Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Valengeta on The Misanthropic Guide to Knowledge

4 weeks ago

Made_Compleat thanks I know about the Battle type cards but unfortunately I can't open a spot in the deck for them because their effects don't quite justify it. The deck works well as it is anyway

Xalor90 on Set You Off Like a …

4 weeks ago

Cloudy2024 it definitely can; it just depends on what you draw in the early game. I could see either one of those being quite effective in this deck.

Crow_Umbra on Please Delete Thread

4 weeks ago

Hey Baron777, please check out these international Suicide Hotlines and give your country's a call. Temporary problems don't need such an extreme and permanent means of resolving them.

kamarupa on Pussy on F I R …

4 weeks ago

With only one green creature, I'd consider dropping Madcap Skills for Brave the Elements, which gives you wide evasion for a fatal swing as well as wide protection from removal.

kamarupa on Halo, and Welcome!

4 weeks ago

Thanks so much for the +1 and thoughtful suggestion, KongMing! At first I couldn't believe I didn't know about Jaheira, Friend of the Forest, but it seems she's not legal in Modern, so that could be why. If she were, I'd def be forking this deck to include her.

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

TypicalTimmy, legendofa: Both of these are extremely cool!

Oh, and "Praize the lava!" is definitely my favourite new phrase.

veritablecvn on Pattern Recognition #353 - Fetching …

4 weeks ago

I'm a little confused about your statement that Evolving Wilds and Terramorphic Expanse cannot search for Wastes. You said 'These are Fetches that appear in common or Uncommon, and are cards that when sacrificed, go for a Basic Land with a Type (No Wastes!)' but the cards say 'Basic Land Card' not 'Basic Land with a Type.' Wastes are a basic land so I do not understand why they're not a legal target.

RandomPoem on actually a Sab-Sunen deck

4 weeks ago

1x Banner of Kinship 1x Bloodline Pretender 1x Door of Destinies 1x Dour Port-Mage 1x Elusive Otter 1x Evolution Witness 1x Ezuri, Stalker of Spheres 1x Fisher's Talent 1x Fortune Teller's Talent 1x Fuel for the Cause 1x Gift of the Viper 1x Gossip's Talent 1x Grolnok, the Omnivore 1x Haze Frog 1x Inspiring Call 1x Jade Avenger 1x Leyline of Transformation 1x Lightning Greaves 1x Long River Lurker 1x Maraleaf Pixie 1x Metallic Mimic 1x Mistbreath Elder 1x Murkfiend Liege 1x Omnibian 1x Ornery Tumblewagg 1x Papercraft Decoy 1x Patchwork Banner 1x Polliwallop 1x Pond Prophet 1x Prime Speaker Zegana 1x Realmwalker 1x Reclamation Sage 1x Reflections of Littjara 1x Reject Imperfection 1x Rishkar, Peema Renegade 1x Roaming Throne 1x Scavenging Ooze 1x Serum Snare 1x Simic Charm 1x Simic Manipulator 1x Snakeskin Veil 1x Splash Portal 1x Steady Progress 1x Stickytongue Sentinel 1x Tainted Observer 1x The Thirteenth Doctor f 1x Three Tree Scribe 1x Thrummingbird 1x Trollbred Guardian

CNG_Stream on Brightglass Gingerbitch

4 weeks ago

Also just realized you could consider using Nurturing Pixie as a searchable creature that you could use to pick gearhulk back up to replay for more triggers. Not too sure how well work, but another card to consider.

CNG_Stream on Brightglass Gingerbitch

4 weeks ago

Sorry for double Comment. System showed Error when trying to post the first, so I tried to resubmit and it seems it posted twice.

CNG_Stream on Brightglass Gingerbitch

4 weeks ago

Considering your equipment are both legendary, I am not sure you want to run 4 copies of each. In particualr I do not see the value of 4 copies of Tarrian's Soulcleaver as you are not doing anything that particularly helps this card grow your creatures a significant deal. I think the Basilisk Collar might be a more useful equipment if you wnat a utility equipment, but if you really want the vigilance then I would suggest Kor Halberd as it gives you a +1/+1 by default. Making sure to suggest equipment that are still one drops due to you building around the gearhulk.

Sadly there is not All That Glitters style of card in standard for this idea, but the gearhulk does search for enchantments as well. So cards like Ethereal Armor and Shardmage's Rescue are probably a really good cards to consider for this deck if you decide to shift to enchantment synergies instead of equip. Considering the Gearhulk gets to search 2 cards, the idea of the Shardmage's Rescue seems like a great include as it gives you a protection spell you can search for along with 1 other card. This also means you cna shift into using cards like Optimistic Scavenger as a good 1 drop to search for as well, but that might be a different idea if you want to try that as it would focus more on enchantments.

Lastly you might want to consider Goldvein Hydra. This spell counts as a 1 cost while in deck, meaning that if you can search out this X power vigilance, haste, trample creature at anytime and even get 2 of them so when the first bites it, you can spend all the treasures made from it to power up the second.

CNG_Stream on Brightglass Gingerbitch

4 weeks ago

Considering your equipment are both legendary, I am not sure you want to run 4 copies of each. In particualr I do not see the value of 4 copies of Tarrian's Soulcleaver as you are not doing anything that particularly helps this card grow your creatures a significant deal. I think the Basilisk Collar might be a more useful equipment if you wnat a utility equipment, but if you really want the vigilance then I would suggest Kor Halberd as it gives you a +1/+1 by default. Making sure to suggest equipment that are still one drops due to you building around the gearhulk.

Sadly there is not All That Glitters style of card in standard for this idea, but the gearhulk does search for enchantments as well. So cards like Ethereal Armor and Shardmage's Rescue are probably a really good cards to consider for this deck if you decide to shift to enchantment synergies instead of equip. Considering the Gearhulk gets to search 2 cards, the idea of the Shardmage's Rescue seems like a great include as it gives you a protection spell you can search for along with 1 other card. This also means you cna shift into using cards like Optimistic Scavenger as a good 1 drop to search for as well, but that might be a different idea if you want to try that as it would focus more on enchantments.

Lastly you might want to consider Goldvein Hydra. This spell counts as a 1 cost while in deck, meaning that if you can search out this X power vigilance, haste, trample creature at anytime and even get 2 of them so when the first bites it, you can spend all the treasures made from it to power up the second.

VitsEco on Mono Blue Delver (Tempo)

4 weeks ago

A couple of copies of Consign to Memory in the side would go along way.

Andramalech on Kuroikage

4 weeks ago

Cloudy2024 yes, this started as a deck I drafted into cockatrice for play testing. I ordered the deck because it was a lot of fun to play, and is now used against my younger brother from time to time.

Cloudy2024 on Set You Off Like a …

4 weeks ago

cool deck,do you get opponents down enough cards to use The Rack of Shrieking Affliction?

legendofa on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Baraton, Reckless Geomancer

Legendary Creature - Human Shaman

Protection from lands

You may play an additional basic Mountain each turn.

Mountains you control have ", : This land deals 1 damage to each creature."

5/6

"What do you mean, dangerous? I'm still alive, right?"


The last ability is lightly stolen from Koth of the Hammer, and Baraton is absolutely in the Seething Song-Pyretic Ritual-Geosurge "praise the lava" stance in the art.

Create a druid's grove.

Blackerhawk on (Sk)Elemental Beatdown

4 weeks ago

Thanks for the suggestion, but I don't think that works as you don't cast the creatures from the graveyard if you use Unearth and Thunderkin Awakener, you put them onto the battlefield. It does work with the Firebolts but it's not worth putting it in just for those.

emask on Alora, Eat the Rich

4 weeks ago

Thanks! While it would work for Alora's ability, it wouldn't let me keep stolen creatures with the "until end of turn" wording unfortunately. Sending a stolen creature back to its owner's hand with Alora isn't too shabby though when you have no way of sacrificing them. Thanks for checking it out!

TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Infernus, Maw of Hell

Legendary Creature - Hellion

Double strike, trample, haste

You may play two additional lands per turn.

Landfall - Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, Infernus deals 3 damage to you and you put a +1/+1 counter on it.

2/5


Protip: Put lifelink on him to effectively cancel it out.


Repeat because I'd love to see what other designs can be made from it.

Kersa on Time to die, mutie.

4 weeks ago

you could probably put a Vesuva in, and replace tainted wood and temple of malady with Path of Ancestry and Reflecting Poolfoil

vensers journal is really expensive for infinite handsize and your draw doesnt seem that great to benefit from the healing maybe use Reliquary Tower or Thought Vessel instead, or if you just want infinite hand size a Spellbook works too

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Please Delete Thread

4 weeks ago

Caerwyn, this seems like a thread that shouldn't run that long, I assume?

Baron777: I suggest you contact an appropriate place of psychological support in your country, or at least talk to a person you trust so they can support you in getting help.

If it's meant as joke: Not funny.

Edgapuffloe on (Sk)Elemental Beatdown

4 weeks ago

The card Burning Vengeance might be alright, it's basically a free firebolt whenever you use Thunderkin Awakener and Unearth. The mana cost might be too much though

seshiro_of_the_orochi on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Omnath, Locus of Growth

Legendary Creature - Elemental

Whenever two or more lands you control enter at the same time, choose one:

  • Create a 2/2 blue elemental land creature token with flying.

  • Put a +1/+1 counter on each land creature you control.

  • Scry 2. Draw a card.

3/3


Create a monored legendary creature that gives you additional land drops.

Brinckenberger on Edgar Vamps

4 weeks ago

Dropped Nomad Outpost, added Cavern of Souls.

Chaise on The Best Defense Is A …

4 weeks ago

if i play Eerie Interlude and on a later turn all the returned creatures die am i able to bring them all back from my graveyard to my hand with dusk/dawn?

philias on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Raz, Conditioner for the Mother-Star

Legendary Creature: Elemental Shaman

Flying

Whenever a creature you control takes damage, add

When ~ does combat damage to a player, it does 1 damage to each other creature.

3/3


Make another elemental

Baron777 on Please Delete Thread

4 weeks ago

Please Delete Thread

Cloudy2024 on Kuroikage

4 weeks ago

you should try Night's Whisper as is good to re-load your hand and lose life.

RandomPoem on 403

4 weeks ago

1x Abrade 1x Akki Blizzard-Herder 1x Arena of Glory 1x Blood Moon 1x Blood Sun 1x Braid of Fire f 1x Cemetery Gatekeeper 1x Chrome Mox 1x Crawlspace 1x Crucible of Worlds 1x Darksteel Citadel 1x Enchanter's Bane 1x Gilded Lotus f 1x Glacial Chasm f 1x Hearthborn Battler 1x Hedron Archive f 1x Leyline of Punishment 1x Magus of the Moon 1x Mana Geyser 1x Molten Psyche 1x Pristine Talisman 1x Razorkin Needlehead 1x Resurrection Orb 1x Shadowspear 1x Stigma Lasher f 1x Thran Dynamo 1x Tunnel Ignus 1x Winter Moon

Cloudy2024 on Don't

4 weeks ago

cool deck, try Koma, World-Eater instead of the other koma.

griffstick on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

enter image description here

Wildcard

Cloudy2024 on Kuroikage

4 weeks ago

have you got the deck in the flesh?

Idoneity on Comb the Desert!

4 weeks ago

When did you upvote it? Now. Wait, when? Just then. I thought you did now! No. That was then, but now is now and then was then. When was then? We just missed it.

KongMing on Halo, and Welcome!

4 weeks ago

Seems good. I could imagine a Naya version with stuff like Jaheira, Friend of the Forest and global Haste that might let you combo out faster.

KongMing on Alora, Eat the Rich

4 weeks ago

Cool deck.

If you add Sundial of the Infinite, you can end the turn on your end step as Alela's trigger goes on the stack, so you don't have to bounce your creature. You can stack the end of turn give-back triggers on stealy cards the same way, and keep someone's creature for good.

DopeyTheCat on Tripwire

4 weeks ago

Thank you! I will look into these cards!

philias on Card creation challenge

4 weeks ago

Primeval Beast

Creature: Beast

Trample, Ward - tap three lands you control

Whenever you cast a creature spell, put a 3/3 beast creature token onto the battlefield.

Whenever you cast a non-creature spell, put 3 +1/+1 counters on a creature you control.

Whenever a land enters the battlefield under the battlefield, you gain 3 life.

6/6


Make a red-green, non-black, zombie

Akromathia on Izzet Double Draw (Do's and …

4 weeks ago

OMG you really really need to update thos thing to 2025! Please!

Cloudy2024 on Tripwire

4 weeks ago

Nighthawk Scavenger,Mirri the Cursed or Kalitas, Traitor of Ghet would up the power level and are cheap(ish). Also Gifted Aetherborn would be a good addition and replacement for Healer's Hawk as it doesn't really fit with the vampire part of the deck anyway. overall an awesome deck and definitely deserves an upvote from me!

DopeyTheCat on Tripwire

4 weeks ago

Thank you for the upvote! I'm glad my deck had an impact. :)

Lewtonium on New hubs to be added

4 weeks ago

Can there be a "Pinger" tag eventually? As in It deals one damage.