Profet93 on The Tin Man Special
1 week ago
Even thought my name is profet, introduction to prophecy is my least favorite colorless card, so thats an easy pick. As for another, here are 2 more options...
Staff of Nin - Costs a lot, draw is slow, deals little damage. I know you need draw, but high costed cards like this aren't ideal. I usually would recommended either Kozilek in colorless but budget limitations restrict that.
Colossus Hammer - Winmore, high cost to equip, no way to bypass cost.
StarRushford on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
Ghalta, Cry of the Wild
Creature - Zombie Dinosaur
Trample
Eminence - As long as Ghalta, Cry of the Wild is in the command zone or on the battlefield, you may pay at any time. When you do, mill 2.
When Ghalta, Cry of the Wild enters the battlefield, you may return each creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield. They become black Zombies in addition to their other colors and types.
12/12
8-16-08-decimus on Jetmir Hares
1 week ago
here's a better way to do it
opening hand Sacred Foundry
+ Sol Ring+ Temple Garden + Stomping Ground + Plains + 2 Hare Apparent
Turn 1: Sacred Foundry + Sol Ring draw for turn 1:Hare Apparent
Turn 2: Temple Garden + 2 Hare Apparent draw for turn 2:Hare Apparent
turn 3: Stomping Ground + 2 Hare Apparent draw for turn 3 Hare Apparent
turn 4: Plains + Jetmir, Nexus of Revels swing for 88
Math-> 4 5/2 Hare Apparent with double strike so 40 dam
+ 6 4/1 Rabbit 1/1 W with double strike so 48 dam
Felipix on Mono U commanders to a …
1 week ago
Anyone knows a mono U commander to take benefit from being a creature less deck?
Caerwyn on Making my mono U commander …
1 week ago
This thread was moved to a more appropriate forum (auto-generated comment)
FenIsABasicSwamp on Dune: He Who Can Destroy …
1 week ago
Foxycide nothing wrong with or unoriginal about Ishiin! I love that card! And your suggestion is great for that deck. This deck is highly complex as you said and very difficult to play. I would say the vast majority of players should not attempt it. It is not going to be a pleasant experience for newer players to try to run it given the complexity.
slvstrChung on The Great Bouncing Kolaghan
1 week ago
Bookrook, it is, but I have two college educations to pay for in 10 years. Spending it all on four pieces of cardboard seems... unwise.
slvstrChung on Toughness Trilogy, Ep. III: The …
1 week ago
KongMing, the only concerns I have about those spells are my budget. This deck is about 300% more money than I prefer to spend. Still, there is definitely an upgrade path for this deck, and I'd say those spells are on it!
Felipix on Making my mono U commander …
1 week ago
(someone can delete the other threads of the theme?)
So I have proxies for my Mono U Nezahal deck, and I don't know if I like the idea of being the archenemy just because of my commander, so I re-note the list and there it is, I need a new commander and 30 synergy cards to play a control creature less deck (It can also go in a polymorph subtheme like running just one big guy) or if not, adding 5~7 creature cards like AEtherling, to win the game
deck:Mono blue commander basics
MadPilot on Modern Simic Infect 2024
1 week ago
Andramalech thank you for your comment of culture
I dont like any of GeminiSpartanX suggested hexproofs because I find that playing 4 Inkmoth Nexus makes me often not have access to colored mana, that's why I find Apostle's Blessing totally superior to them as it also gives evasion and its only downside is the Eldrazi matchup.
On the other side I do want to get Force of Negation soon for this deck
The Mirrex might be good too thanks
E2R4 on The Tin Man Special
1 week ago
Excellent. Any recommendations on cards to remove to slot those in? I'd prefer to keep all my creatures if possible. Maybe I could remove Unstable Obelisk and Introduction to Prophecy?
Felipix on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
Oko Goes away
Tribal Sorcery - Faerie
Create a 1/1 farie with: " create a food token" and a 2/2 Elk with: ": target creature become a copy of this creature, including this ability"
"Don't put me in your jug Jace" -Oko
So Oko lose this time
Create Izzet Talrand or an golgari ghalta
EnbyGolem on An Old-School Nightmare
1 week ago
SufferFromEDHD Great suggestion! Morinfen would like his buddy back - the only problem is finding what creature to take out for them.
Foxycide on Dune: He Who Can Destroy …
1 week ago
I have the card in a pretty casual Ishiin, Two Heavens as One deck (unoriginal, I know). Anyway, how does this deck run? I have never made a deck nearly as complex, although I am a relatively new player.
TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
So Oko is a fae, but it's always bothered me because we traditionally think of fae as these tiny bird-sized creatures, not 6' lean Humanoids.
Faleron the Great
Legendary Planeswalker - Faleron
+1 Each player reveals the top card of their library. You may play up to one of them and spend mana of any color to do so. Then each player shuffles their library.
0 Target player gets an emblem with "Whenever a land enters the battlefield under your control, you lose 1 life."
-8 Each player reveals their hand. You may play cards from them until end of turn without paying their mana costs.
3
That's about as malicious and sinister as I could flavorfully make it in Bant, while also being incredibly respectful to what fae actually are; Devilish tricksters who will severely punish you for entering their domains where they seek to enslave your mind for themselves.
Also being back Planeswalkers who's ultimate wins you the game already lol
More Fae please :3
Epicurus on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
Llanowar Fae
Creature - Faerie
Flying
Whenever ~ enters, you may play an additional land this turn
: Add
1/1
Moar Fae!
Femme_Fatale on Two New Formats and a …
1 week ago
There was some specific issue about account wide and deck specific skibulk that had to have it be deck specific, though I can't remember the specifics right now. I'll note the gold border cards though as something to do in the future.
Avacyn1986 on Volrath: No School, like Old …
1 week ago
I love your deck! I too have built an old school black deck, roughly same rules, with Visara the Dreadful (ONS) and Tainted Field (TOR) being the most recent amongst the cards in my deck. It's not EDH though.
I love the fact that you built a commander deck using only Pre-Mirrodin cards!
Here's a link to my deck! I've got it all, only waiting to play with my friends now.
https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/legacy-black-finished-deck-1/
StarRushford on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
berryjon Oh hi! Didn't realize you posted on this! Big fan. You should do more of the Custom Card Critique.
Anyway, some Fae cards? I made a Fae commander a while ago.
Allis, Queen of Ice
Legendary Creature — Faerie Wizard
Flying
When a creature is tapped, create a 1/1 white and blue Ice Faerie creature token with flying.
3/3
IDK why I made her green, probably for token shenanigans with things like Rhys the Redeemed.
Anyway, repeat or wild.
skibulk on Two New Formats and a …
1 week ago
Two bits of feedback re: setting default printings to Lowest Price:
- Currently, I have to choose lowest price for each of my decks manually. Can we please get an account setting so this isn't necessary?
- Sometimes you get gold border cards in your decks. I have never seen these cards used. It would be great to filter those versions.
Thank you
berryjon on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
Wild, huh?
The Wyld Hunt
Legendary Enchantment Creature - Faerie Mount
Flying, Trample, Deathtouch
Saddle X
When this creature enters, it becomes Night. This creature phases out if it is Day.
Whenever this creature attacks, destroy target creature defending player controls. If you do, you may sacrifice a non-token creature that has Saddled this creature. If you do, return the destroyed creature from the graveyard to your battlefield tapped with a Finality counter on it.
X+1/X+1
Not sure what I wanted to do with this. Let's get some more Fae cards that aren't just Control/Midrange.
Hellaluyeah on Stop Hitting Yourself
1 week ago
Thanks! I appreciate any card suggestions. EDHRec helped me on a lot of decks, but it wasn't much help with this one, since this theme doesn't really come up with this commander.
TypicalTimmy on Card creation challenge
1 week ago
Bocchi, God of Food and Wine
Legendary Creature - God
As long as you control five or more food, Bocchi has indestructible.
Lifelink
At the beginning of your upkeep, whenever you play a land or cast an enchantment create a food token.
Food tokens you control are 2/2 green creatures in addition to their other types. Whenever you sacrifice a food, exile the top card of your library. You may play it until end of turn.
5/4
Sat for 30 hours.
Wild.
Felipix on How do I delete one …
1 week ago
There we go:
https://tappedout.net/mtg-forum/commander-deck-help/can-you-help-with-removal/
https://tappedout.net/mtg-forum/commander-deck-help/nezahal-control-deck/
https://tappedout.net/mtg-forum/commander-deck-help/brew-my-deck-for-me/
https://tappedout.net/mtg-forum/commander/what-gonna-be-my-last-commander/
https://tappedout.net/mtg-forum/commander/im-semi-giving-up-magic/
It's more than I remember, but I'm going to start all over
JeskaiMaster01 on Sisay’s Crew
1 week ago
I suggest Maskwood Nexus and Arcane Adaptation to better utilize Morophon
Felipix on How do I delete one …
1 week ago
As you might know, I'm building my last mono blue deck, and I ask for help on a forum over there like, 3~5 times, how can I delete this threads so I can resume all in a new one at Deck help forum?
Profet93 on The Tin Man Special
1 week ago
Basalt Monolith is an okay mana rock that goes infinite with forsaken monument. Basalt can also act as ramp with voltaic or manifold key.
Rings of Brighthearth + Basalt = Infinite colorless. Rings can double ur PW's abilities, 2 of your creatures and some of your artifacts.
Blinkmoth Well, while not needed, can work well with it's brother, blinkmoth urn. It's also nice to stop opposing artifact (Ex: Forcing them to tap their mana rock during upkeep and spend mana during that phase or lose it).
Andramalech on Modern Simic Infect 2024
1 week ago
Ah yes, the time-honored tradition of building infect in modern; i've tried many times and it always looks very similar to what you have here. GeminiSpartanX makes a fantastic point about wanting some access to protection for super cheap. If price is an issue, then I understand why you wouldn't use something like Flare of Denial or Force of Negation. Good luck at your FNM and I recommend that you invest in some non-zero copies of Mirrex for the mainboard.
Chaospyke on Minklink mech and Enduring Glimmers
1 week ago
Checking back on this, wouldn't Mindlink Mech still be an enchantment in addition to its other types, as being an enchantment is not part of its copiable traits, right?
Like if a Clever Impersonator entered as a copy of the reanimated Mindlink Mech, the Clever Impersonator should just be an Artifact Vehicle.
Profet93 on The Tin Man Special
1 week ago
E2R4 +1
Remove Environmental sciences as a land can take it spot given the life gain is negligent and you aren't running emrakrul for socerries.
Cloud Key and Semblance Anvil are good replacements.
8-16-08-decimus on Pioneer Jund
1 week ago
you could consider Untimely Malfunction it's very versatile
DrummerGarrett on READY RED/GREEN - Creatures and …
1 week ago
Replace both Grapeshots with a Twisted Landscape and an Ignoble Hierarch.
Replace Xira Arien with an additional Draconic Disciple.
Replace Thunderscape Master with Boartusk Liege.
Consider replacing Mana Geode with an additional Draconic Disciple.
Unlicensed Disintegration can most likely be replaced with a Return to Nature or Darigaaz's Charm.
FatFreddiesCat on Confusing damage timing
1 week ago
Thank you. None of my playing friends have been able to adequately describe the different kinds of abilities. You have made the difference between triggered abilities and static abilities with replacement effects perfectly clear. Thanks again.
StarRushford on life link
1 week ago
chainsaber I agree. There aren't any of those mdfc lands either. (BTW i got here from https://tappedout.net/mtg-articles/2019/may/2/pattern-recognition-107-lifegain/ if you were wondering.)
Rhadamanthus on Confusing damage timing
1 week ago
Lightning-Rig Crew deals 4 damage to each opponent and Ghyrson Starn, Kelermorph doesn't get to do anything.
In this situation, no one has a choice of the order to apply things. That's because Ojer Axonil, Deepest Might Flip and Ghyrson Starn use different kinds of abilities that are handled by the rules in separate, specific ways. Ghyrson Starn has a triggered ability, which you can tell by it starting with one of the words "when", "whenever" or "at". Ojer Axonil has a static ability with a replacement effect, which you can tell by the use of one or more of the words "as", "with" or "instead"
A replacement effect modifies an event as it happens and triggered abilities trigger after an event happens. In this example Ojer Axonil sees your Crew is about to deal less than 4 damage to an opponent and replaces the result with 4 damage instead. Ghyrson Starn's triggered ability watches for an event where exactly 1 damage is dealt, but that's not what happened here, so it doesn't trigger.
Breakaway on Mono Green Deathtouch
1 week ago
Nice deck! I would recommend Pathway Arrows and/or Chariot of Victory to provide some inevitability. I find that they make it so that you can't get beat later in the game if your opponent draws more cards than you.
Aggroking80 on Wheels Wheels Wheels
1 week ago
Actually I was wrong all the lands that you are using only deal with the colors you need for the deck
Deathwizard778 on Wheels Wheels Wheels
1 week ago
Aggroking80 I don't understand what you mean the list has more than lands I just updated the list.
Aggroking80 on Wheels Wheels Wheels
1 week ago
All you have to have is basic lands and non-basics in that color that's it