SufferFromEDHD on Gerrard Capashen: You and the …
5 days ago
Buried Ruin is surprisingly useful.
If I go Land Tax route then I have to add Scroll Rack
Planar Portal can grab 4 draw spells and useful removal. I think I see your point though. Bridge grabs a permanent that draws cards and puts it directly into play.
Profet93 on Gerrard Capashen: You and the …
5 days ago
(At the risk of inappropriate) Gerrard Capashen be like - I'd tap that
In all seriousness, Buried Ruin - Recursion
Land Tax - Draw/ramp, ramp with serra sanctum
What has your experience been with planar portal, is there a particular instant or sorcery you want since you opted not to put Planar Bridge in it's place?
Bookrook on Splash Lasher token has reminder …
5 days ago
THe same thing happens with the spellgorger weird from Ral and the Implicit Maze
TypicalTimmy on Splash Lasher token has reminder …
5 days ago
The card Splash Lasher has a token that literally says it has a mana cost of in reminder text?
I thought tokens have no mana cost as they aren't cast, but created?
Is this some new rules update from Bloomburrow?
StarRushford on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Wall of Dominion
Legendary Creature - Elder Wall
(Walls can't attack.)
Omnipotence (This creature has every keyword on each creature on the battlefield.)
When this creature dies, return it to your hand.
3/13
Repeat
Fortheboys on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Alara, Child No More
Legendary Creature - Elder Avatar
Flying, Vigilance, Trample
Avatars you control have Flying, Vigliance, and Trample
Whenever a non-Avatar creature dies, you may pay . If you do, draw a card Whenever an Avatar dies, destroy all nonland, non-Avatar permanents.
7/7
Wild or repeat
Fingall on Vampires at War
5 days ago
4 mountains Basalt Monolith Chromatic Orrery Ashnod's Altar Jet Medallion Ruby Medallion Staff of Domination Ceremonial Knife Sanguine Brushstroke Transmutation Font Twilight Prophet Scion of Opulence Necropolis Regent
Crow_Umbra on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Thank you! Lol, I was looking at The Mycotyrant initially for templating ideas, TypicalTimmy. I also kinda debated on doing a Goyf style power/toughness growth for the Elder Fungus. The damage/sacrifice effect from Star Athlete was also something I looked to for templating.
TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Crow_Umbra lol The Mycotyrant already exists
Just playing, nice design btw
TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
So my understanding is that Edgar Markov was the first vampire on Innistrad, but not necessarily the first vampire in general existence.
This one is meant to be the original first, set on Dominaria. Although admittedly her abilities feel as though they are leaning a bit more toward Zendikar.
Oh well shrug?
Lady Volgrah, First to Drink Blood
Legendary Creature - Elder Vampire
Convoke
Devour 1
Flying, deathtouch, lifelink
When Lady Volgrah enters the battlefield, draw a card for each tapped Human you control that was sacrificed to her Devour mechanic. For each legendary human, each opponent exiles a card from their hand at random.
1/2
There are 1746 Humans in Grixis, with 345 of them being Legendary... I may actually build her as a precon holy shit
Repeat, but if you want a nice added challenge make an Elder Avatar. As in the subtype, not the manga / anime.
Crow_Umbra on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Here's my crack at an Elder Fungus.
Cordyrus, Morbid Assimilator
Legendary Creature - Elder Fungus
Menace
Whenever ~ deals combat damage to a player, put a host counter on a target creature that player controls. ~ gets +1/+1 for each creature you control, but don't own with a host counter on it.
At the beginning of your end step, choose up to one target creature you don't control with a host counter on it. Its controller may sacrifice it. If a player chooses to sacrifice a creature this way, they lose life equal to that creature's power. If they don't, gain control of that creature for as long as it has a host counter on it instead.
3/4
I wanted to do something that was kinda like cordyceps. I was debating on making this card Jund instead, to make the theft more temporary, and also since Grixis is more so in line with theft effects.
Neotrup on If I give control of …
5 days ago
Changing control of a curse with something like Donate will not change who it's attached to, only who controls it. With most curses, control doesn't really matter (some like Curse of Misfortunes or Curse of Leeches Flip do care who controls them). In order to change what an aura is attached to, the spell would need to state that like Aura Graft does, however the only thing I can find to do that would be Ardenn, Intrepid Archaeologist which requires you to still control the curse, and is not available within Lynde, Cheerful Tormentor's color identity.
StarRushford on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Adolphus, Heir of the Wolves
Legendary Creature - Elder Human Werewolf
When you attack, put a +1/+1 counter on each Werewolf you control.
At the beginning of your upkeep, it becomes night.
Daybound
3/3
Adolphus, First of the Wolves
Legendary Creature - Elder Werewolf
When you attack, put a +2/+2 counter on each creature you control. They gain trample until end of turn.
Non-human Werewolves can't transform.
Nightbound
6/6
There are +2/+2 counters: Baron Sengir, Dwarven Armory, Fungus Elemental.
Also, the ability of the second one is based on Immerwolf.
Repeat!
The Elder list is Demon, Dragon, Giant, Dinosaur, Werewolf, and Fungus
legendofa on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Right now, the Elder list is Demon, Dragon, Giant, Dinosaur, and Fungus. (Not counting Dog because the Dog isn't the Elder.)
Avatar of the Past
Legendary Creature - Elder Avatar
At the beginning of your first main phase, return target card from a graveyard to its owner's hand.
At the beginning of your end step, if you have exactly seven cards in hand and your life total is equal to your starting life total, Avatar of the Past gains hexproof and indestructible until your next turn.
6/8
What has happened once must happen again. Such is the unending cycle.
Same challenge.
RawlMage84293 on FutureProjects, CL 34-list
5 days ago
https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/wastes5x/
[List of 5x Wastes here: TALISMAN, CLUESTONE, KEYRUNE, LOCKET, SIGNET]
(https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/wastes5x/)
AspieGG on Dota 2
5 days ago
in order - Aegis of the Immortal, Storm Spirit, LD, BH, Centaur Warrunner, Clockwerk, Courier, either Lycan's Wolves or the Wolf jungle creeps, DK, LD's bear, Earthshaker, Enigma & his eidolons, SF, Phoenix, Techies, Medusa, Troll jungle creep, Weaver, Kotl, Axe, Morphling, Medusa, NS, Nyx Assassin, Sand King???, Storm Spirit, Beastmaster, Alchemist, Pudge, Riki, DK, Bottle, Treant Protector, Shop/Secret Shop, Vanguard, Axe, Necro, WD, Lesh, Dust of Appearance, Ogre, Earthshaker, Doom's Ult/Fortification Glyph, Omniknight, Healing Salve, Silencer, Zeus, Lesh, Lion, Kotl's old skill i guess?, WK, Magnus, Dazzle, NP, Chen's voice line, Disruptor, towers, Alchemist (skip ahead), the jungle (skip ahead), Nyx Assasin (skip), radiant fountain (skip), Beastmaster, Invoker, Meepo, Razor, Lesh, Tinker, Omniknight, Oracle, Treant Protector, Smoke of Deceit, Riki, both Vengeful Spirit and Terrorblade (technically Venge if using the exact wording), Earthshaker, Zeus, Sniper, Tiny, Kotl, Batrider, PL, Jakiro, ET, Doom, Faceless Void
Maybeboard: Viper, Chaos Knight, Broodmother, Zeus???, Lifestealer?????, Underlord/Pit Lord, Kotl, Windranger, Enchantress, Aegis again, AM, Omniknight, Ringmaster, fog of war/Slark's depth shroud, Undying, Razor, Aghs scepter, tower, Slark
forgive me if i messed up the order somewhere, I'm too tired to check all over again
Be_Jamin on If I give control of …
5 days ago
I'm building a Lynde, Cheerful Tormentor deck and I see that cards like Harmless Offering and Donate are usually paired with this commander. With her first ability and attaching the curse to myself, I'm looking for more ways to give others the curses other than multiple upkeeps. What I don't want is to change control of a curse to an opponent and then they turn it around and curse me. If that is the case, could I get an explanation on why such cards would be used in curse decks?
FauxFaux on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Gerref, Heir of Hares
Legendary Creature - Elder Rabbit Noble
Other Rabbit creature spells you cast gain Offspring: .
Whenever a Rabbit creature you control enters, put a +1/+1 counter on ~.
3/4
"To explain just how great he is, it'd take at least 7 generations. Unfortunately, by that time, he'd only become even greater."
Repeat!
Felipix on Mono U commanders to a …
5 days ago
seshiro_of_the_orochi, So I've been looking in this idea while searching for my creatureless commander, and I guess I could go the other direction, tool box... BTW thanks
Balaam__ on Golgari Depths
5 days ago
I’ve seen a few DD variations over the years and this looks fairly solid, all the main pieces are accounted for. Bayou would definitely help, but oh boy that price tag. Maybe a card with a Regrowth type effect would be a sideboard consideration, but then again if your opponent knows what he’s doing it would probably be surgically extracted anyway.
Rhadamanthus on Marchesa, the black rose and …
5 days ago
As long as it's a permanent card (i.e. not an Instant or Sorcery), it will return to the battlefield. If it's a non-permanent card then it will stay in the graveyard.
"Dies" triggers and other "leaves-the-battlefield" triggers care about what an object looked like at the last moment it was still on the battlefield. This means Marchesa's ability will trigger when the creature in your example dies. The delayed trigger that happens at the next end step will still know the card as "that card" and will still be able to act on it. A permanent card can be returned to the battlefield this way, but there's a special rule that specifically disallows non-permanent cards from entering the battlefield.
Rhadamanthus on What happens when someone with …
5 days ago
Of the players who are still in the game, Witch Hunt will return to the control of whoever else controlled it most recently.
One of the steps involved in a player leaving the game is ending any active effects that give them control of things. If an object has been subject to multiple control-changing effects, it's important to note that the old ones still exist, they've just been superseded by the most recently created one. When that most recent one ends, the next most recent one (that hasn't been ended by someone else leaving the game) will be in effect again.
800.4a When a player leaves the game, all objects (see rule 109) owned by that player leave the game and any effects which give that player control of any objects or players end. Then, if that player controlled any objects on the stack not represented by cards, those objects cease to exist. Then, if there are any objects still controlled by that player, those objects are exiled. This is not a state-based action. It happens as soon as the player leaves the game. If the player who left the game had priority at the time they left, priority passes to the next player in turn order who’s still in the game.
Unlife on Card creation challenge
5 days ago
Elder Ooblex
Legendary Creature - Elder Ooze 7/7
Menace, Trample
Whenever another creature dealt damage by Elder Ooblex is put into the graveyard from play, you may exile it. Create a token copy of that creature on the battlefield under your control, except it's an Ooze in addition to its other types.
: Traget creature must block Elder Ooblex this turn if able
: Regenerate Elder Ooblex
We've been getting more in recent years, but the majority of elder creatures is still dragons, let's see another elder creature for a tribe that doesn't have one yet.
Epicurus on Card creation challenge
6 days ago
Gonna consider the challenge to be wild.
Dwarven Brewmaster
Creature - Dwarf Artisan
Whenever ~ enters and during your upkeep, create a food token
Sacrifice a food: Target creature gets +1/+0 for each food you've sacrificed this turn and must attack or block this turn if able
1/2
Make an Elder creature of a creature type that doesn't yet have any elders
versus64 on Elesh Norn, Mom and ETB …
6 days ago
Gidgetimer I believe this is incorrect. According to Ask a Judge: “Norn’s ability causes your triggered abilities to trigger an extra time rather than copying the abilities. This means that all restrictions on the trigger apply to both instances.
In the case of “once each turn” triggers, this will prevent them from triggering again since that clause flat out prevents them triggering more than once in a turn under any circumstances.”
seshiro_of_the_orochi on Mono U commanders to a …
6 days ago
Fblthp, the Lost, in it's most streamlined version, is a creatureless deck. You try to get Proteus Staff out asap and target Fblthp with it. This way, you'll flip your whole deck until you reach Fblthp at the bottom. You put your entire deck back in any order (as Staff tells you to), allowing you to stack your next draws. After the ability of Staff has finished resolving, Fblthp's triggered ability goes on the stack and draws you two cards. So you basically tutored for the best two cards for any given situation.
The remaining cards besides these two should propably be ways to untap Staff, protection for Staff and Phblthp, protection for yourself, interaction and control effects. From there, you're pretty open ended. Taking things away from your opponent could be a thing, but there's tons of things to do.
But you tutor all the time. Which seems honestly pretty boring to me. That's why I never finished or played the deck.
BioProfDude on Sorin Markov - Vampire - …
6 days ago
Is this supposed to be a Modern deck? Almost none of it is Standard legal.
wallisface on What happens when someone with …
6 days ago
Permanents controlled by other players return to their owners when that player dies
Aspitxon on Marchesa, the black rose and …
6 days ago
Let's say I have both Marchesa, the Black Rose and Scroll of Fate on the battlefield and activate Scroll of faith's ability to manifest a Skullclamp. I somehow manage to put a +1/+1 counter on the manifested Skullclamp and it dies. Would Marchesa's ability trigger on the Skullclamp since it was a creature when it left the battlefield or does it need to be a creature card once in the graveyard as well?
builderboy7 on What happens when someone with …
6 days ago
When Witch Hunt deals 4 damage to a player who isn't the owner and dies as a result, what happens to the Witch Hunt enchantment? Does it get exiled when the player dies or returns under its owner's control?
Bookrook on The Great Bouncing Kolaghan
6 days ago
The price did go down to thirty dollars recently... Proxies are probably the best option if your playgroup allows them.
Seuchenschutz on Sidisi Brood Commander
6 days ago
Thx for the suggestions Andramalech! Im really happy to get some feedback on this deck. In an earlier Version i had 2-3 cheap counters in the deck An Offer You Can't Refuse, Swan Song and a Negate but I took them out, because they became a salt factor in my playgroup. Whatever. Victimize is a great card, but after playing it for a while, I often felt like them coming tapped and leaving me with less blockers for a turn is kind of a big downside. I had some situations, where I just couldnt afford to cast it. As for the Diabolic Intent its the same with the counters. Salty players... But I just couldnt get myself to cut the Demonic Tutor. Plumb the Forbidden however might be worth a shot.
TheLazySherlock on best life gain ever (EDH)
6 days ago
I'm not sure why it's the best life gain ever deck, it seems a little light in some ways. Only a little more then half (13/24) creatures have life link or something similar to life link.
Only one of the three planeswalkers have life giving options.
And only 28 out of the 100 cards, only 28% have a way to give you life.
I feel like those numbers can be improved.
Andramalech on Sidisi Brood Commander
6 days ago
Sidisi, Brood Tyrant is so slept on in EDH these days, at least in my circles. It's a great pick, and with a new Tarkir set on the horizon in 2025, I think we should see a reprint. But I digress, this deck is great and I love that it seems like you've got something to cast pretty much every turn. There's a really healthy balance of land and creatures, but potentially consider Plumb the Forbidden or something like Diabolic Intent, potentially Victimize. I really like what I see here but you're lacking a considerable amount of instants, things like Swan Song, Strix Serenade, etc. Just some interaction and draw power would be my only suggestions.