Bookrook on Naya Ponza
2 weeks ago
Ponza without Stone Rain or Pillage? Isn’t ponza basically just midrange land destruction? You even have it in your decks hubs. Still getting an upvote.
Apollo_Paladin on Hell-Queue Magda
2 weeks ago
Heyo, thanks again for help deck tech'ing my own Magda brawl deck!
One thing I see you're not running but has saved me a couple games already is Arena of Glory (admittedly, only about 15 or so games under my own deck's belt).
All the treasures the rest of the deck provides really helps mitigate using it every other turn, and reliably getting extra mana ramp/haste has allowed for some nasty multi-spell turns firing earlier than normal. Maybe one to consider for ya - either way see you on Arena!
K4nkato on Lock Em Down, Draw Em …
2 weeks ago
Weekly Results (from a few days ago):
Orzhov Humans: ✅✅
Mono Black: ✅✅ (they drew horribly)
Selesnya Coco: ✅✅
Niv to Light: ➖
First Place!
8-16-08-decimus on Eerie :: Enchantment
2 weeks ago
you could add Valgavoth's Lair it would help with eerie tiggers and mana fixing
king-saproling on Gimbal, Gremlin Prodigy - Glimmer …
2 weeks ago
Cool deck! Personally I would make these swaps:
Triskelion -> Nexus of Becoming
Svella, Ice Shaper -> Saheeli's Artistry
Ion Storm -> City of Death
Ooze Flux -> Court of Vantress
Clan Crafter -> Artificer Class
Killer Service -> Drafna, Founder of Lat-Nam
Kibo, Uktabi Prince -> Echo Storm
Shapers of Nature -> Extravagant Replication
Zameck Guildmage -> Second Harvest
Sage of Fables -> Intelligence Bobblehead
Collector's Vault -> Luck Bobblehead
Third Path Iconoclast -> Mechanized Production
Chaos Warp -> Meteor Golem
Legion Extruder -> Mirrorworks
Mechtitan Core -> Replication Specialist
Power Conduit -> Coveted Jewel
Ozolith, the Shattered Spire -> Stolen Identity
Hordebane on Literally just a list of …
2 weeks ago
ClockworkSwordfish, those are all great recommendations.
I can't believe I somehow didn't think of Dowsing Dagger.
And One with Nature is an insanely good card for this deck. I obviously don't play enough green, because I never even knew it existed.
I will say though, I try my best to avoid any card that introduces the Day/Night cycle to the game, just for mine and my playgroup's sanity lol.
I'm not super sure why I left Cephalid Pathmage in the list. Maybe I was thinking about using it for politics and giving the unblockable to someone else's creature?
But I definitely agree that it could pretty easily be replaced. In fact, there's probably a handful or more basic or outdated creatures in the list that could be updated with some more modern choices.
DrummerGarrett on Gürt's Krenko Commander
2 weeks ago
Consider replacing Legion Warboss with Iron Myr.
Belfore on Braids American Nightmare
2 weeks ago
Trying to figure out what your aim for the deck is. I am not much o a mono black player either but I have to say I really enjoy my mono black deck (Chainer) give it a look over cause there is a lot of useful things you should consider in it. If you give a more specific idea for what you want your deck to do let me know makes suggestions easier (eg: life drain, or aristocrats, aggro, reanimator). I ask because it feels a little all over the place. With your commander choice I tend to see a lot of aristocrats / reanimator with a splash of token.
WarknightSoul on Iron Man, Nightmares of New …
2 weeks ago
The https://tappedout.net/mtg-combos/manifold-key+sundial-of-the-infinite/ combo doesn't work. At least from what the Sundial of the Infinite says "Activate this ability only during your turn."
FallopianGolem on Action Surge (Karlach Extra Attacks)
2 weeks ago
NV_1980, That looks like a Xenagos deck! There's a player in my regular group that has a Xenagos, God of Revels deck, so I wanted to do something different.
There's a few differences in our two decks, and I think it comes down to your deck's focus on mana production as a means to use cards Aggravated Assault and Moraug, Fury of Akoum more than once, and admittedly, I forgot that card existed. I'll definitely be adding it to my own list. I'll also be looking at adding World at War and potentially Relentless Assault. There are a few other cards I may look into swapping out as well.
My deck above has a "cheat creatures into play" sub theme. This allows me to trigger extra combats by cheating in creatures like Anzrag, the Quake-Mole or Scourge of the Throne on the first combat. Then using the second combat to trigger another combat step or two. With Karlach, Fury of Avernus in the command zone, I also wanted to make sure I was playing other creatures that made more combat steps. Like the aforementioned cards and Combat Celebrant. Running Fury of the Horde and Savage Beating helps add to that, but shouldnt be this deck's primary source of extra combat steps.
Generating a ton of mana via creatures attacking is great value, and it works well to allow both our decks to play one or more large creatures ahead of curve; however, there are some differences that appeal to different play styles in both decks. Looking at your list has definitely given me some extra ideas, but all and all, I think both decks have different sub themes that may appeal to a variety of other players. Thanks for the comment!
leggedman on fighting voltron
2 weeks ago
any feedback is wanted i'd like this to be relatively strong and I'm pretty bad at deck building. so tips are appreciated
JadonSL on Mono Black Devotion Pioneer
2 weeks ago
I ditched it earlier today actually. I came to the same conclusion. I put in 2x Hopeless Nightmare 1x Phyrexian Arena 1x Cling to Dust
Might try more removal like you suggested though.
ClockworkSwordfish on Literally just a list of …
2 weeks ago
Looking good, I like the cohesion and dedication to the concept. Looks like it could do the trick, too!
I can see a couple slots that could use a possible boost, though... you might like something along the lines of Suspicious Stowaway Flip, Silent Hallcreeper or Shoreline Looter over Cephalid Pathmage - there aren't exactly many targets waiting for him to help with unblockability, ha ha. Metathran Soldier might also be a little plain as a vanilla 1/1 for 2.
There are also a few gems that come to mind for 'unblockable tribal' that are worthy of finding room for! Dowsing Dagger Flip ends up being a discount Gilded Lotus, and One with Nature can be a Rampant Growth every turn for one measly mana.
NV_1980 on Action Surge (Karlach Extra Attacks)
2 weeks ago
Hi, I've made a similar deck but I'm using Xenagos, God of Revels as its commander. It contains a few more ways to get many more combats per turn. Feel free to check it out: King Stranger, Make Me Strong!
Icbrgr on MTGA Explorer Mono-red
2 weeks ago
Den of the Bugbear and Anax, Hardened in the Forge might work well in this?
SufferFromEDHD on Pistols Only Baby
2 weeks ago
Balduvian Trading Post niche
Charisma tech
Frostwielder utility
Thumbscrews pew
Caltrops pew pew
Kazeth on Artifact Engine
2 weeks ago
Should think about adding: Neerdiv, Devious Diver Marvin, Murderous Mimic Desynchronization
Stodge17 on G/B graveyard/reanimator deck
2 weeks ago
I agree with you, ramping more many to allow Stick to be brought back again and again along with having few creatures and going with higher mana, stronger creatures to make reanimate more aggressive.
It’s another great point to have multiple wincons and reanimate strategies. Being able use different strategies will make the deck more balanced. Along with having a few token making creatures in the deck will help.
The hard part for me is limiting creature count in the deck. I’ve weeded out several and got it down to 22 in my “dream deck” getting it lower seems so hard. But having more ramp and permanent removal will keep the opponent off balance.
jasinatael on The Ur-Dragon's Master Plan
2 weeks ago
I like the deck but I would like to point out that Ruinous Ultimatum doesn't hit lands.
Bookrook on Mono Black Devotion Pioneer
2 weeks ago
Not Dead After All is a really bad card outside of scam. I would suggest replacing it with Go for the Throat.
mpepler on Swing First, Think Later
2 weeks ago
I happened to have a Tolarian Academy, but it is by no means necessary, I have played this deck many times and still never had it come up. Removing it also cuts a substantial cost from the deck, and so I would basically encourage that, unless you happen to already have one.
Icbrgr on I wanna play Yu-Gi-Oh but …
2 weeks ago
"Did you just summon a bunch of monsters in one turn!?"
salvasaur on The Cauldron
2 weeks ago
Thanks! Definitely will look into getting another Zoraline or two. Currently only have the one.
I am keeping it strictly to Bloomburrow for now, until the wife feels ready to branch out (she’d say I’m cheating XD). It’s her first time playing, so I have to be nice.
Good call on Lunar Convocation. Have to find a couple of those. I did have two Darkstar Augurs in there previously, but removed them in favor of I can’t remember what. Play felt better with the replacement. Thanks, again, for your suggestions!
Taida on I wanna play Yu-Gi-Oh but …
2 weeks ago
BirdieGirlie makes a lot of sense. I playtested the deck just to see how would it work and intended on keep iterating on it. While trying I found what you said. Not enough creatures either for Eldritch Evolution or Fauna Shaman so I will try getting more on the deck. I also found that The World Spell and Invasion of Ixalan Flip usually were very underwhelming. The latter still had some value, but it would rarely be flipped, so I want to try getting simply more draw spells. The ideal here would be to get something like Forging the Anchor is for artifacts, in general a very efficient draw spell just for something, but I don't think there is any choice. Maybe I will try some draw + scry effects. Regarding the Omniscience payoff, Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur is AMAZING, so now I think the deck is just missing some other threat that is more immediately dangerous, as Worldspine Wurm does not seem to go all the way to it. Finally, dealing with removal and counters. I absolutely know that the combo is VERY reliant on Kona, Rescue Beastie living, but I want to just get some more consistent and better tuned deck first. Also, some of the best options like Veil of Summer are quite pricey and feel very bad if they get stuck in your hand without use or you draw too many. For now, I am considering including Destiny Spinner to deal with counters and also act as fodder for some of the crature searchers when not needed.
CommanderNeyo on A Whorled of Gimmicks
2 weeks ago
lol, this deck actually looks so much fun to play, +1
Frykas on Composting with Wurms
2 weeks ago
Thank you both for the tips! Sadly there aren't any card shop anywhere I live so I order my cards online, I'll keep looking!
And thanks for the feedback on card choises, I'll make some adjustements later! I really appreciate it!
DreadKhan on Composting with Wurms
2 weeks ago
Huh, I didn't realize Dark Ritual had gone up that much, but that makes sense. It's a very good card in decks that have explosive uses for it. As was mentioned, you might find it for cheap, I got most of mine when I bought some cards from people I knew (stuff that had rotated out for example). While I got a lot of stuff like this I also got a handful of Dark Rituals! I hope you can find some, they're a really amazing Legacy card, and they cost next to nothing.
Since I don't have anywhere to practice Legacy play atm, I often test decks people post vs stuff I've homebrewed. When I was testing this vs my Pox deck (it's a midrangey Control list that can be incredibly slow) it was a big issue if your deck couldn't reanimate Armada Wurm, that second body is a real hassle in Legacy, where people rarely use wipes. Many decks can pass a single removal check, but two of them can be crippling, and being able to do this each time you reanimate an Armada Wurm played well. Roar was a convenient card relatively early, a 6/6 vanilla is still a must answer threat IMHO, and 3G from your graveyard for it seems playable (it outclasses my Pox deck's various 5/5s). Vs my Affinity deck you were just way too slow to compete (the answer would probably be to run Serenity, Seeds of Innocence, or Force of Vigor, and you'd put them in a sideboard I think), that's why I felt some ramp might help, if you can cast a 4 drop a turn early it'll feel quite good.
As for what to pull, I feel like you should leave at least 1 Armada Wurm, and I'd hate to see Roar go if you add Augur of Skulls, the main problem with Roar seems to be that card sucks to draw early/have in your opener, Augur gives you a way to bin it. Anyways, Rite is one of the worse reanimation options, it's hard to cast either way, and it's pretty bad to mill, so I could see you cutting it (I've seen people use Dread Return like Balaam mentions, it's even got Flashback fwiw). I really don't like Boneyard Wurm very much in practice, if you have it early it'll be bad value for mana, and late game it's still just a vanilla beater, I'd play Ornithopter over that.
This is a bit random, while I'm pretty confident most Dredge stuff wouldn't make sense in here, I do wonder about Dakmor Salvage? It's not a fantastic card, but if you can mill it you can mill more cards to 'draw' it? It's an ETB tapped land so it could hurt you later game a bit, but this deck felt like one that could fit a tapped land into it's curve. Maybe try x1 or x2 in place of swamps?
inni794 on Liesa but Angels
2 weeks ago
Thanks to both multimedia and TheoryCrafter for the suggestions.
A few of them I've acted on, for example, I didn't realise I couldn't use multiple Legion Angel in sideboard, and then Seraph Sanctuary, plus replacing Unmake with the Strictly better Utter End.
Added a Hedron Archive for more ramp, and Divine Visitation (a card I had already and was figuring out which deck to put in), along with another token generator in Dramatic Finale.
However, every addition I've made for your suggestions is just cards I already had (or found randomly when looking through my now 10 year old collection and forgot/didn't know I owned).
For the rest, though I agree with some of them on a concept level, including some of the lower power angels, my friend already has an angel deck and I'm trying to make mine slightly different from hers so as to not have overlap, so some of this was a conscious choice to be different, or some cases, I simply don't have more copies of the cards and don't want to buy more (HI Arcane Signet/Phyrexian Arena.
Again, thanks for your suggestions :)
Balaam__ on Composting with Wurms
2 weeks ago
@Frykas Dark Ritual isn’t too bad if you buy the cheapest printing of the card. It’s ~$1.50 at the moment most places.
If you have a card shop in your area with a ton of bulk commons, it’s worth spending 20mins picking through them. Rituals have been historically cheap, and most shop owners don’t take the time and effort to sort thousands of bulk commons to pick out cards like rituals if they jump in price .75 cents or so. There’s a decent chance you can find some in the .25 box in your local shop.
MNEzia on Myra the Magnificent V2
2 weeks ago
I'm retiring this build! Check out version 3! I'm leaving this one up as sort of an "Unmodified Precon" for Myra. Feel free to leave comments, questions, and suggestions for Myra, and check out my userpage for the updated version!
DrummerGarrett on Gürt's Krenko Commander
2 weeks ago
Consider replacing Arms Dealer with a mana rock like Fire Diamond, a Red Cycle Land, or just another Mountain.
Flarhoon13 on Unleashing the Maelstrom: Yidris' Controlled …
2 weeks ago
Nov 23
Yidris: Controlled Chaos, budget power won a long, kind of crazy game. Darryl cast Jokulhaups via Discord, Lord of Disharmony, which looked like it was handing Nolan the game, since he was able to make his Rakdos, the Muscle commander indestructible. I drew well and cast the greatest thief in the multiverse, Dack Fayden, to steal Darryl's Sol Ring. I cast an Aetherflux Reservoir, and a Sunbird's Invocation. The next turn, I cast a Berserkers' Onslaught, Sunbird's Invocation revealed an Inevitable Betrayal, which I used to get Nolan's Molten Primordial. That stole the Rakdos, the Muscle, a Professional Face-Breaker and an OG Jodah, Archmage Eternal. I attacked Nolan with his own commander and Darryl's Tainted Strike made it lethal, even as I attacked him with Jodah, Archmage Eternal, also for lethal (he was at three life). Doug had enough on board to kill me but I untapped and played Karn's Temporal Sundering, bouncing my Dualcaster Mage. In my extra turn, I had the Dark Petition to grab Ghostly Flicker. Ghostly Flicker copied by Dualcaster Mage does go infinite. Infinite mana, then Seasons Past meant I was totally infinite. I could recur the Dark Petition for Seasons Past and cast them infinitely plus so many more, Aetherflux Reservoir was a win condition
Flarhoon13 on Game of Thrones: Sylvia Brightspear's …
2 weeks ago
Nov 9 and 16
Game of Thrones: Khorvath and Sylvia Brightspear's other Dragons lost one game before finally pulling one out. Jesse's boardwipe inadvertently assisted me--Supreme Verdict? thanks to my Boros Charm. Will killed Kelsey on Orzhov Aristocrats, then my Magmaquake took out Kestia, the Cultivator
in response to an aura being cast. Sunforger got Return to Dust, which took out his Sphere of Safety plus another copy. Quicksilver Amulet, with me on six lands, allowed Utvara Hellkite to make 3 other 6/6 dragon tokens and then finally another 6 on the final turn with me on six lands
Eloniel on Nobody has the intention of …
2 weeks ago
Indeed but I removed Guardian of Meletis a long time ago. We have better walls for 3 manas. The surveil ability is nice, if the wall was a 0/7 it would be an instant addition. At 0/6 it's debatable.
Flarhoon13 on Hey Macleod, Get offa my …
2 weeks ago
Nov 9 and 16 Hey Macleod, Get offa my ewe! (Angus Mackenzie) lost a couple games. Kutzil, Malamet Exemplar stopped my plans to cast Rout on Jinnie Fay, Jetmir's Second's turn. That misplay killed me--i could have cast Rout on Jesse's turn--but my mistake certainly improved Will's mood as his cats clawed us to death.
Flarhoon13 on Blim's Blumpkins
2 weeks ago
Nov 9 and 16 Blim's Blumpkins lost again, once or twice, I am thinking.
Flarhoon13 on Atraxa's Dicebag of Holding (Need …
2 weeks ago
Nov 2 Atraxa's Dicebag of Holding lost to Rich's Zevlor, Elturel Exile. I had 28 counters on a Champion of Lambholt but two castings of Do or Die from Rich slowed me down enough for him to pull out Professor Onyx with the Chain of Smog for the win. I killed Matt on Sultai Gonti, Canny Acquisitor
Flarhoon13 on Daxos the Returned
2 weeks ago
Nov 2 Victor, Valgavoth's Seneschal lost again. Jared on Abomination of Llanowar elfballed and was the threat, rebuilding well after my Wrath of God. However, Matt on Eowyn, Shieldmaiden had a sick Taunt from the Rampart hidden away by Windbrisk Heights for an amazing endgame combat trick. The unblockable goading was enough for him to mop us up in two turn cycles.
Flarhoon13 on Admiral Beckett Brass' High Seas …
2 weeks ago
Nov 2 Admiral Beckett Brass's High Seas Robberies finally won a pretty dominant game. Stole a Circle of Dreams Druid from Jared, who was playing Abomination of Llanowar. Port Razer and Cosmotronic Wave the turn after made for an absolutely devastating combat.
Flarhoon13 on Kruphix's Fantastic Elastic Mighty Morphin …
2 weeks ago
Kingdoms https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=https://www.reddit.com/r/EDH/comments/1plyyj/kingdoms_edh_variant/&ved=2ahUKEwjT3siVo_eJAxVCITQIHQsTK6EQjjh6BAgKEAE&usg=AOvVaw3uTb4zf9LStSG6szZMXZGq
Flarhoon13 on Kruphix's Fantastic Elastic Mighty Morphin …
2 weeks ago
Nov 1 Kruphix's Fantastic Elastic Mighty Morphin Machine won a 5 player custom game. It was pretty much a shutout. Kurtis on Alania, Divergent Storm was the knight and I the King. We dominated. He kept gifting me and Kruphix got Seedborn Muse. We shut them down. I was able to get infinite mana and card draw, drawing Rob out with Blue Sun's Zenith. Rob was about to control me during my combat. Kurtis had eliminated the other two players.
Flarhoon13 on Kaervek the Merciless, Vampires & …
2 weeks ago
Nov 1 Kaervek the Merciless, Vampires & Doomsday Demons (0-3) won with the Worldgorger Dragon combo with Dance of the Dead and Jagged Barrens. Some controversy as Josh tapped out on his turn then realized a couple turns later that he could have used one less land with his Sapphire Medallion in play and disrupted my combo with the March of Swirling Mist he had in hand.
