Repurposing Bay Oildeep Gearhulk Mendicant Core, Guidelight Haunt the Network Guidelight Pathmaker The Aetherspark Starting Column Muraganda Raceway Amonkhetraceway

magwaaf on Miirym's Myriad Mirrored Multiplicative Menagerie

4 weeks ago

lol, ok i was looking for the mechanic. here's mine

https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/cloning-around-3/

pinecone2k3 on Avian Uprising

4 weeks ago

If I was a member of your pod, I would totally vote to allow you to run Crow Storm in a Rule Zero discussion.

Profet93 on Can't Chat Despite Being an …

4 weeks ago

I am finally able to see your message now and just replied.

Craeter on Can't Catch Me, I'm the …

4 weeks ago

Also PS - Accordions are super easy to do. You just click the button, put the title, and copy paste the text inside of it.

Content goes here

Content goes here

Craeter on Can't Catch Me, I'm the …

4 weeks ago

This is sweet (lol) ~ Bant is prolly my fav Tri color combo. It looks like you've got it pretty well dialed in for the particular game plan you've got going on.

Maybe consider is some targeted protection for your commander. Staples like Lightning Greaves, Swiftfoot Boots. Lesser known DFC Sejiri Shelter  Flip.

There are lots of options for messing with the opponents game plan too, but maybe not enough room in this deck for those. Things like more Counterspells, Control (Opposition is a fav of mine, especially with tokens), commander disabling Darksteel Mutation.

You've also got lots of ETB effects. Those could be abused with Brago, King Eternal, Teleportation Circle. I know the game plan is to just sac them off, but Blink is also an option for added value.

Board wipes could also be good in here. Being able to remove an untargetable enemy Voltron commander for instance, but also your own board, however you still have the Gingerbread men surviving the wipe. It could turn the tables in a clutch moment.

Just some stuff to think about. Honestly as it is the deck looks fantastic. Bant has a ridiculous amount of directions it can be taken.

markbeloit on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Unnatural Eruption

Sorcery

Destroy target land. Unnatural Eruption deals 13 damage to target creature.

Overload (You may cast this spell for its overload cost. If you do, change "target" in its text to "each.")


Not sure if it'd be something Avos saw, but once I thought up this card I wanted to put it down.

Wanted to call it Volcanic Eruption or Violent Eruption but those names are taken (sigh)

Repeat challenge (see above).

philias on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Avos, Scholar of the Mother Star

Legendary Creature: Elemental Advisor

Flying

Whenever ~ enters the battlefield, create three artifact tokens with "At the begining of your upkeep, put a charge counter on this artifact."

Remove all counters from an artifact you control, put a creature or enchantment with mana vlaue equal to the number of counters removed this way from your hand onto the battlefield.

2/4


Avos created a tome spanning hundereds of pages to log his many studies on the planets the other vayith would condition. He would study everything from the wildlife, to the flora, the geography and the climate.

Create a legendary instant or sorcery representing one of the pages from Avos' tome. The page itself can do and cost anything

markbeloit on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Eska the Joiner

Legendary Creature - Human Shapeshifter

Soulbond (You may pair this creature with another unpaired creature when either enters. They remain paired for as long as you control both of them.)

Eska the Joiner has the abilities of the creature it's paired with.

The creature Eska the Joiner is paired with gains flying, haste, lifelink, trample, and vigilance.

3/3


A different take on soulbond :)

Wild.

Femme_Fatale on Can't Chat Despite Being an …

4 weeks ago

You can see who is being selected because the panel with that user's name is highlighted. Try again with me to see if it works.

shwebby91 on Mono-Green Hydra

4 weeks ago

Here's my deck, feel free to message me more about it!

Craeter on Super Smash Bros.

4 weeks ago

+1 for the name

I like the group smash ideas getting thrown around in here, as well as some underrated old school cards. Nice work.

My only suggestion would be cards like Zendikar Resurgent to double mana late game, so you can group smash even harder with your commander. Plus creature ETB draw for added spam. The 3 mana activated ability is a lot if you're also playing other cards, so mana doublers would help with that.

Some other mana explosion possibilities: Nyxbloom Ancient, Doubling Cube, Mana Reflection

Balaam__ on Basic Commander Deck: Made by …

4 weeks ago

You can change the format to Commander by selecting it under the Edit Deck option. It’ll let you display your commander up top too for all to see.

Balaam__ on Tripwire

4 weeks ago

An easy path to improvement in speed and consistency would be to add some form of dual land. While you don’t currently have this tagged as ‘Budget’, I’m guessing from the overall price estimate and the fact there are no costly cards here that you’d like to keep it as low as possible (which is perfectly understandable).

In lieu of the obvious go-to selections like Marsh Flats and Godless Shrinefoil which can be quite expensive, there are some decent alternatives. Try looking at Concealed Courtyard and Caves of Koilos or even Isolated Chapel and Shineshadow Snarl.

You’ll want to avoid anything that has an ‘this card enters the battlefield tapped’ anchor chained to it as that will only slow you down, but otherwise it’ll only be a strict improvement if you can acquire some inexpensive lands that provide both and .

RandomPoem on 002

4 weeks ago

1x Anara, Wolvid Familiar 1x Armasaur Guide 1x Belligerent Yearling 1x Bellowing Aegisaur 1x Burning Sun's Avatar 1x Carnage Tyrant 1x Deathgorge Scavenger 1x Descendants' Path 1x Dinosaur Stampede 1x Finale of Devastation 1x Flaming Tyrannosaurus 1x Garruk's Uprising 1x Grave Sifter 1x Heroic Intervention 1x Invasion of Ixalan 1x Jetmir, Nexus of Revels 1x Kodama's Reach 1x Kogla and Yidaro 1x Majestic Heliopterus 1x Marauding Raptor 1x Mirari's Wake 1x Needletooth Pack 1x Poetic Ingenuity 1x Polyraptor 1x Quakestrider Ceratops 1x Raging Regisaur 1x Raging Swordtooth 1x Rampant Growth 1x Ranging Raptors 1x Relentless Raptor 1x Return of the Wildspeaker 1x Ripjaw Raptor 1x Savage Order 1x Scytheclaw Raptor 1x Shifting Ceratops 1x Siege Behemoth 1x Silverclad Ferocidons 1x Skarrg Goliath 1x Spined Tyrranax 1x Sun-Blessed Mount 1x Swooping Pteranodon 1x Thundering Spineback 1x Titanoth Rex 1x Trapjaw Tyrant 1x Tyrranax Rex 1x Verdant Sun's Avatar 1x Wakening Sun's Avatar 1x Wayward Swordtooth 1x Yidaro, Wandering Monster

philias on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Woat Recruiter

Creature: Giant Turtle Barbarian

Enlist for each creature you control with 6 or more power

, sacrifice a land; put a 6/6 green turtle giant creature token that can't block onto the battlefield

"Every woat not in our ranks will." Bram to Maavro

0/6


Make a human with soulbond

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Pelemini, Scriptology Mentor

Legendary Creature - Kor Cleric

Whenever an artifact card leaves your graveyard, put a +1/+1 counter on each creature you control.

, exile a card with mana value X from your graveyard: Scry X, then draw a card. If X was 8 or higher, draw two cards instead.

1/4


Professor of Symbology taught me there are Kor on Arcavios. Didn't know that. I was today years old.


Create a card that creates 6/6 tokens that can't block.

DreadKhan on Voja, Bitey Elves

4 weeks ago

Have you thought about throwing in Timber Wolves? The idea is you attack in a band with Voja, so if anyone throws something like First Strike Deathtouch blockers in your way you can make them all hit the Timber Wolves, allowing Voja to survive. Its also a card if Voja attacks since it's a Wolf, and if you're desperate and need a blocker the Wolves can absorb all of the damage of a creature with Trample.

Maybe Maskwood Nexus? It'll make everything a wolf AND an elf, seems decent?

Sombertone on Voja, Bitey Elves

4 weeks ago

Another single change, I have never used Birthing Boughs to make a changeling and always discard if first when I have to. Throwing in a Timberwatch Elf both as a nod to my elf decks of the past and because giving Voja a big chunk of bonus P/T might just close out a game with commander damage.

doktoras on Mono Blue Delver (Tempo)

4 weeks ago

VitsEco That is a replacement for Ceremonious Rejection. Thank you.

Andramalech on Kuroikage

4 weeks ago

Bookrook I've been waiting to add it as a one of for the list at the barem8nimum, because it could be so useful! Especially since I think Urza's Saga would fetch it, so if I run Mishra's Bauble then it might have some kind of utility. Will see what's up!

Hornetsting86 on Golgari Death Toll

4 weeks ago

Good but really I think more stitcher's supplier as it mills 3 rather than gnawing vermin's two.The -1 ability when it dies is a consideration.

Cloudy2024 on Golgari Death Toll

4 weeks ago

try Gnawing Vermin to get stuff in the bin.

K4nkato on Painting Lotuses

4 weeks ago

Weekly Results:

Rakdos Transmog: ✅✅

Rakdos Sac: ✅❌✅

Atarka Red: ❌❌

2nd Place!

Ventys_Grimm on Infinijani's Myriad

4 weeks ago

The final fortune combo doesn't give infinite turns. At the end of the first turn you lose the game. So you never get to the next turn.

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Zanta, Archdruid of Alara

Legendary Creature - Elf Druid

Plants you control have reach and banding.

At the beginning of your upkeep, create a number of 0/1 green Plant creature tokens with defender equal to the number of lands you control.

The world shall bend to the whims of evil, no more.

3/3


Make Banding Great Again

Anyway, let's see a legendary Kor.

Bonus points if he or she is from a plane other than Zendikar. Which frankly should maybe be the case by now anyway but so far that's the only world they inhabit.

Abridale on Bootlickers

4 weeks ago

worst deck ever

Bookrook on Kuroikage

4 weeks ago

Just saw the new the last ride coming out in aetherdrift.

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Soo have you heard of my favourite new phrase? ;D


Praise the Lava!

Legendary Sorcery

As an additional cost to cast this spell, you may sacrifice a legendary creature. If you do, copy this spell.

Add seven .

Until end of turn, whenever a source you control deals damage, it deals twice that damage instead.


Create a legendary druid.

kamarupa on You Go Squirrel

4 weeks ago

Thanks so much for the +1 and comment, Cloudy2024. I dunno. I'm fairly partial to both Abrupt Decay and Assassin's Trophy. Not that Fatal Push is a bad card by any means.

philias on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Reyland, Archduke Justiciar

Legendary Creature: Angel Advisor

Flying

Whenever a creature does damage to you, exile that creature

; Choose target creature that can attack before attackers are declared; that creature attacks a player of your choice this turn.


Make a legendary instant or sorcery