Vessiliana on The Cult of Astarion
1 month ago
roseofizzet, thank you so much! Let me know how it works for you! <3
TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge
1 month ago
Zarroth, Archangel of Basking Flames
Legendary Creature - Angel Cleric
Flying, vigilance, haste
When Zarroth enters the battlefield or attacks, she deals damage equal to any target equal to the number of lands you control.
4/7
Lopul, Archdruid of Elincia
Legendary Creature - Dryad Druid
Hexproof, defender
At the beginning of your upkeep, you may reveal cards from the top of your library until you reveal a land. Put it into your hand and put the rest on the bottom of your library in a random order. If you do this, skip your draw step.
You may play two additional lands during each of your turns. They each enter tapped.
0/9
Naya lands matter
So we have cards such as Jhoira, Weatherlight Captain, Shepherd of Heroes & Rakish Crew in which a group of cards are given a name.
In this case: Historic, Party and now Outlaws.
Your challenge is to make another grouping of cards. Don't forget to list what they are!
- Note: Notice for Historic it is permanent types, whereas for Party and Outlaw it is creature subtypes. Don't feel like you need to list creature types only; You could make use of any cards you'd like.
Hell, you could even do "Gatewatch" that cares about Gideon, Jace, Liliana, Chandra and Nissa cards! :D
Necramus on Killing with (Konrad)
1 month ago
Femme_Fatale thank you so much!!! I'd send you tacos, if I could!!
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Wakeen Phoenix
1 month ago
Clicked on the list because I wondered how you'd manage to do Taii as a phoenix tribal. Then I spoke out the name and audibly rolled my eyes. This earned you an upvote xD
Regarding any suggestions: You already have Boros Reckoner in here. How about also including Stuffy Doll, Brash Taunter and other similar effects?
Femme_Fatale on Inventory minus cards in Decks
1 month ago
It's still in the suggestions trello but there is a lot of backlog to get through.
Femme_Fatale on *SOLVED* Do Flip Cards Count …
1 month ago
I noticed you changed the title to solved, mind posting what you found the solution to be? I want to make sure it isn't a bug.
Femme_Fatale on Killing with (Konrad)
1 month ago
Finally found the image for it, I figured it'd be a manga promo, but finding the source image took a considerable time.
And I didn't even know the new home page got changed. I had nothing to do with it. I just add cards.
purelycryptic on *SOLVED* Do Flip Cards Count …
1 month ago
I am creating a Commander deck that I have lined up one-for-one on what I own and what I have listed on the deck here, but its numbers aren't aligning with what I have.
I triple checked, and the only thing I could think of is if this might be the issue since I have a few "Flip" cards in it?
Thank you, and sorry if this is not the possible problem, I am really finicky with this type of stuff and want my Commander deck to correctly come up as "legal" to play with as well when I have finished it lol.
SOLUTION: I was over cataloging and posted up the flip sides as well as the non-flips in their respective card type categories.
purelycryptic on Inventory minus cards in Decks
1 month ago
This, absolutely, it would be nice to see the progress I have made in getting these cards into my deck VS my inventory and have like-a seamless transition.
nbarry223 on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread
1 month ago
I am hoping that fixing the meld/flip issue fixes the “ghost” other category in custom categories, where no cards are attached.
I will report back if it doesn’t once it is updated.
AncientIron on "Whale" UW Control
1 month ago
Cloudy2024 I think you are partly right that proliferate could potentially have a place in this deck in terms of helping walkers and the whale, but mostly it comes down to that specific end loop of managing to get them both out at the same time. Generally I feel the whale needs protection as well as a way to get damage in overall - proliferate only solves a smaller part of that problem. It dedicates separate spells to bolster those things, but they don't necessarily win the game through excess proliferation (more of a byproduct of the whale being the win con, you could construct a deck that makes proliferation the point and combo out that way, but this is more of a control theme)
wolfhead on Mono Blue Control-Tron
1 month ago
Oooh spell burst is sweet
I use Shark Typhoon in my blue tron deck,
Especially after the mana value rework, it's great with X spells
Femme_Fatale on Adding brackets to commander decks
1 month ago
As for the actual features we have to wait on yeago. There's nothing I can really do about this right now beyond doing some simple systems design about how it can be implemented here.
AzureCuzYeah on Yarok + Energy = Fun …
1 month ago
Aetherdrift adds some value with Nissa, Worldsoul Speaker, Rampaging Aetherhood, and Aetherflux Conduit
Femme_Fatale on Adding brackets to commander decks
1 month ago
I've messaged Gavin wondering why tappedout wasn't contacted but I have a hunch it's because of the site's lack of social media presence making it hard for other businesses to contact this one.
Femme_Fatale on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread
1 month ago
Yeah I already had a fix submitted for that one FakeHair the site just needs a database push for it to process. Nothing I can really do about it to make that happen.
Tsukimi on Card creation challenge
1 month ago
Kevi Ser, Tower Smuggler
Legendary Creature - Kor Rogue
Goaded creatures your opponents control have Menace.
: Target goaded creature cannot be blocked this turn.
2/2
"Right this way"
Ok so we gave esper goad! Now lets pick another shard color combo and give it a theme demonstrated by partner commanders.
freddiefrick on Smokey's Nightmare
1 month ago
Thanks for the suggestion! I did consider it, but ultimately have abandoned this build of the deck since it’s so commander centric. Since building this deck, I’ve iterated on burn in commander a few times and I feel happier with Boros or Orzhov builds of the archetype. Someday I’ll build a mono red deck for commander, but I don’t think it’ll be Imodane.
Crow_Umbra on Adding brackets to commander decks
1 month ago
Linking the Bracket article for reference to anyone who hadn't read up on it yet. Given that today's announcement is for the Beta version of this system, with a proposed revisit in late April to account for feedback, I'm fine with Tapped Out rolling a flag/feature closer to then.
From some discussions I've seen across social media today, I'm seeing a sentiment that the "Game Chargers" lists are still kinda incomplete. I don't expect these lists to be exhaustive out the gate, but having a general sense of the Bracket parameters is helpful.
I think a more complicated future wrinkle for the Brackets will be taking mana base consistency into consideration beyond fast mana or powerful utility lands like Gaea's Cradle or Glacial Chasm, etc.
Moraff on Adding brackets to commander decks
1 month ago
I second this. It seems that other deck building locations have already rolled out the system. =/ Possibly unfair competition?
ChurchOfJorts on YEEHAW: Treasure Boogaloo
1 month ago
2/11/25 Updates
Swaps
- Swamp for Witch's Cottage
- Boggart Trawler Flip for Hellkite Tyrant
- Throes of Chaos for Dragonhawk, Fate's Tempest
- Exotic Orchard for Atsushi, the Blazing Sky
- Izzet Chemister for Tor Wauki the Younger
- Geothermal Bog for Foreboding Ruins
- Urborg Volcano for Tainted Peak
- Valakut Exploration for Count on Luck
- Cinder Barrens for Command Beacon
kamarupa on Don't
1 month ago
While I don't recommend it, as it really puts a target on your dorks, if you have Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy in play, a Freed from the Real on a Birds of Paradise or Noble Hierarch would generate infinite mana. There's certainly enough protection with current Instants, though, if you wanted to go that route. Bloom Tender would another solid choice to include then, if you felt so inclined.
I definitely think the manabase could be improved on. It seems there's no budget for creatures, but lands are all budget? So I was hesitant earlier, and didn't have the time either then to make a case for improvements. That said, 1x Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth is, IMO, always worth whatever mana-fixing it provides opponents. After that, I tend to prefer Botanical Sanctum, Dreamroot Cascade and Barkchannel Pathway
Flip to the perennially desired Breeding Pool
and Misty Rainforest. I just can't stand the thought of burning 3 life to get one dual land. I usually also include Scavenger Grounds just on the off chance I face a deck that likes to bring stuff back from the graveyard.
I didn't see you asking for removal spells, but Beast Within is decent, IMO, and I wouldn't turn my nose up at any deck running Pongify or Rapid Hybridization, especially if the deck is also packing creatures that can block those 3/3 gift tokens.
While it's a bit gutsy to rely strictly on mana dorks for the white mana needed to cast Gods Willing, I rather like the idea of an unblockable swing thanks to its protection.
In my eyes, the biggest weaknesses are: Opt doesn't provide any card advantage. Divination would be better, and Harmonize better still. Hydroid Krasis, as I said before, seems to fit as well and comes with the bonus of a bit of lifegain which is never bad. And that leads to the next issue - the wincons are [almost] all legendary, and therefore rightly limited to less than 4 copies each. I do like that they come with their own means of preventing removal, though. And finally, that the mana base just isn't as premium as most the spells it supports.
Don't
by goblin4god
LunchBox1211 on Card creation challenge
1 month ago
Aura of Leadership
Enchantment - Aura
Enchant Creature.
Enchanted creature has +2/+2, First Strike, and Mentor.
Radiance - Whenever ~ leaves the battlefield, all creatures that shared a colour with the enchanted creature deal 1 damage to any target.
Aura Swap
Fortheboys11's original challenge was skipped. Go to their post with Esper Legalist, look at the creature, and then do their challenge. I'm curious to see what happens.
Flarhoon13 on Dollar General - Krenko, Baron …
1 month ago
Skirk Prospector is the best goblin at any price. This looks great. Too bad Krenko, Tin Street Kingpin is too expensive, eh?
Dadbod81 on Adding brackets to commander decks
1 month ago
Just wondering if there are plans to flag the bracket of a deck for commander players as we adapt to the new structuring of deck?
Sliverguy420 on Don't
1 month ago
i'd recommend cutting birds and kinnan for Arbor Elf and Utopia Sprawl, then cutting Yavimaya Coast and adding Misty Rainforest and Breeding Pool. 7 mana cards are a bit expensive for modern, but Elder Gargaroth is pretty nice. i'd cut the Gods Willing since you have no lands that produce white. Ram Through is probably your best removal option in green if you stick to tramplers.
Don't
by goblin4god
DarkKiridon on Froggies
1 month ago
MTGShiddur, The Gitrog Monster is not in this deck's color identity.
NonetheWeisser on Pussy on F I R …
1 month ago
Thank you for your kind words! That guy got super rude with me so I had to block him. I've worked hard to make cats as competitive as they can be. I've tried almost everything (3-4 years in the making). They are the best they've been and have a lot of potential. That being said, they definitely don't have enough hits to make Coco worth it. That's why we lean on our 1 drops and early aggression with the auras.
Balaam__ on Pussy on F I R …
1 month ago
I don’t have any amazing insights to give you NonetheWeisser, but I just want to post that I don’t think CoCo is a good fit for the list you’re currently running either. It’s as you said, too many non creature cards to fizzle out on. Maybe there will come a time when we get more feline support and some new cats make a few of those instants/enchantments redundant, at which time CoCo will be a better fit, but until then my thoughts are ‘if it isn’t busted, don’t mess it up’.
ouroborobelisk on Oops, All Bugs!! 2: Electric …
1 month ago
Oh man, that combo win is so convoluted & involved, and I'm friggin' here for it! It makes Gitrog's 4 horseman combo look easy LOL!
RufusTheGrufus on Anikthea's Enchanting Recycling Plant [Primer]
1 month ago
Tsukimi, you and I are on the same wavelength; I was super pumped when the newest zombie precon was spoiled and I saw On Wings of Gold and Renewed Solidarity (as well as Hour of Victory, Momentum Breaker, Dredger's Insight, March of the World Ooze, and to a lesser extent Point the Way which also seem spicy for Anikthea)!!
I was waiting to revisit this list until they were added to Tappedout, and since they're linkable now, it looks like it's finally time!
Goldberserkerdragon on The Wizard of Death & …
1 month ago
Yo NV_1980 Uhhh I would say yes generally but specifically in Nevy you want as little artifacts as possible. But definitely good to think about, even if they existed for one turn. But usually in terms of blinking we can sac/rean Nevy whenever.
NonetheWeisser on Pussy on F I R …
1 month ago
Barely any competitive zoo or stompy decks in the current meta run Coco. It's too slow and easy to counter. Being able to double or triple spell reliably each turn is much better in the interactive format. Our enchantments provide us with early game aggression that cats thrive on. Removal is needed because cats do not have any interaction of their own. My build currently has a 78% win rate in my local meta. Again, I have been playing cats competitively and successfully for 3 years (even before the recent support that pushed them further). I know what works and doesn't work for their strategy and playstyle. Regardless, I appreciate the input.