Welcome to the comment stream... jump in!

Sliverguy420 on Pussy on F I R …

1 month ago

stompy/zoo is just aggro, which coco does best. the simplest answer is to cut the enchantments and helix and run Aether Vial and coco. if coco whiffs, you just built the deck wrong.

FakeHair on Official missing/incorrect card/token thread

1 month ago

Just got confused by the Haunted Ridge / Haunted Dead issue and submitted a bad card fix. Sorry!

NV_1980 on The Wizard of Death & …

1 month ago

Nice deck! Would something like Conjurer's Closet or maybe Cloudstone Curio work in this deck, so that you can blink Nev? Interested in your thoughts!

DungeonMimic1993 on Smokey's Nightmare

1 month ago

Cool commander idea! Have you considered adding Repercussion? It'll alow your deck work even if someone removed your commander or just double the damage while your commander is out.

MTGShiddur on Froggies

1 month ago

The Gitrog Monster would be a good add here. LMK if you wanna borrow mine.

MTGShiddur on Froggies

1 month ago

I'm with Dmitri_Y - BIG BUM DOOKIE!

kamarupa on Don't

1 month ago

Hydroid Krasis, perhaps? It draws you cards, has a variable MV and can be a big threat.

NonetheWeisser on Pussy on F I R …

1 month ago

Sliverguy420

In my 3 years playing cats seriously, they most align with a stompy/zoo based strategy. Coco is fine IF you hit a lord or 2, but there are also cards in my build that do not mesh well with it. Also, due to the amount of spells I run, Coco whiffing is more likely than not.

NonetheWeisser on Pussy on F I R …

1 month ago

Sliverguy420

Because we don't need it. The cat's don't need a 4 mana instant speed spell that can whiff. They curve out reliably on their own. Same reason why Aether Vial was dropped. Just not necessary.

Bixuh on Oops All Gideon's

1 month ago

Altfinity, what you recommend to replace with luxior? Want to do a deck with Gideon for modern to annoy other players and win some games too

DrummerGarrett on Death and Taxes plus Walls

1 month ago

How do you not have Spara's Headquarters in here ?

roseofizzet on The Cult of Astarion

1 month ago

The flavor here is fantastic, and I'm finding it fun to playtest so far!

Sliverguy420 on Pussy on F I R …

1 month ago

how is coco "redundant"? saving on mana, card advantage, and instant speed creatures isn't something your current list can already do.

roseofizzet on "Begging your pardon, but he …

1 month ago

Oh man, I really wasn't sold on the Ring Tempts You mechanic, but this is too adorable not to try.

Profet93 on Gas in the Tank, I'm …

1 month ago

Chill_Casual +1

I love the name of your deck. Is that from a song? Do you smoke weed?

Do you have a budget per card? I was thinking of a swap like Fabled Passage > evolving wilds for example or Ancient Tomb > temple of false

Eye of Ugin - For all the eldrazi.

Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth - To make something like temple of false or eye of ugin to tap for green. Yavimaya Hollow - Protection/politics. None of the lands are really needed, just nice to have.

Maybe a Crucible of Worlds - Get back cycled lands, replay fetch lands (Azusa or courser makes it even better). Although it depends on the amount of fetches you utilize.

Y is seedborn muse in the maybeboard and not mainboard?

berryjon on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Angel of Protective Wings

Enchantment Creature - Angel
Bestow
Flying.
If this creature is cast for its Bestow cost, you may cast it as though it has Flash.
When this creature enters, choose a color. This creature, and the enchanted creature, has protection from that color.
Aura Swap
2/2
"They came to me in my moment of weakness, and held me safe until I was strong before leaving behind another gift to remind me of that passing moment."

Combine Aura Swap with another relatable mechanic. Or Bestow again.

NonetheWeisser on Pussy on F I R …

1 month ago

DarthEmik.

Not a fan of Coco. Tried it before and it was redundant. I wanted to try Skyknight, but I felt like it was a little slow. Might need to revisit.

We had Feline Sovereign as our second lord before Arahbo was released. We will definitely have it in our sideboard for particular match ups. :)

Haykrug24 on Animar, soul of elements

1 month ago

I think you should add more creatures and ramp and cut a few noncreatures. Cards such as stratus dancer can replace a counterspell. Check out my decklist for an almost CEDH list

kamarupa on You Go Squirrel

1 month ago

Big thanks for the the +1 and folder add, hexademinial!!

DarthEmik on Pussy on F I R …

1 month ago

I am currently running a Cat Tribal/Kindred deck in modern currently and have been running very well. Feline Sovereign is an amazing card in the current format it seems. I have been running a 4-of Collected Company and also running a couple Skyknight Squire as well.

Fortheboys11 on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

my bad, somehow missed a page.

here's the Umbra

Gargoyle Umbra

Artifact Enchantment: Aura

Enchant Creature

Umbra armor

Enchanted creature has Flyer, Defender, and Lifelink

Whenever a creature attacks you, draw a card for each creature you control with defender.


sorry about that. Repeat challenge

Fortheboys11 on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Esper Legalist

Artifact Creature - Human Advisor

Lifelink

Whenever a creature enters the battlefield under an opponents control, they may tap that creature. If they don't, goad that creature until ~ leaves the battlefield.

2/3

Make an on-flavor instant of sorcery for this deck.

Dmitri_Y on Froggies

1 month ago

This deck is BIG BUM DOOKIE

metal_mustaine on Spinal Tap

1 month ago

not even legal

billy98roy on TappedOut.User's List of Lists (and …

1 month ago

telegram id : (@planet8corpi) order Clone Cards , cocaine , marijuana Looking for where to buy clone cards,
Buy high-quality fake bills, Counterfeit currency supplier, Buy realistic fake cash, Buy fake bills online, Premium counterfeit notes, Buy fake counterfeit Canadian dollars banknotes,
Buy Japanese Yen (JPY) Online, Buy Chinese Yuan (CNY) Renminbi, Buy Canadian Dollars (CAD) Online, Buy British Pound (GBP) Online, Buy Australian Dollars (AUD) Online,

Sliverguy420 on Is Black Allowed to have …

1 month ago

plakjekaas if you google "mtg punisher cards", the first link says punisher cards can be either of those types of choices.

btw rosewater didn't actually say black shouldn't have punisher cards, just that neither of the choices should be something the color normally doesn't do. like Dash Hopes countering a spell. but thats another time spiral card.

kamarupa on Arti-Kor

1 month ago

When I first started playing, I tried to build a Kor tribal/equipment deck. No matter how much I adjusting things, it never seemed to work out well - either too many equipments and not enough creatures, or the other way around. I just took your word for it that your decklist 'runs smoothly,' but I consider that a feat. And I noticed that this deck hadn't been updated in 9 years, but since I'm not much into EDH, I figured my knowledge base applied better to casual. Anyway, cheers!

ouroborobelisk on Arti-Kor

1 month ago

kamarupa Thank you so much for the +1 & the suggestion. This deck is soooo oooold by now. I made this before I switched over to EDH Commander as my primary format if choice. So much has changed since I last played this decklist, and there are so many new cards printed that I wouldn't know where to start as far as upgrading it.

plakjekaas on Lifegain-how much to be worth …

1 month ago

I forgot about Weather the Storm too, until it basically 6- for-1'd me when I got greedy and tried to Lava Spike+Skewer the Critics+Lightning Bolt+... Fireblast for exactly lethal all on my turn ('^^).

wallisface on Lifegain-how much to be worth …

1 month ago

Ahh yes, that makes a lot of sense :)

plakjekaas on Custom card type groups?

1 month ago

In your deckbuilder, there's a link to Formatting help, you can search that for "custom categories" for a clear explanation, for that and all other ways to use anything with text formatting on the website.

plakjekaas on Lifegain-how much to be worth …

1 month ago

Oh yeah, I play Pauper regularly. Both Weather the Storm and Feed the Clan are the bane of my burn deck.

Crow_Umbra on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Crow Umbra

Enchantment - Aura

Enchant creature

Enchanted creature gets flying and menace.

Umbra Armor (If enchanted creature would be destroyed, instead remove all damage from it and destroy this Aura.)

Aura Swap

When this aura leaves the battlefield you may discard up to two cards. If you do, draw a card for each card discarded this way.

"Crows were always known to give unexpected gifts to those they favored most."


Repeat on Aura Swap, or make an Umbra.

Tsukimi on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Leyline Vision

Enchantment - Aura

Enchanted creature has ": Add one ."

Aura Swap

When this aura leaves the battlefield, untap the creature its attached to.

"Everything. . . It's all connected, in so many more ways than I could ever imagine."


Repeat (make a card with aura swap)

Arcath on Custom card type groups?

1 month ago

I see some decks are laid out with card type groups other than the standard Creatures, Lands, etc.
How do you create the custom groups for a deck?

StarRushford on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Make another card with Aura Swap.

StarRushford on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Darksteel Enchantment

Artifact Enchantment - Aura

Enchant permanent

Aura swap

LunchBox1211 on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Trekkjin, Throne's Heir

Legendary Creature - Dragon

When ~ enters the battlefield, target opponent becomes the Monarch. That player can not attack you or Planeswalkers you control during their next turn.

Whenever you become the Monarch, untap ~.

: Add . Activate this ability only if you are the Monarch.

Partners with Grinslin, Trusted Advisor.

1/3


Grinslin, Trusted Advisor

Legendary Creature - Human Advisor

Whenever a player becomes the Monarch, scry 2.

Whenever you activate a mana ability, if you are the Monarch, instead add that much mana of any colour.

Partners with Trekkjin, Throne's Heir.

0/5


Remember Arcanum Wings? Make another Aura with Aura Swap.

Femme_Fatale on Pls add Unknown Event cards

1 month ago

I'll get to them after I finish with the yellow foiling cards from DFT. The images for them looked ugly so I've been spending some time photoshopping them all to look nicer.

wallisface on Lifegain-how much to be worth …

1 month ago

plakjekaas Which format are you referring to? I’m not sure ”forever” is quite correct, i’ve been playing Modern since Battle for Zendikar, and haven’t seen this card once. It looks playable for kitchen-table environments, but I don’t think they typically use sideboards (or need to worry about burn).

Sombertone on Voja, Bitey Elves

1 month ago

Spending a bit more money for a couple more untapped, fetchable duels.

Forest -> Stomping Ground

Forest -> Temple Garden

I've found myself missing on Red or White more often than I'd like. I'm considering upping the land count but it feels like with all the mana dorks that 37 should be fine. Putting these in for Forests will help with the color fixing.

sageprinny on Twisted Metal Action

1 month ago

Deck is in Progress and would like some suggestions that are cost effective and a little bit more competitive.

Tsukimi on Card creation challenge

1 month ago

Machinations of the Tower

Enchantment

Whenever an opponent attacks and is not attacking you, that player may give target creature they control undying until end of turn. If they do, you each draw a card.

"We must refuse their aid, don't you see what you're doing?"


Make a new set of partner commanders in bant or abzan colors.

plakjekaas on Lifegain-how much to be worth …

1 month ago

Feed the Clan has been played in sideboards forever, for the reasons wallisface specified.

plakjekaas on Is Black Allowed to have …

1 month ago

Your examples are not punishment, they're cruel choices. It's not "i get this good thing unless you get a bad thing", it's "you get one bad thing or another bad thing".

A black punisher card would be Temporal Extortion which we shouldn't count for color philosophy purposes, because it's from Time Spiral block.